Video
Key Frigates of Today & Tomorrow 2: T54, Istanbul & Gorshkov vs Thaon di Revel, Tamandare & Chungnam
Study Key Frigates of Today & Tomorrow 2: T54, Istanbul & Gorshkov vs Thaon di Revel, Tamandare & Chungnam, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 18 Sept 2026, with 43 time notes. Topics include Admiral Gorshkov Class Frigates…
Time notes
- 4:20Why the Type 054 family developed incrementallyChapter
The Type 054, 054A and 054B reflect a steady Chinese frigate program shaped by anti-submarine and presence missions.
- 5:30The Type 054's diesel propulsion tradeoffNotable Point
Combined diesel and diesel machinery is weighed against acoustic demands and the range needed for Chinese patrols.
- 7:25Pakistan's Type 054 purchase and the Chinese equipment ecosystemNotable Point
Pakistan's move from Type 053 to Type 054 ships illustrates the equipment ties that come with a frigate purchase.
- 8:28What a long Type 054 production run buysNotable Point
Repeated Type 054 construction reduces unit cost and trains shipyard workers while building on the Type 053.
- 10:26Type 054 missile cells and a balanced weapons fitNotable Point
The stated 32-cell and 48-cell Type 054 fits lead into a personal preference for larger frigate magazines.
- 12:22Close-in defenses on the Type 054Notable Point
HHQ-10 and HPJ-11 address close-in defense problems comparable to those of RAM and Goalkeeper.
- 14:07Type 054B range, helicopter and presence roleNotable Point
The Type 054B's stated range, size and Z-20 helicopter are tied to a less provocative presence mission.
- 15:21How Type 054 frigates may support layered task groupsNotable Point
A possible larger Type 054 is placed within a forecast of longer-range, layered task-group operations.
- 16:19The Istanbul class and Turkey's shipbuilding capacityChapter
Turkey's coastal operating areas favor numerous relatively compact frigates, while construction across three Turkish yards expands domestic capacity.
- 18:54Istanbul's 76 mm gun and close-in defensesNotable Point
The first ship's imported 76 mm gun gives way to a Turkish-built weapon, alongside 25 mm and 35 mm defenses.
- 21:37Istanbul's 16 air-defense cellsNotable Point
A 16-cell air-defense magazine draws criticism despite quad-packed missiles and a strong anti-ship fit.
- 24:15Why land-based fighter cover can leave gapsNotable Point
Aircraft must leave station to rearm, making a frigate's own air-defense magazine relevant near friendly airbases.
- 25:00Istanbul's missile loadout tradeoffsNotable Point
A proposed 32-cell Istanbul would combine longer-range missiles with more quad-packed rounds than the existing 16-cell arrangement.
- 25:21Istanbul's sensors, helicopters and UAVsNotable Point
Seahawks, UAVs and electronic systems accompany Istanbul's weapons, putting the magazine-depth criticism in context.
- 27:17Istanbul's range and Turkish combat systemsNotable Point
The stated cruise range sits alongside Turkish radar, fire-control and combat-management work.
- 29:06Why Russia built the Gorshkov frigatesChapter
Project 22350 takes on presence functions as older Russian surface combatants age.
- 30:34Project 22350 cells and gas-turbine delaysNotable Point
The stated 16 strike and 32 air-defense cells sit beside a construction history disrupted by turbine supply.
- 33:19Gorshkov strike and air-defense missile optionsNotable Point
Oniks, Kalibr and Zircon provide strike options, while S-350-based air defense demands respect from opponents.
- 34:31Russian missile development and the loss of technical continuityNotable Point
Economic disruption and gaps in engineer training help explain the long path from late Cold War studies to service entry in 2019.
- 37:07Gorshkov's ASW fit and proposed enlarged variantsNotable Point
Helicopter and towed sonar give the existing frigate an ASW role; far larger missile fits belong to proposals.
- 39:26Gorshkov and the move from test beds to a ship classNotable Point
The distinction between isolated experimental ships and a production class shapes the assessment of Gorshkov's stealth features.
- 40:23Gorshkov port visits and naval presenceNotable Point
Port visits give the frigate a visible diplomatic role alongside its combat tasks.
- 43:36Why frigate specifications need a mission contextChapter
ASW work, self-defense and national missions matter more here than a simple ranking of frigate specifications.
- 44:24Why frigate propulsion choices differ between naviesNotable Point
Patrol endurance, industrial ambitions and comparisons with allies produce different machinery priorities.
- 49:11Frigate, light frigate and OPV design prioritiesNotable Point
A role-based distinction separates ASW-led frigates, presence-oriented light frigates and lower-threat OPVs.
- 51:04Why the Italian PPA is treated as a light frigateChapter
Italy's PPA designation is compared with the Thaon di Revel class's size, propulsion and light-frigate role.
- 53:58PPA Full and Light weapon fitsNotable Point
The Full fit carries heavier weapons, while Light variants reserve space for equipment they do not yet carry.
- 56:09PPA modular spaces and the proposed EVONotable Point
Adaptable mission spaces and a proposed 64-cell EVO variant show the PPA family's possible growth.
- 58:43PPA task-group support and patrol presenceNotable Point
Speed, helicopters, boats and towed sonar let the PPA serve patrol routes and supplement a task group.
- 1:02:16The PPA's 127 mm gun and Vulcano ammunitionNotable Point
The Leonardo/Oto Melara 127 mm gun's ammunition choices shape its reach, cost and value beside smaller mounts.
- 1:06:06Building Tamandare frigates in BrazilChapter
Brazil's requirement for domestic construction connects the new frigates to shipyard skills and facilities.
- 1:07:54Tamandare's combat fit and CAMM magazineNotable Point
A roughly 3,500-ton frigate carries Brazilian anti-ship missiles and extensive systems, but only 12 CAMM rounds.
- 1:09:00Planning a frigate for conflicts its navy hopes to avoidNotable Point
Optimistic planning assumptions can underestimate threats that arise during a ship's service life.
- 1:11:58Brazil's Blue Amazon and its new frigatesNotable Point
The scale of Brazil's Blue Amazon helps explain the frigates' patrol and blue-water purpose.
- 1:12:52Missile depth and protection for Brazilian amphibious shipsNotable Point
A hypothetical larger CAMM load raises a conditional question about protecting Brazil's amphibious ships.
- 1:15:58Tamandare's missile capacity and future growthNotable Point
Launch capacity chosen during construction may constrain a Brazilian frigate for decades.
- 1:18:16South Korea's Chungnam frigate lineageChapter
The Chungnam class follows successive Korean frigate programs as domestic shipbuilding capacity develops.
- 1:20:45Chungnam's weapons fit and 16-cell questionNotable Point
The Korean frigate combines a broad weapons and sensor fit with a 16-cell missile magazine.
- 1:24:33What an eight-missile Chungnam headline saysNotable Point
A headline about eight incoming missiles is checked against the article's fuller claim and the ship's 16 physical cells.
- 1:26:43Checking warship claims across reports and languagesNotable Point
Conflicting reports and translations can change how a new ship's specifications appear to readers.
- 1:30:00Comparing naval designs in their own contextNotable Point
Mission, equipment access and industrial capacity are better guides to a design than assumptions about national ingenuity.
- 1:32:45QuestionHow do you see frigate programs developing: more joint programs or more independent projects?AnswerQ&A
Both approaches have a place, with a confident domestic shipbuilding industry making joint development easier.
- 1:34:21QuestionDo you think the number of frigates and navies as a whole will grow?AnswerQ&A
The tentative expectation is growth as governments reconsider earlier assumptions of lasting peace and the risks of feeling weak under pressure.