Video
Check Campaign 14: UAD has updated & to Learn it's new ways I started another British Campaign
Study Check Campaign 14: UAD has updated & to Learn it's new ways I started another British Campaign, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 22 Apr 2024, with 21 time notes. Topics include Alternate History, Battleships, Cruisers.
Time notes
- 8:09QuestionHow would World War II have developed differently if Britain began 1939 with twice as many aircraft carriers?AnswerQ&A
Britain would probably distribute carrier risk differently: Courageous and Ark Royal need not share the same anti-submarine mission, Glorious is less isolated, and Taranto can become a multi-carrier strike.
- 12:10QuestionWould a fleet of roughly fifteen 16-inch-gun battleships plus more carriers deter countries from starting wars by making blockade easier?AnswerQ&A
It would make German surface operations much harder, because numerous fast British capital ships and carriers could cover breakout routes and intercept Bismarck- or Scharnhorst-type raiders without relying on the historical pairings.
- 15:48QuestionWhy praise the Dunkerque class but sound less enthusiastic about the Richelieu class?AnswerQ&A
Dunkerque was an innovative ship with a clear specialist role, while Richelieu was a capable but more conventional continuation that did not solve France's treaty-driven need to cover both the Mediterranean and wider imperial commitments.
- 27:43Representation and equal voting rightsNotable Point
A comment about women's suffrage prompts an argument from no taxation or legislation without representation to equal voting rights.
- 32:41Submarine and minelaying research priorityNotable Point
A research-budget check prioritizes electric batteries, torpedo contact exploders, submarine improvements, and minelaying submarines.
- 36:52Grouping fast cruisers for a torpedo attackNotable Point
A battle setup groups 30- to 33-knot ships, assigns destroyers as protection, and saturates a slower opponent with roughly forty torpedoes.
- 51:57Convoy screening and cruiser positioningNotable Point
A convoy attack highlights why an escorting cruiser cannot drift so far from the convoy that an attacker can pass between them.
- 1:01:13QuestionCan an extremely aggressive submarine build carry the campaign when invasions and convoy battles still require surface vessels?AnswerQ&A
Surface forces are still necessary, but enough submarines can deter invasion by making the expected losses to transports and escorts prohibitively high.
- 1:02:49Repairs compete with new constructionNotable Point
Enemy battle damage and a crowded cruiser program show repair work consuming the same finite yard capacity needed for new construction.
- 1:05:44Calabria as a compact protected cruiserNotable Point
The Italian protected cruiser Calabria becomes a compact example of how much mixed armament could be carried on a 2,700-ton colonial-era warship.
- 1:07:25Torpedo range, sensors, and evasionNotable Point
A failed high-speed cruiser pass demonstrates the danger of entering torpedo range without enough warning or room to maneuver.
- 1:13:43QuestionWould ships such as Yamato, Bismarck, or the Royal Navy's N3 have developed the same way if the United States had built Tillman IV-2?AnswerQ&A
Probably not. Britain would likely answer with faster ships carrying fewer but larger guns, potentially twelve 18-inch weapons, instead of copying the American arrangement.
- 1:21:47Tillman's battleships as shipyard politicsNotable Point
The Tillman program is read as a political effort to steer later cruiser work toward Charleston, not simply a fascination with maximum battleship size.
- 1:27:33Industrial logistics for shipbuildingNotable Point
A shipbuilding aside explains how yards, gearboxes, boilers, armor, rail, and coastal shipping shape where warships can be built.
- 1:28:54Choosing a minelaying submarine designNotable Point
A procurement sequence pairs better torpedo detonators with a minelaying submarine chosen for mine load, speed, stealth, and attack value.
- 1:40:52Cruiser screens and destroyer attack groupsNotable Point
A battle deployment separates battleships and heavy cruisers from their screen, then sends destroyers into the attack while cruisers protect the main force.
- 1:46:14Torpedo damage, maneuver, and warning timeNotable Point
A battleship loss prompts a critique of torpedo damage modeling, advice on turning into a spread, and a research choice that buys more warning time.
- 1:55:17QuestionWhat would the United States receive under the Washington settlement if Britain had already put 16.5-inch guns on its capital ships?AnswerQ&A
The treaty ceiling might rise to 16.5-inch guns and roughly 50,000 tons, but the United States would probably keep its established 16-inch system and seek permission to build more ships rather than pay to retool for only half an inch of extra caliber.
- 2:03:17QuestionIf an eight-inch cruiser used its extra tonnage for armor and carried twelve guns, would the six-inch cruiser retain its theoretical advantage?AnswerQ&A
Not necessarily: better protection and a larger battery could reverse the comparison, but Hawkins remained a large light-cruiser baseline rather than a true heavy cruiser.
- 2:07:20Treaty limits and self-escorting capital shipsNotable Point
A treaty-design aside argues that extra displacement could produce better-protected, more self-sufficient capital ships, while arms control deliberately restricted that possibility.
- 2:14:02Imperial scale does not remove fleet constraintsNotable Point
The campaign's enormous empire still trails the United States in GDP and faces crew and shipyard limits despite its population, territory, and thousand-ship fleet.