Video
Bruships 157: Books so good they've blown the budget on the #ScandiShip24 tour already!
Study Bruships 157: Books so good they've blown the budget on the #ScandiShip24 tour already!, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 30 Jun 2024, with 66 time notes. Topics include Aircraft Carriers, Anti-Submarine Warfare…
Time notes
- 6:30QuestionWhat are your thoughts on Canada's new River class destroyers?AnswerQ&A
They look capable, with a larger Type 26-based design and useful VLS capacity, though the missile fit trades some flexibility for point-defense value.
- 10:13QuestionWould portable breakwaters like the Phoenix units used for Mulberry harbours help with modern operations such as aid delivery to Gaza?AnswerQ&A
They could be useful, but they belong behind more urgent critical and essential requirements in the procurement queue.
- 10:57QuestionIf the treaty standard for destroyers were about 2,500 tons, how would that affect destroyers and interwar U.S. stability problems?AnswerQ&A
The Royal Navy might still trade down to more 2,000-ton destroyers, while the U.S. answer depends on whether designers use the extra tonnage for stability or simply max out the new limit.
- 12:44QuestionWhat naval technology from history would be worth redeveloping?AnswerQ&A
Anti-submarine mortars deserve another look for littoral threats, though the proposal remains open to disagreement.
- 13:41QuestionShould the Royal Navy revive small coastal submarines for operations west of Ireland?AnswerQ&A
No immediate revival is recommended. More P-8s and continued Type 31 and Type 32 production would take priority over another submarine line.
- 19:03QuestionHow much crew could the Gerald R. Ford class save by adopting British weapons-management and storage systems?AnswerQ&A
Potentially a substantial amount, but only if the systems are designed in from the start; retrofitting them would demand a very large refit.
- 20:11QuestionHow might NATO block hostile Baltic ports in a crisis?AnswerQ&A
A likely approach would combine mines, conventional submarines, and air strikes, with the required duration of closure shaping the plan.
- 21:37QuestionHow practical would diesel-electric Scharnhorst machinery based on multiple sets of Deutschland-class engines be?AnswerQ&A
The direct cost might be manageable, but old diesels impose space, power-to-weight, and duplicated-development penalties; a serious diesel Scharnhorst needs new engines and gearing.
- 22:08QuestionWhat if HMS Lion blew up during the Run to the South at Jutland and killed Beatty?AnswerQ&A
Command might pass to Evan-Thomas, changing the rest of Jutland and the later choice of First Sea Lord.
- 23:00Scandinavian maritime books as source workChapter
The book discussion shows why museum finds and foreign-language sources can add new perspectives on the 1931-32 Sino-Japanese crisis and Swedish-Ottoman connections.
- 27:46QuestionHow would small-tube boilers in the Queen Elizabeth class alter the ships and their role in the First World War?AnswerQ&A
They could create 28-knot-plus capital ships and give the Royal Navy a faster, more cohesive heavy wing during the Battle of Jutland.
- 28:31QuestionWould you prefer Batch 2 River-class or Vigilant-class offshore patrol vessels?AnswerQ&A
Vigilant is better in a somewhat higher-threat environment, while the Batch 2 River is better for long-range peacetime patrol and presence work.
- 30:11QuestionWhat might Reginald Henderson have achieved if he had remained fit and influential into 1940?AnswerQ&A
He may have kept the King George V and Illustrious classes moving and protected HMS Unicorn even if other programs were paused.
- 31:11QuestionWould Dunkerque-style rigid-chain loading improve the rate of fire of German 11-inch guns?AnswerQ&A
Possibly by about half a round per minute, but only with a substantial redesign of the turret and its ammunition-handling systems.
- 32:31QuestionWhat kind of hospital-ship design would suit Canada?AnswerQ&A
An off-the-shelf Arctic patrol hull, preferably ice-strengthened, would be a sensible basis for the specialized ship.
- 35:16QuestionWhat if HMAS Australia and HMS New Zealand had been Lion-class battlecruisers?AnswerQ&A
Dogger Bank would be more dangerous for the Germans, and the larger ships would be much harder to give up after the war.
- 39:01QuestionHow did HMS Hood strip a turbine, and could it be repaired without opening the ship?AnswerQ&A
Excessive loading damaged the turbine internally; crews could rebuild much of it in place, but access for major components would probably require opening parts of the ship.
- 39:23QuestionWhat if the Lion-class battlecruisers had been oil-fired only?AnswerQ&A
They would be faster, Tiger would likely follow, and their postwar retention case would become much stronger.
- 39:41Swedish maritime studies beyond battle narrativesChapter
A Swedish essay collection links sea routes, naval archaeology, prize papers, flags, wrecks, national identity, and Baltic memory.
- 43:15A Norwegian museum guide to arms and captured flagsChapter
A Norwegian museum guide provides a compact reference to arms, ammunition, guns, and captured flags in the Armed Forces collection.
- 47:35Norwegian Navy Road maps supply missing place contextChapter
A Norwegian Navy Road walking guide maps a military transport route and supplies geographic context that larger histories may assume.
- 50:18QuestionWhy is there no obvious record of an October 1969 helicopter accident aboard USS Kitty Hawk?AnswerQ&A
Some record must underlie the known details, so trace those references and search nearby dates, transferred files, and unexpected archival headings.
- 52:08QuestionHow much could a stronger German naval air arm change Jutland if the battle happened nine to twelve months later?AnswerQ&A
It could change history if it sank many capital ships, but the scenario runs into torpedo, range, training, AA, fleet-growth, and operating-space constraints.
- 54:40QuestionWhat if the United States built all of the planned Midway-class carriers?AnswerQ&A
The Navy would enter the Cold War with more adaptable large carriers, while some Essex-class ships would probably retire sooner.
- 54:58QuestionHow would events change if Titanic sank so rapidly after striking the iceberg that there were no survivors?AnswerQ&A
The loss would be more traumatic and mysterious, while regulation might move faster toward more lifeboats and stronger hull-protection measures.
- 56:59QuestionWho was the first Royal Navy aircraft carrier commander who was also a naval aviator?AnswerQ&A
It depends on whether observers and escort carriers count; for a pilot commanding a fleet carrier, Caspar John is a likely answer, with qualifications.
- 1:01:44QuestionHow far could the Japanese 410 mm Year 3 naval gun be bored out?AnswerQ&A
Perhaps to roughly 420-425 mm, but only with important penalties in barrel strength, rifling, life, range, and accuracy.
- 1:04:06QuestionWhat if Jacky Fisher had publicly backed Prince Louis of Battenberg in 1914?AnswerQ&A
Battenberg might remain in office while Fisher supplied powerful strategic and political support without taking over daily management.
- 1:04:48QuestionWhat drove the use of a crescent formation, and was it meant as Islamic symbolism?AnswerQ&A
The formation followed operating doctrine: it concentrated defensive fire while sheltering less capable ships.
- 1:05:40QuestionCould an Arado Ar 95-type aircraft replace catapult-launched aircraft in the Imperial German Navy?AnswerQ&A
Probably, but its greater size and handling burden would likely reduce the number of aircraft carried.
- 1:06:39QuestionHow would the war change if Britain had not paused capital-ship, cruiser, and carrier construction?AnswerQ&A
Britain would gain ships, refit capacity, readiness, and operational flexibility, producing stronger and more sustainable task groups in battles such as the hunt for Bismarck.
- 1:11:02QuestionWhat if Canada bought four oil-fired Tiger-class battlecruisers?AnswerQ&A
The Battlecruiser Fleet would gain major depth, and an early Canadian Tiger at Coronel could change the battle and remove the need for the historical Falklands response.
- 1:13:08QuestionWhat if the Royal Navy replaced older armoured and protected cruisers with a Tiger-era 9.2-inch cruiser design?AnswerQ&A
It would gain useful wartime cruisers, a possible basis for later treaty limits, and a stronger squadron for confronting Goeben and Breslau.
- 1:13:46QuestionCould Japan have built several smaller, very fast 410 mm battleships from 1931 instead of the Yamato class?AnswerQ&A
It was technically possible, but industrial displacement, treaty reactions, and Japan's need for heavy fighting power make the proposed small fast ships a poor simple substitute.
- 1:16:18QuestionWhat if Canada ordered three 28-knot Queen Elizabeth-class successors with small-tube boilers?AnswerQ&A
The United States would take greater interest in battleship speed, while one or two completed Canadian ships could strengthen Jellicoe's fast wing at Jutland.
- 1:17:13QuestionIf Germany built a copy of the Japanese 410 mm gun as a built-up weapon, how much weight difference should be expected?AnswerQ&A
The weight might be slightly lighter, but the more important issue is different performance because German metallurgy and industrial memory had been weakened by the interwar construction gap.
- 1:19:37QuestionWhat if the United States remained completely neutral and provided no Lend-Lease aid before Pearl Harbor?AnswerQ&A
Britain would rely more heavily on Canadian supplies and logistics, but the loss would be smaller than later Lend-Lease totals imply.
- 1:20:26QuestionIn a Japan-to-Italy-to-Germany-to-Japan technology exchange, what would be most useful to each recipient?AnswerQ&A
Japanese shell quality control for Italy, Italian aerial torpedoes for Germany, and German synthetic-fuel or radar technology for Japan.
- 1:22:18QuestionHow capable was Admiral Frank Jack Fletcher, and could he have joined the main U.S. Pacific command rotation?AnswerQ&A
He was capable enough to do so, but the Navy already had an effective rotation with Spruance and Halsey.
- 1:24:16Narvik books as local evidence for the Norwegian campaignChapter
A group of Norwegian museum books adds an admiral's postwar career, local war monuments, maps, photographs, and Norwegian perspectives on Narvik.
- 1:28:28QuestionWhat if Germany began the Second World War with its late-war snorkel system?AnswerQ&A
Early U-boats would be more dangerous, but low numbers would give the Allies time to develop a counter before mass deployment.
- 1:29:18QuestionHow fast could a Deutschland-class ship go after conversion to a carrier with a longer hull, four extra diesels, and a third shaft?AnswerQ&A
No responsible speed estimate is possible without a full redesign study because the proposed conversion changes the hull, structure, shafting, machinery, and power-to-weight ratio.
- 1:33:20QuestionCould Germany have blockaded Britain if it possessed snorkels in 1914?AnswerQ&A
Not immediately; too few submarines were available, and British intelligence and ASW development would likely produce countermeasures before the fleet grew.
- 1:38:38QuestionWould USS Portland and three destroyers near the River Plate have attacked Admiral Graf Spee and brought the United States into the war?AnswerQ&A
Portland could fight, but an attack order was politically very unlikely because the United States was not ready to enter the war in 1939.
- 1:45:01QuestionHow much would prewar German long-range wire-guided torpedoes, especially combined with snorkels, improve U-boat effectiveness?AnswerQ&A
They would provide a dangerous early advantage, but limited German numbers and British intelligence and countermeasure development would erode it.
- 1:46:08QuestionHow would County-class cruiser squadrons fare against Admiral Graf Spee or Deutschland?AnswerQ&A
Four Counties should sink the raider, and the loss of Deutschland to Canadians could trigger an early retreat from politically sensitive ship names.
- 1:47:07QuestionDid HMS Unicorn and the 1942 light-carrier program use cruiser turbines?AnswerQ&A
They used carrier turbines that were closer in scale to cruiser machinery than battleship machinery, rather than simply copying a cruiser plant.
- 1:47:57QuestionCould Allied battleships hold German Panzer divisions at bay until heavy land forces were established?AnswerQ&A
Yes; an exposed armoured attack near the coast would give Allied battleships an opportunity to destroy large numbers of German tanks.
- 1:48:31QuestionWould an Admiral-class carrier conversion use the Courageous-class aviation-fuel management system?AnswerQ&A
It would likely start with a contemporary early system and then receive the same kind of repeated upgrades that transformed British carrier fuel arrangements through the interwar years.
- 1:49:48QuestionWhy did the Barracuda Mk V fail to proceed, and would a delayed war have produced a design closer to the original requirement?AnswerQ&A
The Mk V was no longer considered worthwhile, but without the engine dispute a delayed-war Barracuda could have avoided major redesign and entered service closer to the original vision.
- 1:50:23Scandinavian patrol-boat and icebreaker referencesChapter
Two Swedish-language books supply photographs, drawings, and technical context for future studies of patrol boats and icebreakers.
- 1:57:40QuestionWould the war effort have been easier if the Air Ministry had been less troublesome for the Royal Navy?AnswerQ&A
Some naval problems would ease, but the Air Ministry was also trying to correct costly interwar bomber-first choices by investing urgently in fighters and radar.
- 2:00:31QuestionDid Vindictive's conversion show that purpose-built light carriers were the right British path?AnswerQ&A
Britain already preferred purpose-built carriers, but treaty tonnage made small Hermes-sized ships inefficient compared with larger carriers.
- 2:01:21QuestionHow much difference would an early airborne-warning version of the Avenger make if available early in the war?AnswerQ&A
It would substantially improve warning and fighter direction by detecting low-level attacks beyond the shipboard radar horizon.
- 2:02:13QuestionWhat if the Abyssinia Crisis had led to war between Italy and Britain?AnswerQ&A
Italy would face an unfavorable and isolated war because Germany was not yet ready to intervene.
- 2:02:38QuestionWhy was HMS Vindictive given a carrier arrangement?AnswerQ&A
The conversion tested whether the arrangement could be built and what value it offered.
- 2:02:45QuestionWould more joint Navy and Air Ministry exercises in the 1930s have improved war preparation?AnswerQ&A
They would help to a degree, though disagreement over the results could prevent the lessons from being applied.
- 2:03:01QuestionWhat if HMS Hermes had been one of a class of eight purpose-built carriers?AnswerQ&A
The Royal Navy would gain useful light carriers and probably fight for separate treaty tonnage categories for fleet and cruiser-sized carriers.
- 2:03:08A Swedish naval-forces reference closes the book tourChapter
The final Swedish reference offers a broad illustrated overview of the country's naval forces and coastal-defence history around the twentieth century.
- 2:06:34QuestionHow impractical is an aircraft carrier displacing roughly 107,000 tons at full load?AnswerQ&A
The ship is feasible, but operating much more than about 96 aircraft creates deck and organizational congestion that can erase the benefit of the larger air group.
- 2:07:35QuestionCould a U.S. Second World War submarine fire a Mark 48 torpedo, and what if it replaced the Mark 14 in 1942?AnswerQ&A
It might launch one after modification, but effective use would require a major fire-control upgrade to provide the modern torpedo's information needs.
- 2:08:34QuestionWould a Royal Navy SBD Dauntless need reduced-span or folding wings?AnswerQ&A
Yes; folding or reduced-span wings would be required to meet British carrier-aircraft stowage rules.
- 2:09:00QuestionWhy did HMS Tiger have such a large gap between her after turrets?AnswerQ&A
The spacing followed from the position of the turbines and gearing and from the need to balance the hull.
- 2:09:27QuestionWhat if the F8F Bearcat had been available early enough for Royal Navy wartime service?AnswerQ&A
Britain might adopt it instead of the Wildcat and then have little reason to move through the Hellcat as an intermediate fighter.
- 2:10:33QuestionWould Germany have been better served by 11-inch or 15-inch coastal guns around Normandy instead of 9.4-inch weapons?AnswerQ&A
Larger guns would be more dangerous locally, but fixed defenses still face an attacker who chooses the landing site and can concentrate greater force there.
- 2:11:17QuestionWhat if the F-15 had been designed for carrier operations instead of developing the F-14 path?AnswerQ&A
A joint Air Force-Navy F-15 fleet might have stayed in naval service and displaced the requirement that led to the F/A-18.