Notable Point · 2:31 Royal connections brought extra scrutiny, while Battenberg's German name made promotion a recurring political test.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 7:46 Jellicoe was needed with the Grand Fleet, while Beresford's factional record left Battenberg as the practical choice.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 9:55 Furious's two-gun design had poor targeting prospects, while conversion to an aircraft carrier offered a useful role.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 10:55 Battenberg's marriage linked him to Queen Victoria's family, while his relatives' fate in Russia brought difficult family obligations.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 19:04 Battenberg's written approvals followed private debate, so the paperwork alone can conceal how he influenced decisions.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 21:57 Battenberg advanced through professional ability despite objections that followed him from junior rank.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 25:42 Fisher's continued access to Churchill and the Fisher-Beresford feud explain why Battenberg became vulnerable; Fisher's death removes a key pressure point.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 26:11 French names after the Huguenot arrivals are not treated as a close parallel to Battenberg's German name.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 33:43 Battenberg's support for technical education and better fleet training gave him a substantial record in naval readiness.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 35:02 Requests from commanding officers and the appointments of junior contemporaries answered objections to Battenberg's foreign birth.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 36:52 The promise of a possible wartime recall kept Battenberg from outside employment, yet the Navy gave him no command and left him under growing financial strain.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 45:18 Battenberg underestimated the loss of capable staff while factional attacks distracted him from supervising wartime administration.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 47:01 A public cruise could display readiness and reassure France, while a deployment off Germany risked provoking the war.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 51:45 The Coronel counterfactual turns on staff attention: reinforce Cradock rather than disperse scarce cruisers across distant contingencies.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 57:44 Supporting cruisers and command orders complicate the familiar picture of Denmark Strait as a two-ship duel.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 58:31 Containing Goeben required enough battlecruisers to cover the Atlantic route and the possible escape toward the Black Sea.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 59:45 Enemy basing and the available cruiser force determine where an expensive battlecruiser is needed.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Chapter · 1:05:04 Battenberg's existing construction programme points toward completed Revenge-class battleships and an experimental fast Agincourt rather than Fisher's Renown and Repulse battlecruisers.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 1:07:13 American neutrality rules out using the Panama Canal to feed von Spee into a British ambush.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 1:10:03 Existing infrastructure, ideas for employing Tiger, and small-tube boilers made a protected 28-knot battleship a plausible 1914 proposal.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 1:13:30 A speculative six-gun, 28-knot Agincourt could enter service in late 1915 or early 1916 if its assumed construction timetable held.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 1:18:49 Possible improvements to deck and belt protection remain modest by later fast-battleship standards.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 1:21:59 Support for seaplane carriers provides a starting point, while events would determine Battenberg's approach to further carrier construction.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 1:23:40 Cancellation language, boiler-development timing, and the Furious guns support a hypothesis about Agincourt's intended design.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 1:29:04 Intelligence-led procurement might bring Flower-class sloops forward and develop informal bombardment ideas into monitors.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 1:29:43 Once Agincourt establishes the design path, wartime battlecruiser losses make the four Admiral-class ships more likely to become protected 18-inch fast battleships.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 1:31:55 The experimental Agincourt would establish a design line continued by the Admiral class rather than remain a one-off ship.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 1:35:20 German raids on the British coast would reinforce the demand for fast reaction forces while increasing political pressure on Battenberg to adopt the Mountbatten name earlier.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 1:37:49 Submarine ambushes were part of the plan, but early boats struggled to reach a fleeting interception position.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Chapter · 1:38:15 Large Swift-style leaders could screen fast battleships, while smaller destroyers and earlier Flower-class sloops supplied numbers.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 1:45:15 Battenberg used relatives in European royal houses as informal sources on foreign destroyers, cruisers, and naval construction.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 1:47:05 A reported harbour accident gives a concrete example of the weather limits on small torpedo craft.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 1:48:05 If Gallipoli still went ahead, Battenberg's Army relationships and interest in mine countermeasures could support a coordinated assault.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 1:53:28 A possibly apocryphal story has Wilhelm II personally sending Battenberg details of German warships.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 1:55:58 Success removes Churchill's resignation and could make him Lloyd George's rival if Asquith's government still fell.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 1:59:50 Rapid aircraft development makes wartime capability more useful than a fixed 1912 policy for judging carrier construction.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 2:01:16 A different battlecruiser commander could leave damaged Blucher behind, continue the pursuit, and possibly sink Seydlitz with consequences for Hipper and later German damage control.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 2:11:19 Sturdee could have dispersed the force by overthinking enemy escape routes and building successive defensive lines.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 2:14:44 Lion could engage Blucher while the remaining British ships continued after the German battlecruisers.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 2:15:44 Overseas presence duties would require the proposed fast battleships to include an admiral's accommodation.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 2:15:58 Starting with fast battleships could avoid redesign delays and leave five large 18-inch-gunned ships in service before naval treaty negotiations.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Chapter · 2:17:00 The Jutland branch rests on whether a better-informed Admiralty keeps the battlecruisers, fast battleships, Harwich Force, and Grand Fleet working to one plan.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 2:22:23 The speculative fast Agincourt offers Jellicoe a ship he helped shape and the speed to move ahead of the Grand Fleet.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 2:23:51 A surface-fleet raid through German minefields makes little sense when blockade and aircraft could apply pressure at lower risk.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 2:25:15 Hipper surviving as a British prisoner would still leave Scheer without his battlecruiser commander.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 2:27:19 Better British information and a more aggressive pursuit could force the High Seas Fleet to abandon slow pre-dreadnoughts and perhaps its battlecruisers to save the modern battle line.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Q&A · 2:29:31 Cradock might redirect battlecruiser gunnery practices without completely reversing the existing culture.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024
Notable Point · 2:31:52 Earlier sloops and an anti-submarine inquiry precede a possible handover to Jellicoe in late 1916 and a research role for Battenberg.
From Patreon 101: If Lord Fisher died in Jan 1914, how does Prince Louis of Battenberg perform as 1SL? · 12 Apr 2024