Video

Bruships 157: Books so good they've blown the budget on the #ScandiShip24 tour already!

Study Bruships 157: Books so good they've blown the budget on the #ScandiShip24 tour already!, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 30 Jun 2024, with 66 time notes. Topics include Aircraft Carriers, Anti-Submarine Warfare…

Date
Runtime2:14:24
Guide points66 time notes

Time notes

  1. 6:30
    QuestionWhat are your thoughts on Canada's new River class destroyers?Answer

    They look capable, with a larger Type 26-based design and useful VLS capacity, though the missile fit trades some flexibility for point-defense value.

    Q&A
  2. 10:13
    QuestionWould portable breakwaters like the Phoenix units used for Mulberry harbours help with modern operations such as aid delivery to Gaza?Answer

    They could be useful, but they belong behind more urgent critical and essential requirements in the procurement queue.

    Q&A
  3. 10:57
    QuestionIf the treaty standard for destroyers were about 2,500 tons, how would that affect destroyers and interwar U.S. stability problems?Answer

    The Royal Navy might still trade down to more 2,000-ton destroyers, while the U.S. answer depends on whether designers use the extra tonnage for stability or simply max out the new limit.

    Q&A
  4. 12:44
    QuestionWhat naval technology from history would be worth redeveloping?Answer

    Anti-submarine mortars deserve another look for littoral threats, though the proposal remains open to disagreement.

    Q&A
  5. 13:41
    QuestionShould the Royal Navy revive small coastal submarines for operations west of Ireland?Answer

    No immediate revival is recommended. More P-8s and continued Type 31 and Type 32 production would take priority over another submarine line.

    Q&A
  6. 19:03
    QuestionHow much crew could the Gerald R. Ford class save by adopting British weapons-management and storage systems?Answer

    Potentially a substantial amount, but only if the systems are designed in from the start; retrofitting them would demand a very large refit.

    Q&A
  7. 20:11
    QuestionHow might NATO block hostile Baltic ports in a crisis?Answer

    A likely approach would combine mines, conventional submarines, and air strikes, with the required duration of closure shaping the plan.

    Q&A
  8. 21:37
    QuestionHow practical would diesel-electric Scharnhorst machinery based on multiple sets of Deutschland-class engines be?Answer

    The direct cost might be manageable, but old diesels impose space, power-to-weight, and duplicated-development penalties; a serious diesel Scharnhorst needs new engines and gearing.

    Q&A
  9. 22:08
    QuestionWhat if HMS Lion blew up during the Run to the South at Jutland and killed Beatty?Answer

    Command might pass to Evan-Thomas, changing the rest of Jutland and the later choice of First Sea Lord.

    Q&A
  10. 23:00
    Scandinavian maritime books as source work

    The book discussion shows why museum finds and foreign-language sources can add new perspectives on the 1931-32 Sino-Japanese crisis and Swedish-Ottoman connections.

    Chapter
  11. 27:46
    QuestionHow would small-tube boilers in the Queen Elizabeth class alter the ships and their role in the First World War?Answer

    They could create 28-knot-plus capital ships and give the Royal Navy a faster, more cohesive heavy wing during the Battle of Jutland.

    Q&A
  12. 28:31
    QuestionWould you prefer Batch 2 River-class or Vigilant-class offshore patrol vessels?Answer

    Vigilant is better in a somewhat higher-threat environment, while the Batch 2 River is better for long-range peacetime patrol and presence work.

    Q&A
  13. 30:11
    QuestionWhat might Reginald Henderson have achieved if he had remained fit and influential into 1940?Answer

    He may have kept the King George V and Illustrious classes moving and protected HMS Unicorn even if other programs were paused.

    Q&A
  14. 31:11
    QuestionWould Dunkerque-style rigid-chain loading improve the rate of fire of German 11-inch guns?Answer

    Possibly by about half a round per minute, but only with a substantial redesign of the turret and its ammunition-handling systems.

    Q&A
  15. 32:31
    QuestionWhat kind of hospital-ship design would suit Canada?Answer

    An off-the-shelf Arctic patrol hull, preferably ice-strengthened, would be a sensible basis for the specialized ship.

    Q&A
  16. 35:16
    QuestionWhat if HMAS Australia and HMS New Zealand had been Lion-class battlecruisers?Answer

    Dogger Bank would be more dangerous for the Germans, and the larger ships would be much harder to give up after the war.

    Q&A
  17. 39:01
    QuestionHow did HMS Hood strip a turbine, and could it be repaired without opening the ship?Answer

    Excessive loading damaged the turbine internally; crews could rebuild much of it in place, but access for major components would probably require opening parts of the ship.

    Q&A
  18. 39:23
    QuestionWhat if the Lion-class battlecruisers had been oil-fired only?Answer

    They would be faster, Tiger would likely follow, and their postwar retention case would become much stronger.

    Q&A
  19. 39:41
    Swedish maritime studies beyond battle narratives

    A Swedish essay collection links sea routes, naval archaeology, prize papers, flags, wrecks, national identity, and Baltic memory.

    Chapter
  20. 43:15
    A Norwegian museum guide to arms and captured flags

    A Norwegian museum guide provides a compact reference to arms, ammunition, guns, and captured flags in the Armed Forces collection.

    Chapter
  21. 47:35
    Norwegian Navy Road maps supply missing place context

    A Norwegian Navy Road walking guide maps a military transport route and supplies geographic context that larger histories may assume.

    Chapter
  22. 50:18
    QuestionWhy is there no obvious record of an October 1969 helicopter accident aboard USS Kitty Hawk?Answer

    Some record must underlie the known details, so trace those references and search nearby dates, transferred files, and unexpected archival headings.

    Q&A
  23. 52:08
    QuestionHow much could a stronger German naval air arm change Jutland if the battle happened nine to twelve months later?Answer

    It could change history if it sank many capital ships, but the scenario runs into torpedo, range, training, AA, fleet-growth, and operating-space constraints.

    Q&A
  24. 54:40
    QuestionWhat if the United States built all of the planned Midway-class carriers?Answer

    The Navy would enter the Cold War with more adaptable large carriers, while some Essex-class ships would probably retire sooner.

    Q&A
  25. 54:58
    QuestionHow would events change if Titanic sank so rapidly after striking the iceberg that there were no survivors?Answer

    The loss would be more traumatic and mysterious, while regulation might move faster toward more lifeboats and stronger hull-protection measures.

    Q&A
  26. 56:59
    QuestionWho was the first Royal Navy aircraft carrier commander who was also a naval aviator?Answer

    It depends on whether observers and escort carriers count; for a pilot commanding a fleet carrier, Caspar John is a likely answer, with qualifications.

    Q&A
  27. 1:01:44
    QuestionHow far could the Japanese 410 mm Year 3 naval gun be bored out?Answer

    Perhaps to roughly 420-425 mm, but only with important penalties in barrel strength, rifling, life, range, and accuracy.

    Q&A
  28. 1:04:06
    QuestionWhat if Jacky Fisher had publicly backed Prince Louis of Battenberg in 1914?Answer

    Battenberg might remain in office while Fisher supplied powerful strategic and political support without taking over daily management.

    Q&A
  29. 1:04:48
    QuestionWhat drove the use of a crescent formation, and was it meant as Islamic symbolism?Answer

    The formation followed operating doctrine: it concentrated defensive fire while sheltering less capable ships.

    Q&A
  30. 1:05:40
    QuestionCould an Arado Ar 95-type aircraft replace catapult-launched aircraft in the Imperial German Navy?Answer

    Probably, but its greater size and handling burden would likely reduce the number of aircraft carried.

    Q&A
  31. 1:06:39
    QuestionHow would the war change if Britain had not paused capital-ship, cruiser, and carrier construction?Answer

    Britain would gain ships, refit capacity, readiness, and operational flexibility, producing stronger and more sustainable task groups in battles such as the hunt for Bismarck.

    Q&A
  32. 1:11:02
    QuestionWhat if Canada bought four oil-fired Tiger-class battlecruisers?Answer

    The Battlecruiser Fleet would gain major depth, and an early Canadian Tiger at Coronel could change the battle and remove the need for the historical Falklands response.

    Q&A
  33. 1:13:08
    QuestionWhat if the Royal Navy replaced older armoured and protected cruisers with a Tiger-era 9.2-inch cruiser design?Answer

    It would gain useful wartime cruisers, a possible basis for later treaty limits, and a stronger squadron for confronting Goeben and Breslau.

    Q&A
  34. 1:13:46
    QuestionCould Japan have built several smaller, very fast 410 mm battleships from 1931 instead of the Yamato class?Answer

    It was technically possible, but industrial displacement, treaty reactions, and Japan's need for heavy fighting power make the proposed small fast ships a poor simple substitute.

    Q&A
  35. 1:16:18
    QuestionWhat if Canada ordered three 28-knot Queen Elizabeth-class successors with small-tube boilers?Answer

    The United States would take greater interest in battleship speed, while one or two completed Canadian ships could strengthen Jellicoe's fast wing at Jutland.

    Q&A
  36. 1:17:13
    QuestionIf Germany built a copy of the Japanese 410 mm gun as a built-up weapon, how much weight difference should be expected?Answer

    The weight might be slightly lighter, but the more important issue is different performance because German metallurgy and industrial memory had been weakened by the interwar construction gap.

    Q&A
  37. 1:19:37
    QuestionWhat if the United States remained completely neutral and provided no Lend-Lease aid before Pearl Harbor?Answer

    Britain would rely more heavily on Canadian supplies and logistics, but the loss would be smaller than later Lend-Lease totals imply.

    Q&A
  38. 1:20:26
    QuestionIn a Japan-to-Italy-to-Germany-to-Japan technology exchange, what would be most useful to each recipient?Answer

    Japanese shell quality control for Italy, Italian aerial torpedoes for Germany, and German synthetic-fuel or radar technology for Japan.

    Q&A
  39. 1:22:18
    QuestionHow capable was Admiral Frank Jack Fletcher, and could he have joined the main U.S. Pacific command rotation?Answer

    He was capable enough to do so, but the Navy already had an effective rotation with Spruance and Halsey.

    Q&A
  40. 1:24:16
    Narvik books as local evidence for the Norwegian campaign

    A group of Norwegian museum books adds an admiral's postwar career, local war monuments, maps, photographs, and Norwegian perspectives on Narvik.

    Chapter
  41. 1:28:28
    QuestionWhat if Germany began the Second World War with its late-war snorkel system?Answer

    Early U-boats would be more dangerous, but low numbers would give the Allies time to develop a counter before mass deployment.

    Q&A
  42. 1:29:18
    QuestionHow fast could a Deutschland-class ship go after conversion to a carrier with a longer hull, four extra diesels, and a third shaft?Answer

    No responsible speed estimate is possible without a full redesign study because the proposed conversion changes the hull, structure, shafting, machinery, and power-to-weight ratio.

    Q&A
  43. 1:33:20
    QuestionCould Germany have blockaded Britain if it possessed snorkels in 1914?Answer

    Not immediately; too few submarines were available, and British intelligence and ASW development would likely produce countermeasures before the fleet grew.

    Q&A
  44. 1:38:38
    QuestionWould USS Portland and three destroyers near the River Plate have attacked Admiral Graf Spee and brought the United States into the war?Answer

    Portland could fight, but an attack order was politically very unlikely because the United States was not ready to enter the war in 1939.

    Q&A
  45. 1:45:01
    QuestionHow much would prewar German long-range wire-guided torpedoes, especially combined with snorkels, improve U-boat effectiveness?Answer

    They would provide a dangerous early advantage, but limited German numbers and British intelligence and countermeasure development would erode it.

    Q&A
  46. 1:46:08
    QuestionHow would County-class cruiser squadrons fare against Admiral Graf Spee or Deutschland?Answer

    Four Counties should sink the raider, and the loss of Deutschland to Canadians could trigger an early retreat from politically sensitive ship names.

    Q&A
  47. 1:47:07
    QuestionDid HMS Unicorn and the 1942 light-carrier program use cruiser turbines?Answer

    They used carrier turbines that were closer in scale to cruiser machinery than battleship machinery, rather than simply copying a cruiser plant.

    Q&A
  48. 1:47:57
    QuestionCould Allied battleships hold German Panzer divisions at bay until heavy land forces were established?Answer

    Yes; an exposed armoured attack near the coast would give Allied battleships an opportunity to destroy large numbers of German tanks.

    Q&A
  49. 1:48:31
    QuestionWould an Admiral-class carrier conversion use the Courageous-class aviation-fuel management system?Answer

    It would likely start with a contemporary early system and then receive the same kind of repeated upgrades that transformed British carrier fuel arrangements through the interwar years.

    Q&A
  50. 1:49:48
    QuestionWhy did the Barracuda Mk V fail to proceed, and would a delayed war have produced a design closer to the original requirement?Answer

    The Mk V was no longer considered worthwhile, but without the engine dispute a delayed-war Barracuda could have avoided major redesign and entered service closer to the original vision.

    Q&A
  51. 1:50:23
    Scandinavian patrol-boat and icebreaker references

    Two Swedish-language books supply photographs, drawings, and technical context for future studies of patrol boats and icebreakers.

    Chapter
  52. 1:57:40
    QuestionWould the war effort have been easier if the Air Ministry had been less troublesome for the Royal Navy?Answer

    Some naval problems would ease, but the Air Ministry was also trying to correct costly interwar bomber-first choices by investing urgently in fighters and radar.

    Q&A
  53. 2:00:31
    QuestionDid Vindictive's conversion show that purpose-built light carriers were the right British path?Answer

    Britain already preferred purpose-built carriers, but treaty tonnage made small Hermes-sized ships inefficient compared with larger carriers.

    Q&A
  54. 2:01:21
    QuestionHow much difference would an early airborne-warning version of the Avenger make if available early in the war?Answer

    It would substantially improve warning and fighter direction by detecting low-level attacks beyond the shipboard radar horizon.

    Q&A
  55. 2:02:13
    QuestionWhat if the Abyssinia Crisis had led to war between Italy and Britain?Answer

    Italy would face an unfavorable and isolated war because Germany was not yet ready to intervene.

    Q&A
  56. 2:02:38
    QuestionWhy was HMS Vindictive given a carrier arrangement?Answer

    The conversion tested whether the arrangement could be built and what value it offered.

    Q&A
  57. 2:02:45
    QuestionWould more joint Navy and Air Ministry exercises in the 1930s have improved war preparation?Answer

    They would help to a degree, though disagreement over the results could prevent the lessons from being applied.

    Q&A
  58. 2:03:01
    QuestionWhat if HMS Hermes had been one of a class of eight purpose-built carriers?Answer

    The Royal Navy would gain useful light carriers and probably fight for separate treaty tonnage categories for fleet and cruiser-sized carriers.

    Q&A
  59. 2:03:08
    A Swedish naval-forces reference closes the book tour

    The final Swedish reference offers a broad illustrated overview of the country's naval forces and coastal-defence history around the twentieth century.

    Chapter
  60. 2:06:34
    QuestionHow impractical is an aircraft carrier displacing roughly 107,000 tons at full load?Answer

    The ship is feasible, but operating much more than about 96 aircraft creates deck and organizational congestion that can erase the benefit of the larger air group.

    Q&A
  61. 2:07:35
    QuestionCould a U.S. Second World War submarine fire a Mark 48 torpedo, and what if it replaced the Mark 14 in 1942?Answer

    It might launch one after modification, but effective use would require a major fire-control upgrade to provide the modern torpedo's information needs.

    Q&A
  62. 2:08:34
    QuestionWould a Royal Navy SBD Dauntless need reduced-span or folding wings?Answer

    Yes; folding or reduced-span wings would be required to meet British carrier-aircraft stowage rules.

    Q&A
  63. 2:09:00
    QuestionWhy did HMS Tiger have such a large gap between her after turrets?Answer

    The spacing followed from the position of the turbines and gearing and from the need to balance the hull.

    Q&A
  64. 2:09:27
    QuestionWhat if the F8F Bearcat had been available early enough for Royal Navy wartime service?Answer

    Britain might adopt it instead of the Wildcat and then have little reason to move through the Hellcat as an intermediate fighter.

    Q&A
  65. 2:10:33
    QuestionWould Germany have been better served by 11-inch or 15-inch coastal guns around Normandy instead of 9.4-inch weapons?Answer

    Larger guns would be more dangerous locally, but fixed defenses still face an attacker who chooses the landing site and can concentrate greater force there.

    Q&A
  66. 2:11:17
    QuestionWhat if the F-15 had been designed for carrier operations instead of developing the F-14 path?Answer

    A joint Air Force-Navy F-15 fleet might have stayed in naval service and displaced the requirement that led to the F/A-18.

    Q&A