A faster Tiger would push later battlecruisers harder
A 30- or 32-knot Tiger would pressure later battlecruisers to become faster and widen the competition over speed.
From The 18in Gun HMS Agincourt and UAD video comment response (Long Patrol) ·
Complete directory
Browse all time notes.
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
Recreating historical ships without exact templates
UAD lets players build ships from components rather than supplying exact historical templates, which is enough to explore many design choices without reproducing every fitting.
From The 18in Gun HMS Agincourt and UAD video comment response (Long Patrol) ·
Both fleets wanted battle on favourable numerical terms
Germany wanted local superiority against an isolated British formation, while Britain wanted its larger fleet concentrated against the enemy.
From The 18in Gun HMS Agincourt and UAD video comment response (Long Patrol) ·
Why early torpedoes could not stop a crossing-the-T manoeuvre
Early dreadnought-era torpedoes lacked the range to serve as a practical answer to an opponent crossing the T.
From The 18in Gun HMS Agincourt and UAD video comment response (Long Patrol) ·
All-forward layouts can simplify hull design
Concentrating triple turrets forward can let designers organise the hull efficiently around known machinery, magazine, and armament zones.
From The 18in Gun HMS Agincourt and UAD video comment response (Long Patrol) ·
Command succession after a flagship is lost
After Hibernia sinks, the simulation leaves the chain of command and the successor flagship unclear.
From The 18in Gun HMS Agincourt and UAD video comment response (Long Patrol) ·
All-forward armament and the pursuit manoeuvre
An all-forward battery can let a ship turn onto an enemy's stern while keeping its own guns bearing, but it also creates firing-arc limits and vulnerable blind spots.
From The 18in Gun HMS Agincourt and UAD video comment response (Long Patrol) ·
Internal and deck-mounted capital-ship torpedoes
Replacing an internal torpedo chamber with deck mountings recovers hull space but leaves exposed explosives that require careful siting and protection.
From The 18in Gun HMS Agincourt and UAD video comment response (Long Patrol) ·
Why a 1939 war would not follow the 1941 script
The opening premise is that Japanese naval doctrine changed markedly between 1939 and the Pacific War of 1941-45.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
What use would Vittorio Veneto be to the Royal Navy?
An opening side question asks how Britain could employ an Italian battleship made available to its fleet.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Would British motor boats deploy to Singapore?
A viewer asks whether war in 1939 would send the Royal Navy's small fast attack craft to the Pacific instead of the Channel.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Could Yonai prevent war by prosecuting the officers?
A proposed face-saving prosecution runs into the factional and institutional structure of the Japanese state.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Would war in the Pacific come before war in Europe?
The counterfactual reverses the historical sequence by beginning with an eastern coalition war before a European conflict.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Could Tiger or Blake have helped in the Falklands?
A side question considers the command and fire-support value of reactivating the Tiger-class cruisers in 1982.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Would a reactivated Tiger class shape postwar designs?
The follow-up asks whether wartime use of a large command cruiser would create demand for a successor.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Did Japan have an admiral like Beresford?
Prince Fushimi is offered as an imperfect Japanese comparison for a status-protected and politically disruptive senior admiral.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Reserve cruisers would release modern ships for Asia
Older cruisers on secondary stations could free modern ships for the main coalition fleet in the Far East.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Fushimi, Yonai, and the factions behind Japanese doctrine
The navy of early 1939 was shaped by a struggle between status-conscious expansionists and pragmatic modernizers.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Did Japan have a naval reformer like Fisher?
Mitsumasa Yonai is presented as Japan's Fisher-like modernizer, with strong strategic judgment but less freedom to reshape the navy.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Were IJN leaders trained in Japan or overseas?
A viewer asks whether Japan's admirals were products of foreign schools or domestic naval institutions.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Could Japan afford the 10:10:7 treaty ratio?
The desired treaty ratio was financially possible only by changing the balance of the Japanese fleet.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Mitsumasa Yonai's case for infrastructure over prestige ships
Yonai's strategic objection to war centered on Japan's fuel, shipyard, dry-dock, and internal-transport weaknesses.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Yoshida made synthetic fuel a test of the Tripartite Pact
Fuel technology offered a concrete measure of whether alliance with Germany would improve Japan's ability to sustain a war.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Which infrastructure did Yonai think Japan lacked?
The direct answer names the industrial and transport bottlenecks that made Japan's fleet strength difficult to sustain.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Are there English-language sources on Yonai?
The source discussion identifies a major language and access gap in the study of Yonai's career and ideas.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
How would early Yamatos change Allied battleship design?
Allied reaction depends on when the Yamato class becomes known and how accurately its armament is understood.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Yonai-era reform reshapes Japanese naval aviation
A January 1939 war begins while aviation doctrine is still evolving and reform-minded officers retain influence over mobilization.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
How long would synthetic-fuel plants take to build?
Prewar synthetic-fuel advocacy becomes a concrete mobilization timeline and a limited buffer against an oil cutoff.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Kantai Kessen meets British and American bases
The decisive-battle doctrine assumed an exhausted enemy approach that Britain and the United States could avoid through forward basing.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Treaty parity hid Britain's larger ready fleet
Equal treaty allowances did not mean Britain and the United States could place equal numbers of ships in service in early 1939.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Big ships, big guns, and the insecurity of treaty limits
Japanese faith in large, heavily armed ships made numerical and tonnage restrictions feel like permanent strategic inferiority.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Could more realistic treaty limits reduce conflict?
A viewer asks whether attainable ship limits could reduce cheating, mistrust, and the insecurity produced by the treaty system.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Japan's layered attrition and ambush doctrine
The more applicable late-1930s concept used submarines, aircraft, and night attacks to wear down an approaching fleet.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
A Pacific-first war redirects fighters and radar to the fleet
With the Royal Navy leading the war, carrier fighters and tactical shipboard radar would compete successfully for national resources.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Why not attack British and American trade first?
A viewer asks why Japan would not prioritize commerce destruction before confronting the enemy fleets.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Two navies prepared for night fighting
A 1939 Anglo-Japanese war could pit two highly developed but different night-fighting systems against one another.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
What fleet would Britain send to the Far East?
The likely reinforcement combines fast capital ships, a strike carrier group, fleet-defense aircraft, and accelerated radar development.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
How would 25 mm fire affect a Swordfish?
The Swordfish's fabric covering complicates how explosive shells interact with the aircraft without making it immune to hits.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
What would France contribute to the coalition?
France would mobilize broadly, while coalition strategy sends modern units east and uses older ships nearer Europe.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Would the United States and other powers join Britain?
Strategic influence, public opinion, and the peace settlement all give the United States strong reasons to enter an anti-Japanese coalition.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
A no-win war and the paradox of Japanese risk
Senior officers could expect defeat yet still choose war, creating tension between existential rhetoric and conservative fleet handling.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Tsingtao: a confrontation at point-blank range
The historical incident put HMS Birmingham and Japanese cruisers in an unusually dangerous armed standoff.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Tsingtao's command breakdown made diplomacy dangerous
British officials without radio contact still coordinated more effectively than Japanese customs and naval authorities who could communicate.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
What the first salvos at Tsingtao might have done
At ranges down to roughly 400 yards, even a doomed British force could inflict severe mission damage before being overwhelmed.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Why did Britain later strip forces from Malaya?
The contrast between 1939 and 1941 reflects Britain's limited resources and the priority imposed by war in Europe.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Britain's likely answer: Singapore, sea control, and blockade
The proposed British approach builds at Singapore, protects the South China Sea, and progressively cuts Japan off from trade and fuel.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
A Far Eastern war keeps carriers and capital ships building
Fighting Japan first would reverse Britain's historical decision to prioritize escorts for the European submarine threat.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·
Cunningham and the first fleet to Singapore
The likely opening reinforcement combines an experienced fleet commander, carriers, modernized battleships, and later Anglo-American concentration.
From Patreon 48: Anglo-Japanese War in Feb 39 - if Tsingtao Incident goes "hot", what's IJN doctrine? ·