Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 1:29:40-1:31:33

If France fragmented after the Franco-Prussian War

A hypothetical French breakup in 1872 raises regional identity, Italian territorial gains, and British colonial opportunism.

Alternate HistoryBasquesBrittanyColonialismCorsicaEuropean Balance Of PowerFranceFranco Prussian WarItalySavoy
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

What if France collapsed into smaller states after the Franco-Prussian War, as the Soviet Union did much later?

Short answer

Europe would face a major power vacuum: culturally distinct French regions might break away, Italy could absorb nearby territories, and Britain could exploit the colonial dislocation.

Notes

The scenario places a Soviet-style breakup of France in 1872, after the Franco-Prussian War. Clarke expects Britain to take desirable parts of the French colonial empire. Other participants interpret the breakup through culturally distinct regions, naming Brittany and a southern region whose spoken name is unclear. Savoy and Corsica are considered possible Italian gains or separate Italian states. The Basque suggestion prompts a disagreement about identity and population on the French side of the Pyrenees. These are proposed consequences of the scenario, rather than a reconstruction of events that occurred.