Notable Point · 30:06 If Germany cannot finish the Norwegian campaign, pressure on Sweden or Finland could turn a contained northern front into a broader Scandinavian coalition war.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Chapter · 34:15 No Taranto, Matapan, or Mediterranean carrier losses leave Britain with more ships for Norway, the Atlantic, and a future Indian Ocean fleet.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 38:44 Formidable, Victorious, and Indomitable anchor a fast Home Fleet while Illustrious and a Nelson-class battleship form a slower Gibraltar backstop.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Chapter · 40:28 As King George V-class replacements enter service, modernized Queen Elizabeth-class battleships, Rodney, Repulse, and three carriers build up at Ceylon to deter Japan.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 42:38 Submarines not consumed by Mediterranean operations can move east, potentially placing about eight long-range T-class boats at Singapore by 1941.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 45:13 Extra capital ships make a Hood modernization and radar or anti-aircraft work on Repulse more plausible before German bombing pressures British dockyards.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Chapter · 48:08 Without the Mediterranean or North African campaigns, Andrew Cunningham and forces not needed in Norway can strengthen Malaya, Burma, and imperial garrisons.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 51:32 Allied airfields in Norway enable denser maritime patrols, making German submarines and surface raiders easier to detect as they enter the Atlantic.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 53:18 Neutral internment keeps major French warships inactive in Britain instead of giving Free France a fleet that might intervene when Japan takes Indochina.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Chapter · 53:18 Japan may still occupy Vichy Indochina, but an attack on the oil-rich Dutch East Indies brings Britain and the United States into the war against it.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 57:45 Holding northern Norway could shorten bombing routes into Germany, protect much of an Arctic convoy passage, obstruct Swedish iron-ore traffic, and change Finland's strategic choice.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Chapter · 59:16 Ark Royal, Glorious, and Furious could launch roughly 96 Albacores at night against Japanese carriers and Kongo-class battleships approaching the Dutch East Indies.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Chapter · 1:04:12 After the British night attack, intact American forces arrive from the Philippines and Pacific, leaving Japan's carrier force little chance of surviving the combined response.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Chapter · 1:07:20 With Japan's carriers broken, the Allies can retake the Dutch East Indies, seize forward bases on the Chinese coast, and blockade Japan much earlier.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 1:09:28 Italy's armed forces and geography forced the Allies to disperse resources; removing that pressure strengthens France, Britain, Norway, and the Far East at the same time.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 1:11:11 The closing thought experiment asks how naval aviation doctrine develops if the Pacific war contains only a British night strike and one major American carrier battle.
From So what happens in the Pacific if Italy stays neutral for WWII? · 13 Nov 2024
Q&A · 7:10 Drachinifel proposes retaining two Admiral-class battlecruiser hulls to form the Royal Navy's large interwar carrier force.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 10:19 References to Admiral-class conversion studies help explain Cammell Laird's reputation as a strike-carrier specialist before building Ark Royal.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 15:09 Large Admiral-class conversions might have raised naval aviation's institutional status and improved the Royal Navy's influence over aircraft requirements.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 20:13 Several naval and Air Ministry offices separated Fleet Air Arm experience from the engineers designing its aircraft.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Chapter · 21:51 The alternate fleet assigns older and smaller carriers to support, training, cruiser, and regional duties around two large strike carriers.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 26:39 Argus's Queen Bee aircraft put drone operations at sea decades before modern uncrewed carrier proposals.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 27:21 Large Admiral-class conversions could encourage twin-engine naval aircraft and alter the hangar layout of later carriers.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 30:24 A Wasp-style lift could free internal space while allowing heavy doors to close the hangar against North Sea weather.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 33:33 The Blackburn Blackburn combined naval spotting equipment with visual warning of approaching aircraft.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 34:37 Restarting all three suspended Admiral-class hulls as carriers would change the fleet Britain brought to the Washington negotiations.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Chapter · 35:43 The Royal Navy distinguished strike-carrier, fleet-carrier, and cruiser-carrier concepts between the wars.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Chapter · 39:40 The ideal late-interwar design combines Ark Royal's air group with armor, while larger surviving carriers make multi-carrier operations more attainable.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 40:33 Far East deployment made repair distance a carrier-design problem, while the RAF reinforcement plan required the same ships to ferry aircraft east.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 45:18 Replacing Courageous and Glorious with larger Admiral conversions changes both the damage the fleet carriers might survive and which ships should accept convoy and submarine-hunting risk.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 47:57 A larger replacement for Glorious could rescue RAF aircraft while maintaining reconnaissance, giving it time to avoid or attack the German battlecruisers.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 50:48 The Navy financed the Fleet Air Arm even while the Air Ministry administered pilots, contracts, and the route to aircraft manufacturers.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Chapter · 51:58 British Malta and American Midway designs approached a common compromise between armored flight decks, large air groups, and ventilated hangars.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 56:01 Pacific sea room, confined British operating areas and North Sea weather produced different compromises between aircraft capacity, protection and hangar ventilation.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 58:37 Artificial exercise boundaries could exaggerate the ability of cruisers to find carriers and distort which ships attacking aircraft would choose.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Q&A · 1:01:00 Britain's crowded postwar carrier fleet included worn wartime ships and newer hulls worth developing for the jet age.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 1:04:55 Repeated high-speed flight operations gave aircraft carriers destroyer-like machinery wear, leaving the Illustrious class with little economical postwar life.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Chapter · 1:08:19 A staged program uses light carriers for experiments before completing Audacious and Malta hulls with mature jet-age features.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Chapter · 1:13:42 The Centaur class becomes a purposefully limited helicopter, amphibious-assault, and command layer beneath the larger Audacious and Malta carrier force.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 1:14:51 The largest alternate carriers inherit the Royal Navy's most prestigious carrier names, with Africa treated as the Malta-class hull most easily renamed.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 1:17:19 A layered fleet protects four Malta-class strike carriers by offering less capable ships for successive budget reductions.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 1:21:24 Hull wear, machinery condition, and growing aircraft would put Malta replacements into construction in the early-to-mid 1980s.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 1:22:26 A sustained British carrier force could anchor NATO's Atlantic strike command and become a routine instrument of prime-ministerial signaling.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 1:25:27 A caveated Soviet targeting story illustrates how propaganda, hierarchy, and fear can preserve factual errors inside a technically powerful state.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Chapter · 1:29:52 Four identical carriers could keep two hulls at sea and surge a third by changing the Royal Marines support ship's air group.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Notable Point · 1:34:02 A helicopter-heavy carrier with fighters and Hawkeyes could protect amphibious movement, while a larger Fearless force carried the Royal Marines.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Q&A · 1:36:20 A naval Tornado would need extensive structural redesign, while its strike and fighter roles offered little reason to accept the difficulty.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024
Chapter · 1:40:54 Sustained naval aircraft orders could support a Sea Vixen successor, while larger decks simplify the alternative of operating Phantoms.
From @Drachinifel & Dr Clarke Discuss Royal Navy Aircraft Carriers that almost were! #2Historians ep 1 · 12 Nov 2024