Notable Point · 4:16:13 Open internal doors worsened flooding, while armour sufficient to resist Rodney's heavy shells would have imposed a large weight penalty high in the ship.
From Günther Lütjens, useful idiot or misunderstood leadership? · 25 May 2023
Notable Point · 4:17:37 Lütjens understood the danger facing his force, but his career had not provided all the experience his final command demanded.
From Günther Lütjens, useful idiot or misunderstood leadership? · 25 May 2023
Notable Point · 4:19:29 An unexpected route west of Ireland under British colours offers a risky counterfactual, dependent on mistaken identification and the chance of escaping reports to Britain.
From Günther Lütjens, useful idiot or misunderstood leadership? · 25 May 2023
Q&A · 4:21:45 Rodney opened around twenty-five thousand yards, was probably below eighteen thousand while disabling the main battery, and eventually closed to roughly three thousand yards.
From Günther Lütjens, useful idiot or misunderstood leadership? · 25 May 2023
Q&A · 4:23:28 Sailing under British colours would not itself count as piracy in this account; attacking while displaying that flag would cross the stated boundary.
From Günther Lütjens, useful idiot or misunderstood leadership? · 25 May 2023
Notable Point · 4:25:17 Destroyed command positions leave uncertainty over whether the first officer or a surviving engineering officer ordered the scuttling.
From Günther Lütjens, useful idiot or misunderstood leadership? · 25 May 2023
Chapter · 0:49 A ship-design exercise frames the trade between a 13.5-inch main battery, armour, machinery, stability, and displacement.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 15:07 The American opponent is rebuilt around period 12-inch and six-inch weapons so an ahistorical game default does not decide the comparison.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 19:05 A comparison of two dreadnought concepts shows why nominal gun range is not enough without speed and reliable target detection.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 24:33 Graf Zeppelin's launch arrangement is compared with a seaplane-carrier system that suited limited operations better than sustained carrier flying.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 27:11 A gunnery manoeuvre uses rapid closing movement to complicate an opponent's range corrections, even though it sacrifices distance.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 30:33 A redesign tests whether an early dreadnought hull can carry its 13.5-inch guns on the centreline instead of accepting wing turrets.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Chapter · 32:42 A fictional Ajax design tests an all-centreline 13.5-inch battery, heavy six-inch secondaries, a shallow hull, and the tactical cost of closing range.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Chapter · 54:12 A fictional British fast capital ship combines G3 and F3 ideas while balancing 16.5-inch guns, armour, underwater torpedoes, and 5.5-inch dual-purpose weapons.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Chapter · 1:02:16 A 9.2-inch-gun large cruiser shows how high speed, belt depth, layered protection, and hull stability compete within a 15,000-ton design.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 1:10:03 A layered-armour thought experiment considers using an outer belt to trigger a shell before an inner belt protects vital spaces.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Chapter · 1:12:10 A fictional French opponent uses all-forward quadruple turrets to explore Dunkerque-like geometry, machinery, anti-aircraft guns, and topweight.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 1:31:36 A simulated cruiser action illustrates why speed should let an intact cruiser disengage once a battleship becomes the enemy's main target.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Q&A · 1:36:00 A viewer exchange explains that the Deutschland class was troublesome not because it was useless, but because its awkward utility created operational burdens.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 1:40:04 A Yamato-inspired design review brings together 6.1-inch secondary turrets, 5-inch dual-purpose guns, heavy protection, and long-range gunnery.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 1:48:17 A night action contrasts long-range Japanese practice with the simulation's close engagement, visible gun flashes, and accuracy-driven result.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 1:51:46 A brief historical aside links Hood's 5.5-inch battery to a speculative calibre that might have served several naval roles if developed successfully.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 2:07:00 A convoy scenario shows why smoke, separated attack axes, and surviving long enough to reach torpedo range matter to defending destroyers.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 2:09:56 A historical correction challenges the idea that the British battlecruisers sent after Coronel were brand new in 1914.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 2:15:28 The destruction of Yamato's forward turrets illustrates why a turret hit can threaten the ammunition spaces below even on a heavily protected ship.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Notable Point · 2:22:56 Carrier aircraft can search for scattered merchant ships more efficiently than a lone battleship, with a destroyer flotilla as the surface alternative.
From A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work? · 24 May 2023
Chapter · 0:00 The opening challenges a backwards-looking label and separates the distinct generations of late nineteenth-century battleships.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Chapter · 6:34 The Royal Sovereigns’ seaworthiness, freeboard, armament layout, and balanced design mark a meaningful step in battleship development.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 8:45 A gun-calibre counterfactual shows how a British 13.5-inch Dreadnought could have widened the challenge facing Germany's 11-inch weapons.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 10:14 Construction tables show how British output created a fleet advantage that individual foreign ships could not easily offset.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 16:13 The Brandenburg class illustrates how machinery faults and weak acceptance practice can turn construction delays into operational risk.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 18:30 Two former Brandenburgs at the Battle of Lemnos demonstrate what can happen when 1890s battleships remain in front-line service into the 1910s.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 19:40 Sissoi Veliky's fate at Tsushima shows the limits of judging a 1890s design outside its original strategic and technical context.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Chapter · 23:27 Britain’s sustained output enabled gradual refinement from class to class while rivals faced sharper gaps and jumps.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 27:28 Nine Majestics demonstrate how a mature maritime-industrial base could field a single class larger than some national battle fleets.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 29:40 Britain's unusually large battleship output is linked to the worldwide security burden of a maritime empire rather than treated as fleet size without strategic context.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Chapter · 30:40 British continuity, American bursts of funding, and Russian and Japanese constraints shaped the battleship balance before 1906.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 31:33 France remained strategically relevant across the Channel even though its battleship output did not approach the Royal Navy's worldwide strength.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 33:30 Launch totals that seemed to favour Russia before 1904 could not erase the geographical, maintenance, and logistical realities of fighting Japan in East Asia.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 35:59 The Duncan class reveals a fleet policy aimed at more than matching rivals: it sought enough ships to create credible overmatch worldwide.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 40:00 Former Chilean orders became useful British fast battleships, illustrating how speed and the right ship in the right theatre could alter a campaign.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 45:01 HMS Dreadnought briefly reset the technical standard; in this interpretation, innovation alone could not preserve the older British deterrent margin.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 46:35 The Virginia class’s stacked eight-inch and twelve-inch turrets show how an apparent gain in broadside fire could create mechanical and damage-control liabilities.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Chapter · 50:39 The Deutschland class connects Germany’s 11-inch-gun tradition, naval laws, and a cautious design culture that persisted into later fleets.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 56:28 Lord Nelson and Agamemnon combined heavy main and intermediate batteries, leaving Britain powerful even if the Dreadnought experiment had disappointed.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 58:21 Royal Navy order size becomes a clue to whether the service was testing technology or committing to a design it trusted for squadron service.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Chapter · 59:14 The final construction comparison explains how intermittent orders raise costs and prevent yards from building the skills and capacity needed for rapid naval expansion.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023
Notable Point · 1:05:04 Satsuma and Aki show why the boundary before Dreadnought was already blurred by faster ships with unusually heavy intermediate batteries.
From Sovereign Battleships... & Why Pre-Dreadnoughts really shouldn't be called that Round 2 · 23 May 2023