Video

What happends if you Tigered the Queen Elizabeth Class?

Study What happends if you Tigered the Queen Elizabeth Class?, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 3 Oct 2026, with 51 time notes. Topics include Alternate History, Battle Of Jutland, Fast Battleships.

Date
Runtime1:29:58
Guide points51 time notes

Time notes

  1. 0:00
    Tiger and Queen Elizabeth approaching the fast battleship

    Tiger's size and protection provide the starting point for a hypothetical Queen Elizabeth built around a battlecruiser hull.

    Chapter
  2. 1:48
    Overlapping programmes and different trial requirements

    Queen Elizabeth was launched before Tiger but needed longer trials for her fire control and new 15-inch guns.

    Notable Point
  3. 3:11
    Heavier battlecruisers and faster battleships

    Two British design paths address the danger posed by enemy battlecruisers to the fleet's leading ships.

    Notable Point
  4. 4:27
    Why cruiser support called for 28 knots

    A 28-knot reconnaissance line needs fast-battleship support ahead of a battle line accelerating to about 21 knots.

    Chapter
  5. 6:27
    Why 24 knots still gave Queen Elizabeth tactical value

    Queen Elizabeth's speed fell short of the stated aim but still offered an advantage over a 21-knot battle line.

    Notable Point
  6. 7:53
    Interpreting the disputed Super Lion connection

    The Super Lion idea raises a question about which contemporary fast-ship project Fisher and Churchill had in mind.

    Notable Point
  7. 9:00
    Pink Lists as dated snapshots of naval readiness

    Pink Lists help locate ships and assess their condition, provided their date and reporting limits remain clear.

    Notable Point
  8. 10:34
    Why ship-design folders can mix several projects

    Mixed folders, meetings and recollections make a design label such as Super Lion difficult to trace.

    Notable Point
  9. 12:20
    The uncertain claim of a Tiger sister named Leopard

    Singular Super Lion wording supports a tentative Tiger connection, while the claimed Leopard sister remains uncorroborated.

    Notable Point
  10. 14:33
    British and German battlecruiser roles

    Different expectations of battle-line support help explain why Britain needed a tougher battlecruiser in Tiger.

    Chapter
  11. 17:32
    Tiger's belts and the distribution of hull weight

    Tiger's armour layout shows how a heavily protected battlecruiser still differed from a battleship.

    Notable Point
  12. 19:12
    Queen Elizabeth's deeper belts and selective protection

    Queen Elizabeth's lower belt nearly matches Tiger's main belt, while selective coverage points toward a different armour philosophy.

    Notable Point
  13. 21:03
    Hull shape trades speed against gun stability and manoeuvrability

    Tiger's sleeker hull and Queen Elizabeth's fuller form reflect different priorities in speed, gunfire and turning.

    Notable Point
  14. 21:53
    Construction volume allowed separate specialized hulls

    Britain's construction throughput and large fleet made separate battleship and battlecruiser designs affordable.

    Notable Point
  15. 25:02
    A common Scharnhorst hull in a diesel-fleet scenario

    Repeating a Scharnhorst hull in a diesel-fleet scenario could reduce delays from enlarging German shipyards.

    Notable Point
  16. 26:37
    French intervention and the Anglo-Japanese alliance

    French entry into a hypothetical Russo-Japanese War would widen the conflict through the Anglo-Japanese alliance.

    Notable Point
  17. 28:38
    A rough three-month delay for the Tiger-based design

    Using Tiger as the basis requires waiting longer for its design, with roughly thirteen weeks adopted for the scenario.

    Chapter
  18. 29:50
    Tiger's dimensions and machinery baseline

    Tiger's 39-boiler installation supplies a baseline for judging the proposed battleship's power and space requirements.

    Notable Point
  19. 31:07
    Why boiler count does not directly determine horsepower

    Steam quantity, pressure and turbine efficiency interact, limiting simple comparisons between boiler numbers.

    Notable Point
  20. 33:03
    Queen Elizabeth's boiler and turbine combinations

    Different boiler and turbine combinations help explain why twenty-four boilers could support a high power target.

    Chapter
  21. 35:46
    An unpublished hypothesis about Warspite's steam surges

    An unpublished naval engineer's hypothesis links Warspite's performance differences to uneven boiler settings and steam surges.

    Notable Point
  22. 37:36
    Lion and Iron Duke as machinery comparisons

    Earlier battlecruiser and battleship installations show how rapidly machinery options were changing.

    Notable Point
  23. 39:56
    Higher steam pressure and turbine blade efficiency

    The machinery estimate treats a rise from 235 to 265 psi as a roughly thirteen-percent power boost, with turbine blade design offering another efficiency gain.

    Notable Point
  24. 41:29
    Hull proportions and the yards that could build them

    Length-to-beam ratios explain the proposed gain in speed efficiency and its compatibility with existing yards.

    Notable Point
  25. 43:05
    Battleship armour constrains boiler-room space

    Supporting heavier armour requires framing and subdivision that prevent a direct copy of Tiger's five boiler rooms.

    Notable Point
  26. 44:23
    Thirty-two boilers and Parsons turbines

    The proposed machinery combines four rooms of eight Yarrow boilers with Parsons turbines and an estimated 80,000-85,000 shaft horsepower.

    Notable Point
  27. 45:43
    A provisional armour and turret arrangement

    The longer ship could retain heavy belts and two funnels while changing the position of an aft turret.

    Notable Point
  28. 46:34
    Could extra time help the longer 15-inch gun?

    Three extra months might help the 15-inch/45 programme, although a major change in gun development remains doubtful.

    Notable Point
  29. 47:50
    Keeping battleship beam on Tiger's longer hull

    The proposed ship retains at least 28 metres of beam for its 15-inch guns while adopting Tiger's approximate length.

    Notable Point
  30. 48:42
    Delayed entry, Gallipoli and Jutland availability

    The assumed delay could keep Queen Elizabeth away from Gallipoli while leaving four sisters available for Jutland.

    Chapter
  31. 49:38
    The unresolved design of the proposed sixth Queen Elizabeth

    The unbuilt Agincourt raises competing possibilities: a distinctive six-gun fast battleship or another ship of the common class design.

    Notable Point
  32. 51:10
    Why the estimate rounds up to 30,000 tons

    Repeated weight estimates produce figures below 30,000 tons, with an added margin for potentially missed items.

    Notable Point
  33. 53:05
    Higher speed with battleship-like acceleration

    Higher-pressure boilers and a finer hull offer greater speed, while added weight leaves the ship with battleship-like acceleration.

    Notable Point
  34. 55:08
    Fuel load, full displacement and Suez access

    The 30,000-ton estimate excludes fuel and water, which could bring full load to roughly 37,000-38,000 tons.

    Notable Point
  35. 1:03:32
    The proposed 28-knot speed remains uncertain

    The final design assessment leaves top speed and some turret, mast and fire-control positions provisional.

    Notable Point
  36. 1:05:38
    Making the German naval race financially unsustainable

    A major British capability increase could intensify the budget pressure between Germany's navy and army.

    Notable Point
  37. 1:07:04
    American standard battleships facing a faster opponent

    British battleships making 27-28 knots would challenge American standardization around a 21-knot battle line.

    Chapter
  38. 1:08:47
    Changing bearing and range with superior speed

    A faster force can complicate gunnery by changing its bearing and range, even when a complete encirclement is impractical.

    Notable Point
  39. 1:09:36
    A speculative building pause and delayed First World War

    A second Dreadnought-like design shock could prompt reassessment, with a further speculative effect on readiness for war.

    Notable Point
  40. 1:11:46
    Keeping Agincourt within the fast Queen Elizabeth design

    A sixth fast Queen Elizabeth could take priority over a special Agincourt carrying six 18-inch guns.

    Notable Point
  41. 1:12:21
    A cheaper R class that preserves speed

    Three triple turrets offer a possible way to reduce cost while keeping a fast battle line.

    Chapter
  42. 1:14:56
    Italian fast-battleship ambitions and British throughput

    British production volume could turn the design advantage into completed ships before rival programmes.

    Notable Point
  43. 1:16:32
    Fast Queen Elizabeths in Jutland's run to the south

    Faster battleships could join the front of the action, adding heavy firepower and protected targets to the British force.

    Chapter
  44. 1:17:41
    A damaged scouting force could change Scheer's decision

    Severe damage to the German scouting force could encourage withdrawal, while British speed makes a pursuit hazardous.

    Notable Point
  45. 1:19:25
    Competing demands on fast battleships and gunnery training

    Ships well suited to protecting the Grand Fleet could become difficult to retain there when the battlecruiser force needs reinforcement.

    Notable Point
  46. 1:20:30
    Fast battleships weaken the case for battlecruiser successors

    An established fast battle line could limit Fisher's arguments for replacing battleships with battlecruisers.

    Notable Point
  47. 1:21:38
    A twelve-gun fast battleship successor

    The triple-turret branch leads to an imagined successor with twelve 15-inch guns, about 45,000 tons and 28-30 knots.

    Notable Point
  48. 1:22:35
    A fast battle line changes treaty bargaining

    Four 45,000-ton fast battleships would make a 35,000-ton limit harder to negotiate than a single exceptional Hood.

    Chapter
  49. 1:24:25
    Would Amagi and Lexington still be battlecruisers?

    An earlier British fast-battleship line raises uncertainty about the form of later Japanese and American ships.

    Notable Point
  50. 1:25:01
    Eight or nine 16.5-inch guns in the successor class

    Larger-gun branches preserve the proposed speed and protection while increasing pressure on rival designs.

    Notable Point
  51. 1:26:23
    Why Tiger and Queen Elizabeth remained separate designs

    Construction urgency and separate design discussions help explain why Tiger's hull was never combined with Queen Elizabeth's attributes.

    Notable Point