Video
Bruships 35: Personal Wars + a New Book from Pen & Sword
Study Bruships 35: Personal Wars + a New Book from Pen & Sword, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 31 Jan 2021, with 62 time notes. Topics include Book Reviews, Falklands War, Fleet Air Arm.
Time notes
- 5:56QuestionHow might a confrontation develop after China authorized force at sea and the United States sent coast guard vessels to the South China Sea?AnswerQ&A
Cutters could make a Chinese armed response look disproportionate, but their size and uncertain suitability for ramming leave them vulnerable in close encounters with larger coast guard vessels.
- 7:39US-China competition and the loss of long-term planningNotable Point
An immediate US-China war is considered unlikely in January 2021, while China's greater attention to long-term planning is treated as a strategic advantage.
- 9:08A defense buildup can stimulate technology without requiring a warNotable Point
The Reagan-era defense buildup is presented as an example of economic stimulus and technological development that did not require a new war.
- 10:09A Mediterranean naval-history survey through decisive battlesChapter
Quentin Russell's survey links major Mediterranean battles across two millennia, with room for additional coverage of Venetian-Ottoman warfare and the First World War Adriatic.
- 13:05Ice strengthening gives the Harry DeWolf class unusual collision resilienceNotable Point
The Harry DeWolf class's ice-strengthened hull could be an advantage in confrontations involving ramming, despite criticism of its modest gun.
- 14:50Navarino and naval intervention for Greek independenceChapter
An allied fleet approached Navarino ready for action while Greek independence still depended on foreign assistance and recognition.
- 18:08Greek sailors and fireships delayed Ottoman-Egyptian reconquestChapter
Greek sailors and fireships disrupted an Ottoman-Egyptian plan to recover the islands and squeeze the Peloponnese from land and sea.
- 21:24Public pressure and great-power rivalry led to intervention at NavarinoChapter
The Greek revolt's military crisis, public sympathy abroad, and rivalry among the great powers led to the 1827 Treaty of London.
- 25:04QuestionWhy did Stephen Harper not rename the service the Royal Canadian Coast Guard?AnswerQ&A
A proposed historical explanation is that avoiding the royal title helped keep Canadian fishery-protection vessels available locally instead of making them liable for Royal Navy service elsewhere.
- 26:40Vietnamese pilots taught Soviet advisers how to fight American aircraftNotable Point
Vietnamese pilots' combat experience helped Soviet advisers learn how to use their aircraft against American opponents.
- 34:2142 Commando's difficult move to Mount KentChapter
A reading from March to the South Atlantic shows how helicopter shortages, darkness, fatigue, and improvised command arrangements shaped 42 Commando's move to Mount Kent.
- 35:24Getting fire support and Blowpipe missiles onto Mount KentNotable Point
The Mount Kent plan coordinated infantry, artillery, mortars, and air defense around helicopter availability and terrain that made heavy missile loads impractical at night.
- 36:39Norway-focused planning left a Falklands helicopter-control gapNotable Point
Plans to use Norwegian infrastructure had reduced the independent helicopter-control capacity needed for an operation in the Falklands.
- 41:28Matching helicopter loads to the force needed on Mount KentNotable Point
The second Mount Kent attempt depended on loads that delivered a usable fighting force, specialist movement control, and staff intervention to retain scarce helicopters.
- 44:32Max Hastings talked his way onto the Mount Kent liftChapter
In Nick Vaux's account, Max Hastings secured a helicopter place without the authorization he claimed and later carried a Blowpipe missile toward K Company.
- 49:12QuestionDoes March to the South Atlantic cover all operations in the Falklands, and does it have photographs and maps?AnswerQ&A
It covers 42 Commando's extensive experience and includes good maps and photographs taken at the time, so its coverage follows the unit's part in the campaign.
- 50:26Canberra reported a combat landing as passengers deliveredNotable Point
A terse P&O message turned Canberra's delivery of troops into San Carlos Water into an understated passenger-service report.
- 58:14Warrior route clearance and extraction during Operation PimlicoChapter
A Warrior platoon checks a route for roadside bombs before collecting troops under fire during an arrest operation in Al-Amarah.
- 1:08:32Jeremy Bowen's account of reporting from GroznyChapter
A BBC crew drives an armored Land Rover through shelled Grozny to find a vantage point near the parliament district.
- 1:13:27Jeremy Bowen's moments of terror amid sustained dangerNotable Point
Continuous danger did not produce continuous fear for Bowen, who remembers brief episodes of terror amid periods when he could work calmly.
- 1:14:08Why Bowen's crew remained in exposed Minutka SquareNotable Point
Collecting a stranded cameraman and his footage kept the BBC crew in a square that also served as an assembly point for Chechen fighters.
- 1:16:14A destroyed bridge prompted an improvised river crossingNotable Point
Damage to a bridge disrupted the route into Grozny, and the crew chose an improvised river crossing in its armored Land Rover.
- 1:17:43A BBC crew survives an airstrike in Minutka SquareChapter
An airstrike kills a Chechen fighter and damages the BBC crew's armored vehicle; the crew later infers from its recording that cluster bombs were used.
- 1:23:12When embedded journalists had the better communications gearNotable Point
An Afghanistan satellite-phone anecdote prompts a disagreement over soldiers borrowing journalists' vehicles and the risks to the press.
- 1:27:09Harry Patch remembers the advance at PasschendaeleChapter
Harry Patch remembers a precarious pontoon crossing, taped assembly positions, and the limited view of an infantryman at Passchendaele.
- 1:31:00A German relief complicated the defense of LangemarckNotable Point
A relief in progress contributed to confused German resistance, while a surviving pillbox and approaching prisoners complicated the British advance.
- 1:31:45Patch could not stop for the wounded during the advanceChapter
Orders to keep advancing and responsibility for the Lewis gun left Patch unable to help or identify many of the casualties he passed.
- 1:32:37The DCLI advanced by stages behind the creeping barrageNotable Point
Shell holes disrupted formations, but successive objectives and timed artillery lifts organized the advance, with pigeons carrying confirmation to headquarters.
- 1:36:18Patch tried to spare a German attackerChapter
Harry Patch recalled choosing three disabling revolver shots while protecting his Lewis gun, then wondering for years what became of the wounded German.
- 1:44:21Seafire operations aboard HMS ImplacableChapter
They Gave Me a Seafire supplies a pilot's view of HMS Implacable's air group, flight-deck hazards, landing practice, and crowded wartime accommodation.
- 1:45:41Seafire carrier landings could wreck aircraftNotable Point
Descriptions of torn landing gear and a barrier crash explain the concern about bringing Seafires back aboard ship.
- 1:48:53Implacable's Norwegian raid and a recovered FireflyNotable Point
The carrier's Norwegian operations combined a reported U-boat sinking with the loss of a Firefly later recovered for a museum.
- 1:50:23Embarking aircraft after the ground crews had already leftNotable Point
Crossley's pilots had to move and start their own aircraft with a single battery trolley before flying out to Implacable.
- 1:52:13Implacable tested degaussing protection against magnetic minesNotable Point
Electrical degaussing reduced Implacable's magnetic signature to protect her against magnetic mines.
- 1:53:11Landing on a carrier that could swing out of the windNotable Point
Harbour landing practice required pilots to watch the ship's heading as well as the batsman's signals.
- 1:54:27Charles Lamb's relationship with Implacable's flight-deck partyNotable Point
Crossley remembered a tough flight-deck party with fierce loyalty to Charles Lamb despite frequent arguments.
- 1:59:13QuestionDo British forces still have batmen or comparable personal attendants?AnswerQ&A
Naval stewards retain a related support role. A carrier batsman is a separate role concerned with guiding aircraft onto the flight deck.
- 2:00:29QuestionWhat are the US Navy Seabees?AnswerQ&A
They are armed naval construction battalions that build bases and infrastructure in expeditionary conditions, often beginning work while a captured area is still dangerous.
- 2:02:55QuestionWhy do senior officers need someone to make sure they eat and sleep?AnswerQ&A
High-intensity operations keep senior officers on the bridge or in the combat information center, so a steward brings food and watches for neglected basic needs.
- 2:07:23QuestionIs the executive officer the third person responsible for looking after the captain?AnswerQ&A
The additional person identified is the ship's senior petty officer. The executive officer's main responsibility is to look after the crew below.
- 2:08:12Knowing what a captain will eat during a busy watchNotable Point
Personal knowledge helps stewards keep captains fed, and a successful working relationship can continue into a later appointment.
- 2:10:41QuestionWho looks after the chief engineer?AnswerQ&A
The executive officer checks on the chief engineer's welfare while the captain makes operational requests.
- 2:11:40QuestionIs a ship simply lucky if it has both a good captain and a good executive officer?AnswerQ&A
The Royal Navy tries to pair officers whose strengths work together, including different strengths in warfare and personnel leadership.
- 2:13:24A steward bartered whisky for food the captain would eatNotable Point
A steward's whisky-for-biscuits exchange supplied food an overworked captain would eat during a Middle East deployment.
- 2:14:40Steward service could become a route to a naval commissionNotable Point
Close work with senior officers could reveal a steward's judgment and produce unusually strong recommendations for officer training.
- 2:17:09QuestionAre there stories of captains returning from deployment weighing more?AnswerQ&A
No example comes to mind; the more familiar observation is surprise that an overworked captain had maintained their weight.
- 2:17:34Stewards protect the critical people who keep a ship functioningNotable Point
Steward support protects senior personnel whose neglected food and welfare can impair the ship's functioning.
- 2:18:58Stewards give captains an informal view of shipboard lifeNotable Point
A trusted steward can alert the captain to misconduct and overlooked good work through contacts throughout the ship.
- 2:25:06The US steward system carried both an operational purpose and a segregation legacyNotable Point
The American steward system's segregation legacy accompanies a separate question about how personal support affects command efficiency.
- 2:26:19Steward support preserves space between the captain and the wardroomNotable Point
The captain's separate dining arrangements give other officers some respite, while defined steward duties reduce ambiguity about personal favors.
- 2:29:35QuestionWhat happened to Dudley North after the Gibraltar controversy?AnswerQ&A
Although cleared of the accusation, North lost the critical window for another major command, and the delay effectively ended the wartime career path he might otherwise have followed.
- 2:30:12Cork and Orrery's investigations cost the Royal Navy usable officersNotable Point
A severe assessment of Cork and Orrery connects his role in Norway with prolonged inquiries that kept capable officers away from useful service.
- 2:32:30Steward support frees a highly trained captain for command workNotable Point
Routine household support frees a highly trained commanding officer to spend more time on work requiring command authority.
- 2:34:33QuestionIf most Royal Navy officers were upper class, is a nanny a better comparison for the captain's steward?AnswerQ&A
The premise is overstated: many officers were middle or upper-middle class, and senior admirals often received their titles for naval service.
- 2:35:26QuestionWhat happens to a steward who is so good at the job that nobody wants to let them do anything else?AnswerQ&A
They can move up with the officer they support, transfer to another officer, or enter officer training with senior recommendations; some also build successful civilian careers.
- 2:38:23QuestionWere there admirals whose careers suffered because they wanted to remain at sea with their crews?AnswerQ&A
Many admirals disliked land postings and sought ways back to sea. Cunningham accepted shore command despite his preference for serving afloat.
- 2:38:52QuestionDid the Soviet Alfa-class submarine really operate with only about thirty people, most of them officers or warrant officers?AnswerQ&A
The quoted reference gives Western estimates of twenty-five to forty-five crew, with a very high proportion of officers and warrant officers and few if any enlisted personnel.
- 2:44:08QuestionDid holding the Queen's commission mark someone as upper-middle or upper class?AnswerQ&A
Historically it carried that association, but officers also came from rating backgrounds; the Royal Navy sometimes exceeded the French Navy's minimum intake from the ranks without using a fixed quota.
- 2:47:35The Alfa class's small crew left an open question about submarine automationNotable Point
The Alfa demonstrated radical crew reduction, while later Soviet and Russian choices leave its wider desirability unresolved.
- 2:48:05QuestionWhich warships, besides Warspite and the Tribals, fought with exceptional aggression when another ship was threatened?AnswerQ&A
Examples include Renown pursuing Scharnhorst and Gneisenau, American destroyers with Taffy 3, and motor torpedo or gun boats in the Pacific and English Channel.
- 2:55:00Why the Second World War favored fast battlecruisersNotable Point
Carrier operations rewarded battlecruiser speed, while hypothetical G3 carriers would have created a stronger modernization case for Hood, Renown, and Repulse.
- 2:57:18A captain's steward could connect Star Trek's command staff and lower decksNotable Point
The real steward's movement across a ship offers a plausible way to connect senior officers and ordinary crew in fiction.