Video
Check Campaign 18: UAD has updated & to Learn it's new ways I started another British Campaign
Study Check Campaign 18: UAD has updated & to Learn it's new ways I started another British Campaign, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 19 May 2024, with 31 time notes. Topics include Battle Of Coronel, Battlecruisers…
Time notes
- 3:47Destroyer and cruiser convoy attackNotable Point
An early convoy action shows destroyers and a cruiser using speed, torpedoes, and gunfire against merchant ships with little escort pressure.
- 20:17Surface raiders need places to repairNotable Point
The convoy victory prompts a comparison between campaign raiders with worldwide repair access and German surface raiders constrained by scarce safe bases.
- 23:02Heavy cruisers withdraw from a battleshipNotable Point
A fight against a 90,000-ton fast battleship becomes a lesson in testing cruiser toughness without accepting an unwinnable slugging match.
- 35:24Designing ships for battles or warsNotable Point
A design aside distinguishes a ship optimized to win each battle from a fleet built to win the wider war.
- 41:50Communism, anarchism, and assumptions about human behaviorNotable Point
A political aside argues that communism and anarchism depend on people assigning enough weight to other people's needs, which makes their theoretical appeal hard to realize in practice.
- 44:23Why battleship rankings hide design tradeoffsNotable Point
A discussion of Iowa and Yamato shows why speed, gun power, classification, treaties, and infrastructure resist a simple best-battleship ranking.
- 48:28QuestionIf Plan Z were completed and India became a dominion before war, could a Royal Indian Navy receive battleships to spread the cost of the imperial battle fleet?AnswerQ&A
Potentially, but only after years of building officers, crews, dockyard capacity, and experience with cruisers, destroyers, and sloops; Australia and perhaps New Zealand or Canada would probably receive capital ships first.
- 51:23Germany's interwar naval development gapNotable Point
A delayed-war counterfactual shows how Germany's long shipbuilding interruption and slower design cycle could leave Plan Z further behind rival navies rather than buying it time to catch up.
- 58:03QuestionWould Germany have alarmed the Allies by moving directly from 11-inch to 16-inch battleship guns, and did Krupp still possess 15-inch tooling?AnswerQ&A
The Anglo-German Naval Agreement permitted 16-inch guns, Britain already operated Nelson and Rodney, and Versailles-era destruction forced Germany to rebuild 15-inch tooling before it could create 16-inch capacity.
- 1:02:31Engineering perfection as a procurement trapNotable Point
A technology-choice aside warns that chasing engineering perfection can keep naval equipment from ever reaching the fleet.
- 1:13:58What HMS Dreadnought might change at CoronelNotable Point
An alternate Battle of Coronel considers whether HMS Dreadnought's presence would deter von Spee or trap his squadron against an opponent it could not outrun.
- 1:18:36Port capacity, personnel, and submarine sea denialNotable Point
A fleet-management pause connects visible port capacity and personnel shortages to construction sequencing and the growing sea-denial effect of submarines.
- 1:32:26Destroyer screens and sensible battery targetsNotable Point
An errant destroyer screen and reversed gun targets expose the difference between fleet roles and the simulation's automatic behavior.
- 1:34:38Long-range guns and the politics of modernizationNotable Point
A one-sided long-range engagement becomes a lesson in why recognizing and funding obsolete naval guns can be as difficult as replacing them.
- 1:40:02Should a sunken magazine still be burning?Notable Point
A fire continuing deep below the waterline prompts a realism check on magazine explosions, flooding, and the condition of a submerged wreck.
- 1:49:38Mine losses depend on what remains at seaNotable Point
French warships suffer mine damage while British merchantmen remain exposed, showing how the traffic each side still operates shapes its loss categories.
- 1:52:53Merchant cruisers and convoy-defense researchNotable Point
A research review prioritizes merchant cruisers and single torpedo launchers for convoy defense while previewing improved destroyer hulls and submarine torpedoes.
- 1:57:13Destroyer and submarine mass buildoutNotable Point
A fleet-management pass weighs whether to finish destroyers or submarines first before moving back to battleship and minelaying-submarine construction.
- 2:04:04Low-fuel destroyers and battle-line focusNotable Point
A late battle uses heavy cruisers and destroyers to isolate a French battleship despite low-fuel escort limitations.
- 2:11:22Cruiser torpedo reserve and a task-group mistakeNotable Point
A failed pursuit shows why heavy cruisers may need reserved torpedoes and why the right supporting ship must be detached at the start of an attack.
- 2:22:46The survivability of a 90,000-ton battleshipNotable Point
A battered French battleship keeps its speed and remains afloat under prolonged fire, prompting a close look at damage, scale, and watertight integrity.
- 2:36:57Plunging fire and the point to abandon shipNotable Point
The final salvos expose the battleship's deck, followed by an argument that a captain should abandon or surrender a ship that can no longer fight.
- 2:41:20Edward Seymour instead of Fisher in 1914Notable Point
An alternate leadership path asks whether Admiral Edward Seymour's seniority could prevent Fisher's 1914 return and change the Royal Navy's response to trade protection and submarines.
- 2:48:12A thousand-submarine fleet goalNotable Point
Another hundred-submarine order reveals a campaign force-structure goal of roughly one thousand boats for global sea denial.
- 2:49:58Modernizing the Revenge II battleshipsNotable Point
A Revenge II redesign balances 16.5-inch main guns, a larger six-inch battery, destroyer defense, speed, range, and weight distribution.
- 2:57:34A complementary 18-inch-gun battleshipNotable Point
A second battleship is designed to complement Jupiter with 18-inch guns, trading rate of fire and weight for heavier shells and different penetration performance.
- 3:10:00Capital-ship weight, armor, and ballast tradeoffsNotable Point
The 18-inch design sheds thousands of tons while preserving armor, secondaries, torpedoes, speed, and stability, exposing the value of a dedicated ballast control.
- 3:21:28A mixed heavy squadron for war with AmericaNotable Point
Four ships of each new battleship design are paired into an 800,000-ton heavy squadron intended for a future war against the United States.
- 3:24:24Mothballing old ships to crew new destroyersNotable Point
Older warships enter mothballs so their crews can commission new destroyers, showing personnel rather than hulls as the binding fleet constraint.
- 3:32:03War Plan Red and the industrial-fleet balanceNotable Point
A campaign comparison tests War Plan Red against population, budgets, ports, tonnage, crews, and the composition of the British and American fleets.
- 3:35:40War Plan Red and two-ocean geographyNotable Point
The American two-ocean problem becomes more severe when Britain surrounds the Panama Canal and controls the Caribbean approaches.