Video

A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work?

Study A 13.5in gun Dreadnought? Would it work?, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 24 May 2023, with 20 time notes. Topics include Battleship Design, Carrier Aviation, Dreadnoughts.

Date
Runtime2:31:13
Guide points20 time notes

Time notes

  1. 0:49
    Designing a 13.5-inch-gun dreadnought

    A ship-design exercise frames the trade between a 13.5-inch main battery, armour, machinery, stability, and displacement.

    Chapter
  2. 15:07
    Calibrating a game dreadnought against South Carolina and Delaware

    The American opponent is rebuilt around period 12-inch and six-inch weapons so an ahistorical game default does not decide the comparison.

    Notable Point
  3. 19:05
    Speed, spotting, and gun range

    A comparison of two dreadnought concepts shows why nominal gun range is not enough without speed and reliable target detection.

    Notable Point
  4. 24:33
    Why Graf Zeppelin's catapult system was a poor carrier fit

    Graf Zeppelin's launch arrangement is compared with a seaplane-carrier system that suited limited operations better than sustained carrier flying.

    Notable Point
  5. 27:11
    Steaming into the fall of shot

    A gunnery manoeuvre uses rapid closing movement to complicate an opponent's range corrections, even though it sacrifices distance.

    Notable Point
  6. 30:33
    Escaping wing turrets on an early dreadnought hull

    A redesign tests whether an early dreadnought hull can carry its 13.5-inch guns on the centreline instead of accepting wing turrets.

    Notable Point
  7. 32:42
    An all-centreline 13.5-inch dreadnought experiment

    A fictional Ajax design tests an all-centreline 13.5-inch battery, heavy six-inch secondaries, a shallow hull, and the tactical cost of closing range.

    Chapter
  8. 54:12
    Reworking G3 and F3 capital-ship ideas

    A fictional British fast capital ship combines G3 and F3 ideas while balancing 16.5-inch guns, armour, underwater torpedoes, and 5.5-inch dual-purpose weapons.

    Chapter
  9. 1:02:16
    Building a 15,000-ton large cruiser

    A 9.2-inch-gun large cruiser shows how high speed, belt depth, layered protection, and hull stability compete within a 15,000-ton design.

    Chapter
  10. 1:10:03
    Layered belt armour and where shells detonate

    A layered-armour thought experiment considers using an outer belt to trigger a shell before an inner belt protects vital spaces.

    Notable Point
  11. 1:12:10
    A French all-forward capital-ship concept

    A fictional French opponent uses all-forward quadruple turrets to explore Dunkerque-like geometry, machinery, anti-aircraft guns, and topweight.

    Chapter
  12. 1:31:36
    Cruiser speed as a survival tool

    A simulated cruiser action illustrates why speed should let an intact cruiser disengage once a battleship becomes the enemy's main target.

    Notable Point
  13. 1:36:00
    QuestionWhy describe the Deutschland class as a particularly troublesome German warship design?Answer

    Because it was capable enough to require real employment but worked in ways that complicated both German planning and its opponents' responses.

    Q&A
  14. 1:40:04
    Yamato's protection and secondary battery

    A Yamato-inspired design review brings together 6.1-inch secondary turrets, 5-inch dual-purpose guns, heavy protection, and long-range gunnery.

    Notable Point
  15. 1:48:17
    Night fighting, range, and revealing gun flashes

    A night action contrasts long-range Japanese practice with the simulation's close engagement, visible gun flashes, and accuracy-driven result.

    Notable Point
  16. 1:51:46
    Hood and the potential of the 5.5-inch gun

    A brief historical aside links Hood's 5.5-inch battery to a speculative calibre that might have served several naval roles if developed successfully.

    Notable Point
  17. 2:07:00
    Destroyer convoy defence and access to torpedo range

    A convoy scenario shows why smoke, separated attack axes, and surviving long enough to reach torpedo range matter to defending destroyers.

    Notable Point
  18. 2:09:56
    The age of the battlecruisers at the Falklands

    A historical correction challenges the idea that the British battlecruisers sent after Coronel were brand new in 1914.

    Notable Point
  19. 2:15:28
    Turret penetration as a gateway to the magazines

    The destruction of Yamato's forward turrets illustrates why a turret hit can threaten the ammunition spaces below even on a heavily protected ship.

    Notable Point
  20. 2:22:56
    Carrier aircraft for hunting a scattered convoy

    Carrier aircraft can search for scattered merchant ships more efficiently than a lone battleship, with a destroyer flotilla as the surface alternative.

    Notable Point