Video
Battle of Stromboli (8th of January 1676...that's 345yrs ago tomorrow)
Study Battle of Stromboli (8th of January 1676...that's 345yrs ago tomorrow), a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 7 Jan 2021, with 49 time notes. Topics include Age Of Sail, Aircraft Carriers, Battle Of Augusta.
Time notes
- 10:00Why the Messina revolt drew Dutch and Spanish fleets togetherChapter
Messina's revolt brought French intervention, a Spanish appeal for Dutch help, and an undermanned Dutch expedition to Sicily.
- 13:28Cruisers provide presence without battleship expenseNotable Point
Starfleet Command's Enterprise illustrates a real naval choice: cruisers provide useful presence without the running costs of battleships.
- 15:39The Lipari defeat makes Dutch intervention necessaryNotable Point
A French victory over Spain at the Lipari Islands, also called the first Battle of Stromboli, sets up de Ruyter's arrival in the campaign.
- 22:41A de facto British fleet predates the 1707 UnionNotable Point
Scottish officers and sailors were already serving alongside English personnel even though the political Act of Union still lay three decades ahead.
- 24:34Sicilian currents buy time for Duquesne's reinforcementNotable Point
Difficult local currents delayed contact long enough for Duquesne to arrive with a stronger French force on 7 January.
- 26:39Louis XIV turns inheritance clauses into a war aimChapter
An unpaid dowry and disputed inheritance rights helped Louis XIV justify invading the Spanish Netherlands, provoking a coalition to contain France.
- 35:14Louis XIV tries to separate the Dutch from their alliesNotable Point
After the settlement, Louis XIV sought to isolate the Dutch by paying Britain to stay out and encouraging Swedish commitments elsewhere.
- 41:18Water transport connects Britain's early industrial economyNotable Point
Coastal shipping, rivers, and canals helped Britain connect industrial centres while France faced greater difficulties moving goods internally.
- 43:49The United Provinces and Spanish Netherlands on a modern mapNotable Point
The distinction between the United Provinces and Spanish Netherlands helps locate the war in the modern Netherlands, Belgium, and Luxembourg.
- 45:57QuestionWhat infrastructure problems affected French ships and armies?AnswerQ&A
Separated yards made ship standardization difficult, while poor army supply administration encouraged dependence on food taken locally.
- 48:40Abraham Duquesne's long route to French fleet commandChapter
Duquesne's merchant, Swedish, and French service made him one of France's most experienced admirals, although his Protestant faith limited his career.
- 54:15Duquesne's personal exemption did not protect his familyNotable Point
Duquesne could remain in France while his sons were banished; accounts of his heart and pension offer uncertain details about that separation.
- 56:43QuestionWhere did you find information about Abraham Duquesne?AnswerQ&A
The research began with Encyclopaedia Britannica and cited sources, including foreign-language material used cautiously through machine translation.
- 1:02:38Michiel de Ruyter builds command experience from the bottom upChapter
De Ruyter rose from boatswain's apprentice and merchant master to combat command through nearly four decades of practical shiphandling.
- 1:06:32De Ruyter builds his fighting reputation against privateersNotable Point
Dutch counter-privateers answered commercial attacks on trade, creating the fighting environment in which de Ruyter first made his name.
- 1:11:01Fleet lists reveal Stromboli's communications and logisticsChapter
Support vessels and a French convoy commitment complicate a comparison based only on the fleets' gun totals.
- 1:11:36Fast snows carry orders between squadronsNotable Point
Small, fast snows carried messages between Dutch squadrons, making communications vessels part of the fleet's command system.
- 1:13:55Why Dutch command titles resist modern rank equivalentsNotable Point
Admiralty-specific titles and the presence of flag captains complicate attempts to assign modern ranks to the Dutch squadron commanders.
- 1:23:47Parliamentary funding helps the Royal Navy overtake its rivalsNotable Point
The Dutch and French fleets still ranked ahead in the 1670s, but steadier parliamentary appropriations later gave the Royal Navy a durable advantage.
- 1:28:42QuestionDid French Protestant officers join the Royal Navy after the Edict of Nantes was revoked?AnswerQ&A
Yes. Officers also went to the Dutch, Swedish, Russian, and Italian services.
- 1:30:07QuestionWere French Protestant officers merely serving abroad between wars, or were they forced out after the Edict of Nantes was revoked?AnswerQ&A
Before revocation they could serve abroad temporarily, but afterward Protestant officers were denied advancement, expelled, pressured to convert, or driven into foreign service.
- 1:34:03The Edict of Nantes separates civil loyalty from religious uniformityNotable Point
The 1598 settlement offered Huguenots legal protection; its later revocation exchanged religious accommodation for a costly loss of military experience.
- 1:38:18QuestionWhat training system could produce good sailors and captains?AnswerQ&A
A navy could train landsmen quickly when it preserved a strong core of experienced sailors to teach and supervise them.
- 1:41:06De Ruyter turns maneuver and broadsides against French gun numbersChapter
The Dutch line yielded gradually, kept its broadsides bearing, and frustrated repeated French attempts to close and break through.
- 1:50:03QuestionDid the French convoy reach Messina after Stromboli?AnswerQ&A
Yes. Duquesne took the convoy around Sicily and delivered it to Messina without another battle.
- 1:52:47Poor coalition command exposes de Ruyter at AugustaChapter
A Spanish refusal to mix squadrons left the Dutch van isolated, allowing Duquesne to concentrate against de Ruyter from both sides.
- 2:00:12Fire ships devastate the allied fleet at PalermoNotable Point
A month after Augusta, French gunfire and fire ships destroyed Dutch and Spanish vessels anchored inside Palermo harbour.
- 2:01:49QuestionDid Duquesne perform better against de Ruyter than de Ruyter's English opponents had?AnswerQ&A
Yes; the Dutch did better tactically, but Duquesne achieved the strategic objective by delivering the convoy.
- 2:02:13QuestionWere any of the commanders of the different groups of ships competent?AnswerQ&A
Yes. Jan den Haen, Duquesne, and de Ruyter were capable commanders; the criticism falls particularly on de la Cerda.
- 2:03:44QuestionWhere was the painting shown during the Augusta discussion located?AnswerQ&A
A viewer identifies Luxembourg Palace in Paris, correcting the initial tentative identification of a Dutch museum.
- 2:04:02QuestionAre there other names for the battles of Augusta and Stromboli?AnswerQ&A
Yes; Augusta is also called Etna, while this Stromboli action may be called the second Battle of Stromboli or the Battle of Alicudi.
- 2:04:38QuestionDid de Ruyter know what he was doing at Augusta, and why was his force surrounded?AnswerQ&A
De Ruyter was using the allies' advantage in viable ships, but Spanish inaction let Duquesne bring his center against the Dutch van from the other side.
- 2:07:52Duquesne's name connects Stromboli with later submarine plansNotable Point
Duquesne's commemoration in the French submarine program links Stromboli with Australia's Attack-class plans as they stood in January 2021.
- 2:12:16QuestionAre there many naval and maritime historians who use multiple languages effectively for this period?AnswerQ&A
Fewer than would be hoped.
- 2:14:41De Ruyter and the release of Hungarian Protestant pastorsNotable Point
A viewer places de Ruyter's release of twenty-six Hungarian Protestant pastors shortly after Stromboli.
- 2:15:46The Dutch Water Line turns flooding into a defensive systemNotable Point
Flooding, fortified routes, small boats, and mobile artillery formed a Dutch defensive system while the wider war strained naval resources.
- 2:20:45QuestionWho was better, de Ruyter or Tromp?AnswerQ&A
The personal preference is de Ruyter, though Tromp was also good and the comparison depends on the criteria.
- 2:23:42QuestionWhy did France not buy or copy a Yorktown-class carrier design?AnswerQ&A
Suitable French yards were committed to battleships, and Yorktown's Pacific-oriented design was not an ideal match for Mediterranean requirements.
- 2:25:57QuestionWould de Ruyter defeat Duquesne in an otherwise even fleet action?AnswerQ&A
Probably; de Ruyter generally benefited from more competent subordinate commanders.
- 2:26:17QuestionWould an Illustrious-class design have suited the French Navy?AnswerQ&A
Yes; among plausible British designs, Illustrious would fit French needs better than Ark Royal.
- 2:27:41Graf Zeppelin needed a balanced raider task forceChapter
German admirals wanted carriers for reconnaissance and strike support, but capital ships, cruisers, and sustained funding were needed to make the concept operationally credible.
- 2:32:22QuestionWere sixty-gun ships among the largest warships during this period?AnswerQ&A
Yes; ships later classed as third rates were close to first-rate fleet units in the 1670s, though a few larger ships existed.
- 2:32:37QuestionDid the Luftwaffe restrict aircraft supply to Graf Zeppelin?AnswerQ&A
At points it did, but the larger design penalty came from demanding land-base-like hangar space for each aircraft.
- 2:33:20QuestionHow was Graf Zeppelin's planned trolley aircraft-handling system supposed to work?AnswerQ&A
Aircraft would move on rail-mounted trolleys from hangar to lift and launch position, gaining security at the cost of complexity and vulnerability.
- 2:36:29QuestionDo German naval archives have aircraft and trolley plans useful for a Bf 109T model?AnswerQ&A
They are suggested as a possible source, but no specific archive or collection is identified.
- 2:36:40QuestionWould Germany have benefited from operating a carrier around 1928 before designing Graf Zeppelin?AnswerQ&A
Yes; early operating experience would likely have shown which carrier arrangements were useful in practice.
- 2:36:59Using a carrier lift as a crane can obstruct its main jobNotable Point
Using an aircraft lift for crane work saves dedicated equipment but can leave the lift unavailable for normal aircraft movements.
- 2:39:33Complex systems can replace judgment but concentrate failureNotable Point
Complex machinery can secure aircraft and reduce reliance on individual checks, but simpler arrangements can ease production and maintenance.
- 2:42:32QuestionWere reported leaks aboard HMS Prince of Wales caused by cost-cutting during construction?AnswerQ&A
Possibly, but construction savings were an unconfirmed suspicion, not an established cause.