Video
HMS Gorgon(HNoMS Nidaros) takes part in the First Battle of Narvik
Study HMS Gorgon(HNoMS Nidaros) takes part in the First Battle of Narvik, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 11 Sept 2025, with 24 time notes. Topics include Alternate History, Battles Of Narvik, Coastal Defence Ships.
Time notes
- 0:00Why Narvik's Norwegian naval defense matteredChapter
The opening reframes the first fight at Narvik around the Norwegian coastal-defence ships Eidsvold and Norge and the orders that kept them apart.
- 3:17Why Norway declined the future HNoMS NidarosChapter
Norway refuses the former HMS Gorgon after wartime conversion, citing the dry-dock burden created by her enormous anti-torpedo bulges.
- 6:02How Nidaros would reshape Norway's officer pipelineNotable Point
Keeping Nidaros in service creates an extra ladder of commands and promotions, so the ship's 1940 captain cannot simply be borrowed from the historical roster.
- 7:54Why Carl Gustav Fleischer was sidelinedNotable Point
Carl Gustav Fleischer's removal from command of the Free Norwegian forces shows political caution sidelining an officer regarded as too militant toward Germany.
- 9:15Nidaros as an armored floating fortNotable Point
A comparison with Eidsvold shows how Nidaros would add heavier guns, newer technology, thick armor, and major torpedo protection to Norway's coastal fleet.
- 10:25Norway's missed coastal-defence modernizationNotable Point
Accepting Nidaros could have been followed by a new pair of coastal-defence ships as rapid technological change made the Eidsvold class increasingly dated.
- 10:56Gorgon's 9.2-inch guns and armored coreNotable Point
After British relining, Gorgon's guns fire a 420-pound shell at a quoted 2,900 feet per second, backed by heavy armor and enormous anti-torpedo bulges.
- 15:35Mutual support changes the torpedo problemNotable Point
A second heavy ship beside Eidsvold would make it harder for a German destroyer to prepare a point-blank torpedo attack unnoticed.
- 16:51Command experience and destroyers packed with troopsChapter
The opposing commanders, troop-laden destroyers, and restricted fjord waters explain why every German ship loss would carry an unusually high operational cost.
- 18:51Why Eidsvold and Norge had no heavy reserveNotable Point
The older Tordenskjold class had become training ships and was declared unfit for war, leaving Eidsvold and Norge as Norway's strongest combat vessels.
- 21:44Why confined-water training mattered at NarvikNotable Point
Bonte's destroyers enter a fjord far removed from their North Sea and Baltic maneuver training, a weakness later exposed by British close-quarters tactics.
- 21:52The blocked withdrawal toward BjørnfjellNotable Point
A Norwegian force of roughly 200 soldiers trying to leave Narvik is defeated after German troops seize Bjørnfjell station near the Swedish border.
- 24:10Per Askim's civilian maritime expertiseNotable Point
Askim's lighthouse-service work and international committees on signals, coastal marking, and radio beacons add civilian maritime-systems expertise to his naval command.
- 25:20Late Norwegian readiness meets German naval hubrisChapter
Norwegian crews trained urgently after years of neglect, while Germany risked scarce destroyers to secure Atlantic access through Norway.
- 27:11How Atlantic bases shape convoy routesNotable Point
Norwegian and French bases widen the U-boat threat, while denying either coastline lets Allied planners route convoys farther from German operating areas.
- 30:10Eidsvold's challenge and sudden destructionChapter
Poor visibility, deceptive negotiations, and a point-blank torpedo spread destroy Eidsvold before her crew can bring its guns fully into action.
- 34:44Norge fights alone inside NarvikChapter
Norge opens fire on German destroyers in darkness but poor sights, neglected equipment, and torpedoes end the remaining naval resistance.
- 41:16The counterfactual deployment beside EidsvoldChapter
The scenario places Nidaros alongside Eidsvold near the fjord entrance while Norge remains inside Narvik, creating three mutually supporting heavy ships.
- 41:48The excluded 14-inch-monitor branchNotable Point
Accepting Gorgon might have opened a wider surplus-ship purchase, including Abercrombie-class monitors with 14-inch guns, but the video deliberately excludes them.
- 47:44If the opening torpedoes hit Nidaros insteadNotable Point
Nidaros might absorb the first torpedo spread and answer at point-blank range, turning a quick ambush into a costly close-quarters fight.
- 50:11A point-blank salvo against Wilhelm HeidkampNotable Point
While Eidsvold negotiates, Nidaros can train her guns and strike Wilhelm Heidkamp with 9.2-inch shells at less than a kilometer.
- 54:24Three Norwegian ships contest the harborChapter
Eidsvold and Nidaros reach Norge before German landings settle the battle, forcing troop-laden destroyers to fight three supporting armored ships.
- 56:22Surviving warships change Sundlo's surrender calculusNotable Point
Destroyer losses could reduce the German landing to only hundreds of troops while Norwegian ships provide fire support, making an immediate surrender much harder to justify.
- 58:38Narvik becomes a German Pyrrhic victoryChapter
The projected result is a German victory bought with most of the destroyer force and many mountain troops, allowing faster Allied intervention at Narvik.