Haida stayed in action after a gun-mount explosion
A gun-mount explosion caused fatal casualties and a fire, but Haida continued fighting before a later refit upgraded her systems.
Complete directory
Browse all time notes.
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
Convoy RA66 survived a late U-boat attack
Trained zigzagging helped RA66 avoid torpedoes before its escorts counterattacked, losing Goodall while sinking two U-boats.
Haida and Huron: Trondheim surrender duty and Pacific refit
Haida and Huron's wartime partnership continued through Trondheim surrender duties and preparations for the invasion of Japan.
Canada retained destroyers in postwar reserve
Storing large destroyers allowed Canada to recommission selected ships when postwar requirements increased.
Wartime readiness served a lasting trade need
Reserve preparation supported wartime expansion, while Canada's dependence on seaborne imports and exports supplied the continuing reason for an escort fleet.
British car manufacturing after the loss of British ownership
British factories can retain skilled assembly and export work after their manufacturers pass into foreign ownership.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Science-fiction universes that shaped the panel
Star Trek is a recurring personal favorite, while the answers distinguish science fiction, science fantasy, superheroes, and cyberpunk.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Dahak versus the Death Star
A comparison of two moon-sized warships turns on sensors, weapon range, fleet support, and inconsistent fictional power scales.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Choosing a Star Wars ship to own
Personal ship choices expose the crew, cargo, endurance, and automation assumptions behind an expedition or mobile base.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
A Vickers salesman selling oversized phasers
The sales pitch turns on whether a large weapon can be integrated into a ship.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Deep Space Nine's armament and the limits of an overseas base
Deep Space Nine's armament debate shows how sovereignty, diplomacy, logistics, and internal power politics constrain an apparently simple military upgrade.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Fighter hangars for Deep Space Nine
A fighter proposal encounters hangar-space, structural, and political constraints.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
The danger of self-replicating smart mines
Cyberpunk and Deep Space Nine provide competing fictional examples of autonomous mine replication and control.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
A three-pod air group for Deep Space Nine
External pods become a specific proposal for a larger fighter and runabout force.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Swordfish, Devastator, and Avenger against Bismarck
Aircraft performance, torpedo quality, construction, and anti-aircraft fuzing shape a counterfactual attack on Bismarck.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Russia's intended victory in the Russo-Japanese War
The short answer distinguishes Russian objectives in China and Korea from an invasion of the Japanese home islands.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Swordfish night attacks and the price of training
Specialized night training explains a capability that aircraft specifications alone cannot establish.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
A fictional jump drive and its navigation constraints
The requested setting prompts a tentative description of jump points, a transit bubble, and mass-related obstacles.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
FTL speculation and control of spacetime
An optimistic answer about FTL leads to the unresolved problem of producing and controlling extreme conditions.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Translating between scientific specialties
A personal conference recollection suggests a use for AI, while the reply raises the risk of false connections.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
How Roosevelt might have shaped the early Cold War
The counterfactual contrasts continuity in postwar pressures with possible differences in presidential relationships and Lend-Lease policy.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Bismarck and the naval treaty system
Bismarck emerged in a world still shaped by Washington and London treaty assumptions, although Germany did not design the ship to comply with the Washington treaty itself.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Swordfish against super-battleships
The harbor setting is the specific exception to the rejection of a general Swordfish advantage.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Why Babylon 5's fleets feel more organized than Star Trek's
Visible command staffs earn Babylon 5 credit, while a Star Trek briefing illustrates the personnel omitted from television planning scenes.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
If France fragmented after the Franco-Prussian War
A hypothetical French breakup in 1872 raises regional identity, Italian territorial gains, and British colonial opportunism.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Landing parties and command continuity
A proposed landing party protects senior expertise and gives junior specialists an experienced security escort.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Chief O'Brien's authority and two competing jobs
The issue is both formal authority and the workload created by combining practical engineering leadership with staff duties.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Rank and staffing in a mixed engineering organization
Interoperability and workload complicate the idea that practical competence alone resolves O'Brien's position.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Host-nation politics and inherited base infrastructure
A Cold War basing analogy meets the objection that a space station creates much greater dependence on inherited life-support systems.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Does the Federation maintain armies or marines?
A dispute over Federation ground forces turns on MACOs and which supporting sources each participant accepts.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Why a visible fleet does not settle its organization
Galaxy-wing counts and an in-universe cartoon illustrate the limits of using a scene as a complete institutional record.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Russian intervention in the Franco-Prussian War
The effect of Russia repudiating the post-Crimean settlement depends on whether it opens an eastern threat before or after Prussia has defeated France.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
How USS Puritan became a replacement disguised as a rebuild
Puritan's transferred identity illustrates the gap between a ship's administrative continuity and its physical construction.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Postal engineering and the wider value of infrastructure
The British postal engineering example connects network services, technical expertise, and long investment horizons.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Infrastructure capacity and the Bengal famine response
Railway investment and wartime shipping constraints form a disputed explanation of responsibility for Bengal famine relief.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
What Ajax reveals about defence procurement failure
The Ajax budget question turns on unrecovered spending, replacement choices, and competing service requirements.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Why older British tracked vehicles remained in service
Repeated cancellations and cost objections provide the background to Ajax and the survival of older tracked vehicles.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Closed production lines and the cost of replacing FV432
A disagreement about old vehicles leads to the interaction between factory restart costs and smaller orders.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Creating a defence monopoly and then avoiding it
The procurement dispute traces the tension between industrial scale, supplier choice, and policy continuity.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Why add LAV 6 when Britain is buying Boxer?
The reply favors using the selected vehicle and examines the costs attributed to leaving a collaborative program.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
An attributed account of inconsistent Ajax hulls
A secondhand account raises a quality-control problem in the division of work between Spain and Britain.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Engineering expertise on the government's side of a contract
Naval constructors illustrate why a buyer needs enough independent expertise to evaluate specifications and supplier advice.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
What generalists contribute to technical departments
Technical organizations need translation between departments alongside the specialist knowledge being translated.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Finding Derfflinger's role in science-fiction fleets
A proposed Malevolence analogy prompts disagreement over first-line status and cruiser-hunting employment.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Why Thunderbird 2 wins on logistics
The preference for Thunderbird 2 rests on bringing the equipment that turns arrival at an incident into practical rescue work.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Finding a joint account of the Kusaka cousins
A biographical reading question receives a partial answer and an explicit limit on the books recalled.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
What a monitor becomes in space warfare
Bombardment and local defence provide two different ways to identify a monitor in a fictional fleet.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·
Protecting Andromeda's missile bombardment ships
A missile-heavy fleet needs enough forward combatants to stop an enemy reaching its bombardment ships.
From Bruships 223: Naval History & Science Fiction Questions Answered Live... ·