Notable Point · 45:18 Japan's incremental path from Kongo through Atago to Maya supports realistic upgrades and future railgun or laser integration.
From Maya Class: The Ultimate Arleigh Burke Flight IIA or something else? · 19 Sept 2025
Chapter · 47:32 The Kongo and Type 45 replacement windows may overlap enough for a joint Anglo-Japanese program, though design identity and radar choices remain difficult.
From Maya Class: The Ultimate Arleigh Burke Flight IIA or something else? · 19 Sept 2025
Chapter · 0:00 Torpex combines established explosives with aluminium to increase destructive effect while economizing on difficult or costly ingredients.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Chapter · 3:35 TNT's route from Julius Wilbrand's yellow dye to a pourable explosive shows how feedstock purification, unusual stability, and regulation shaped military adoption.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 6:52 German and British navies valued TNT because its stability let a shell pass through armour before exploding instead of bursting on first impact.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 7:35 American grade choices, TNT's low melting point, and German monthly output show how explosives performance depends on purification, storage, and industrial scale.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Chapter · 9:16 British work at the Royal Arsenal sought an explosive more energetic than TNT for attacking increasingly robust submarines.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 12:05 RDX was stable and energetic but too expensive to use alone across the enormous tonnages demanded by modern war.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 13:45 The secrecy surrounding explosives research forces historians to distinguish documentable facts from plausible conclusions that the surviving record cannot prove directly.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 16:46 Woolwich and Waltham Abbey gave Britain durable laboratories, accumulated expertise, and room to conceal experimental weapons work.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 19:51 Torpex belonged to a wider British naval buildup paced for 1942, including new escort destroyers, corvettes, and sloops ordered before the war began.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Chapter · 21:02 RDX, TNT, aluminium, wax, and moisture control balance greater blast duration against shock sensitivity and storage hazards.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Chapter · 23:11 Late-1930s British torpedo work appears to have anticipated the new explosive's compact, more powerful warhead.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 25:39 Torpex's roughly fifty-percent advantage over TNT lets an unchanged torpedo warhead deliver a much larger blast effect.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 26:20 Churchill's decision to pause construction and development repeated a First World War response even though the 1939 Royal Navy had invested more heavily in small ships and methodical procurement.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 27:38 A 50-percent increase in torpedo explosive effect could have magnified British damage at Taranto and trapped more of the Italian fleet at Matapan.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Chapter · 29:35 War forced Britain and North America to turn a workable batch method into industrial RDX output measured in hundreds of tons per day.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 31:19 The need to preserve current output delayed a superior explosive until 1942, even as wartime demand rapidly expanded its use once production matured.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 32:36 The closing counterfactual asks how a prewar RDX scale-up might have changed British bombs, mines, and torpedoes while rejecting Torpex-filled gun shells as unsafe.
From Torpex: A Short History of it's History... · 18 Sept 2025
Chapter · 6:20 A simulated British response to Japan's Number 13 design tests whether twelve 18-inch guns, 33 knots, and heavy protection can fit within 58,000 tons.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Q&A · 12:16 Fitting modern sensors and missiles into an old battleship is technically possible, but gun shock, electrical demand, and the scale of reconstruction undermine its practicality.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 19:03 A generator on deck avoids difficult access below, but noise, blast, and heat complicate that apparently simple refit option.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 20:36 Turret removal creates space for missiles, but internal layout and the difference between empty launchers and a complete installation still matter.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 25:35 Ten twin 4-inch mounts and simulated pom-poms give the British design a heavy antiaircraft fit while armor weight favors the main armament over the conning tower.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Chapter · 32:08 A simulated Italian answer to Nelson combines 381 mm guns and 30 knots within 35,000 tons, then exposes compromises in secondary mounting and fire control.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Q&A · 48:58 The exposed deck torpedoes would be fired early, either at close range or as spoiling shots before a prolonged gun duel.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 53:23 The Italian design's heavy battery depends on one vulnerable fire-control center, while its bridge also has an obstructed view.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Chapter · 54:44 Two 1940 game designs use an 80,000-ton allowance for either twenty 16-inch guns or twelve 18-inch guns, with Pacific range and enlarged canal locks shaping the hull.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Q&A · 1:04:44 The assumed expansion of the Panama Canal locks permits a beam wider than Iowa's for the 80,000-ton American design.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Q&A · 1:07:29 The recalled ammunition arrangement feeds a superposed 8-inch turret through two additional hoists inside the lower 12-inch mount.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Chapter · 1:14:38 A hypothetical British competitor for Japan's Kongo contract compares a ten-gun battlecruiser with a twelve-gun alternative carrying very light secondaries.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 1:26:01 South Dakota's electrical distribution deserves examination against contemporary engineering practice and the control systems available in the 1940s.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Q&A · 1:27:53 Mixed voltage labels prompt several possible explanations, with no confirmed cause for the difference.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 1:29:32 A recalled machinery photograph places a clutch aboard a geared-turbine warship and records its operating-speed restriction.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Chapter · 1:37:17 Two hypothetical 90,000-ton battleships converge on sixteen 16.5-inch guns but favor different protection schemes and engagement ranges.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Q&A · 1:39:29 A tracked German midget submarine raises a practical question about whether self-propelled movement ashore justified the complexity compared with a towable carriage.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 1:41:59 The rocket-assisted Tallboy proposal adds eight RP-3 rockets to a heavy bomb to increase impact speed and penetration.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 1:44:17 The T12 Cloudmaker and a two-Grand-Slam B-29 configuration illustrate the modifications associated with exceptionally large bunker-busting bombs.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Q&A · 1:46:50 Hypothetical Grand Slam loads for the B-52 and B-2 depend on room at external stations and inside the bomb bay.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 1:47:40 A recalled proposal would replace a 747's passenger accommodation with four twelve-shot rotary cruise-missile launchers.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Notable Point · 1:51:35 A disputed Vulcan B3 performance claim leads into a counterfactual Concorde bomber with rotating missile bays and a fast approach-and-withdrawal concept.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Q&A · 1:54:58 Remembered H-class studies supply the caliber, while bulky game models for larger twin turrets lead to sixteen 16.5-inch guns in quadruple mounts.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Chapter · 2:01:20 A 1920s design challenge forces same-caliber wing and centerline turrets into an Austro-Hungarian capital ship.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Q&A · 2:10:29 The New Mexico and as-built South Dakota classes receive the two votes, with additional interest in the unbuilt 1920s South Dakota design.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Q&A · 2:11:22 A proposed mobilization Vanguard keeps the 15-inch battery while reducing hull size and speed and changing the secondary armament.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Chapter · 2:17:08 Competing Agincourt alternatives explore triple 15-inch guns and twin 18-inch guns under counterfactual British technology assumptions.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Q&A · 2:21:55 Duke of Edinburgh is proposed as a Type 83 class name, with Princess Royal suggested for an individual ship.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025
Q&A · 2:25:56 A Swedish coastal-defence battleship is considered a plausible challenger, but the fleet-specific comparison remains unresolved.
From #2Historians Live: With @Drachinifel comes to chat & build UAD Dreadnoughts that Almost were P3 · 17 Sept 2025