Video
Empire Total War Twitch Stream 5(March 2023)
Study Empire Total War Twitch Stream 5(March 2023), a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 13 Mar 2023, with 44 time notes. Topics include Age Of Sail, British Empire, Campaign Strategy.
Time notes
- 5:24Rebuilding the Caribbean squadron after pirate lossesChapter
Caribbean losses require new preparations against the pirates, while Portsmouth supplies replacements for the home fleet.
- 9:02Choosing when a naval battle needs hands-on commandNotable Point
Wind, formation handling, and the desire to capture a third rate shape a manually controlled naval engagement.
- 17:36Using warships as shock forces in the gameNotable Point
The game's ships are compared to cavalry: their decisive effect comes from the opening movement and volley, with little staying power afterward.
- 19:02Choosing between prize money and captured shipsNotable Point
Keeping prizes would strengthen the fleet directly, but an apparent sale shifts attention back to building ships and financing the next operation.
- 24:46Building overlapping artillery fields of fireChapter
Guns covering different approaches catch advancing pirate troops in overlapping fire, while fences and a wall provide protection.
- 40:10Turning a captured pirate position into a forward baseNotable Point
A captured pirate position supports an army base and a forward fleet intended to threaten Martinique if France declares war.
- 41:45QuestionWhat is the difference between Empire: Total War and Napoleon: Total War?AnswerQ&A
Napoleon develops Empire's systems further. The preference here is for Empire because Napoleon feels too focused on its central figure and his mythology.
- 43:06Protecting artillery with infantry lines and woodland fireNotable Point
An enemy general advances separately from his infantry, while British infantry and woodland sharpshooters protect the gun positions.
- 50:22Questioning the game's generic Indigenous faction templateNotable Point
Clothing and unit choices make the game's Inuit faction look like a recycled version of other Indigenous peoples instead of a distinct society.
- 51:22What Empire's map leaves out of Spanish AmericaNotable Point
Planning an offensive against Spain leads to a critique of the campaign map's compressed and sometimes misplaced representation of the Americas.
- 52:57Russia's expansion complicates a move against DenmarkNotable Point
A proposed move to deny Russia a northern foothold encounters Denmark's Russian alliance and the risk of a wider war.
- 55:58How sponsored travel can supply useful local knowledgeNotable Point
A missionary's reconnaissance role in the game leads to an analogy about sponsors benefiting from the knowledge travellers bring home.
- 58:01Using quiet turns to finance the next campaignsChapter
British shipbuilding, army reconstruction, farms, logging, and channel defence are coordinated during a pause before further offensives.
- 1:01:51Why the campaign map weakens Gibraltar's defensive geographyNotable Point
The game's compressed coastline and separate port lose some of Gibraltar's defensive geography.
- 1:04:57Keeping a fleet ready for Spanish operationsChapter
Comparing the strength of British squadrons leads to a redistribution of ships ahead of operations against Spain.
- 1:06:40Using a winning position to demand technology for peaceNotable Point
Spain's request for peace becomes an opportunity to demand technology and concessions within the campaign's diplomacy system.
- 1:08:31Coordinating several campaign axes across North AmericaChapter
Several British armies are positioned to support threatened regions before advancing on separate objectives across North America.
- 1:20:09Reassessing Britain's garrison as Russia growsNotable Point
An expectation that Russia will attempt an invasion makes Britain's thin home garrison a concern.
- 1:31:40Using cavalry movements to distract the Spanish armyChapter
Visible cavalry repeatedly draws the Spanish formation toward new threats while concealed British troops move elsewhere at New Orleans.
- 1:39:37Damaging a siege army's prospects by destroying its gunsNotable Point
Losses among Spanish cavalry and artillery could decide the next siege battle even if the immediate fight goes badly for Britain.
- 1:43:29Using terrain to bring artillery around the Spanish lineNotable Point
Covered movement and a cavalry threat let British guns reach a position from which they can rake the Spanish line at New Orleans.
- 1:54:20Weighing friendly-fire risk against concentrated supportNotable Point
In this game attack, concentrated support is judged to outweigh the friendly-fire risk to infantry expected to hold its position.
- 1:57:27Breaking infantry squares with artillery and infantryNotable Point
Artillery disrupts a square, infantry attacks the broken formation, and cavalry pursues once it runs.
- 1:58:14Winning a duel while losing the wider battleNotable Point
A Leman Russ example illustrates how anger and fixation on one opponent can conceal a surrounding force.
- 2:05:20What 'father' signaled in Roman political languageNotable Point
A fictional leadership dispute leads to an explanation of 'father' as deference to an elder's authoritative wisdom rather than a literal family claim.
- 2:09:02Drawing raiders out of woodland before fightingNotable Point
Local raid damage is accepted so an enemy force leaves woodland suited to ambushes and advances onto less favorable ground.
- 2:09:49QuestionWas the Emperor to blame because he failed to explain his plan to his subordinates?AnswerQ&A
Not necessarily: large commands assign objectives and coordinate activity without giving every subordinate the leader's complete information.
- 2:17:08QuestionIf Angron struggled to lead a small group, how could he be expected to understand running an empire?AnswerQ&A
Some of the Imperium's leaders were suddenly given roles for which they had not been trained. That lack of preparation is treated as an institutional problem.
- 2:38:18Acting before every uncertainty is resolvedNotable Point
A leader can lack both necessary information and awareness of what is missing, yet still face a decision that requires risk.
- 2:48:48Russian gains in Scandinavia and the move against IcelandChapter
Russian expansion makes a future war with Britain appear likely while a quick operation against Denmark and Iceland is still being considered.
- 2:52:14How raids give an opponent time to reinforceNotable Point
Spanish raids leave time to enlarge the defending army and prepare an offensive intended to stop further incursions.
- 2:58:23How a defender gives away terrain and tempoNotable Point
An outnumbered defending army abandons useful high ground and advances, allowing the nominal attacker to dictate the battle's pace.
- 3:08:12Fixing the enemy with infantry before a cavalry flank attackNotable Point
The planned attack uses infantry to hold the enemy's attention while cavalry descends on its rear from a hill.
- 3:11:12Financing a British response to Russian expansionNotable Point
Britain's campaign income is treated as the resource that could let it match Russia's expanding armies.
- 3:20:02The cost of using a general as heavy cavalryNotable Point
Losing a general exposes the tradeoff between another mounted fighting unit and the command abilities that general provides.
- 3:23:47Moving artillery onto a ridge without leaving it exposedNotable Point
Guns need a clear view of the enemy, but reaching the right ridge also requires an escort and supporting troops.
- 3:26:09How emergent campaigns challenge historical inevitabilityNotable Point
Random runs of capable digital generals and unexpected events can make empires rise or fall without any contact with the player.
- 3:30:28Lord Granby, Lord Germain, and command rivalryNotable Point
Jealousy over Granby's potential credit is offered as an explanation for Germain's refusal to permit a charge, followed by criticism of his later direction of the war in America.
- 3:33:29Using one routed unit to spread panicNotable Point
Breaking one formation can start a wider collapse when its flight carries disorder through the rest of the line.
- 3:34:44Poland-Lithuania survives the Russian advanceNotable Point
A map check corrects the assumption that Poland-Lithuania has disappeared and identifies the powers still resisting Russia.
- 3:35:18Using Ceylon to limit Maratha expansion in IndiaChapter
The campaign's closing review turns Ceylon into a strategic foothold for checking the Maratha Confederacy without abandoning naval options elsewhere.
- 3:40:17Using a ridge to spoil enemy artillery fireNotable Point
A low ridge gives troops some protection by increasing the risk that enemy cannon fire will fall short or overshoot.
- 3:42:11A Maratha campaign that reverses Alexander's routeNotable Point
A recalled Maratha playthrough carries expansion from India into Europe and the Americas, prompting a reflection on alternative historical outcomes.
- 3:45:55Using Agincourt to explain collapsing assault wavesNotable Point
Successive game attacks prompt an Agincourt analogy: early failures leave disorder that makes each later wave harder to organize and advance.