Video
Bruships 105: Six Age of Sail Useful Books
Study Bruships 105: Six Age of Sail Useful Books, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 5 Mar 2023, with 70 time notes. Topics include Age Of Sail, Naval Doctrine, Naval History.
Time notes
- 1:23QuestionDid the vibration problems in Washington and North Carolina continue into the South Dakota and Iowa classes?AnswerQ&A
No. They were hard to fix once built into the North Carolinas, but understanding the problem allowed later designers to remove it.
- 1:42QuestionWould the proposed Resistance ships form a slower Revenge subclass used for convoy duties?AnswerQ&A
They were still Revenges and would perform the same duties. A substantially different alternative would be three Renown-style battlecruisers.
- 5:33When construction changes justify a subclassNotable Point
Slightly longer Queen Elizabeths illustrate batch changes, while the Town-class cruisers show the larger changes that justify subclasses.
- 10:14QuestionWhat changes if the Royal Navy enters the Washington negotiations with more surviving battleships and battlecruisers?AnswerQ&A
Probably only a somewhat larger tonnage allowance; the old ships would mainly serve as placeholders until Britain could replace them with new construction.
- 11:25Why ships from one class could differ between yardsNotable Point
Yards adapted common designs to their facilities and methods, with central control limiting those changes more closely in the Royal Navy.
- 12:25QuestionWould a Royal Navy captain who became an admiral in a foreign navy return with that higher rank recognized?AnswerQ&A
No. He would still be a Royal Navy captain, although he might be appointed commodore for a particular command.
- 13:40QuestionIf there were two Tiger-class battlecruisers, which one would survive the treaty reductions?AnswerQ&A
Whichever ship was in the best condition.
- 16:28Why historians must keep each navy's class distinctionsNotable Point
A design difference that the Royal Navy treated as a variant could define a separate class in another navy.
- 18:24QuestionWould Britain leave an officer in command of a useful allied navy and use the post to train or employ more officers?AnswerQ&A
Yes, if the ally and assignment remained useful; British officers could stay and others might follow, as service aboard Russian ships illustrates.
- 18:51QuestionHow much would GPS help a French Age of Sail fleet?AnswerQ&A
It would improve navigation, but it could not remove the constraints of wind, tide, current, and the routes fleets had to use.
- 21:01QuestionDid the Royal Navy become stricter about shipyard and engine variations after the Orlando problems?AnswerQ&A
Yes, especially for machinery: engines increasingly had to meet specified performance, and the Navy's buying power reshaped the supplier market.
- 23:06QuestionIf HMS Tiger survived the treaty period, how might the Royal Navy modernize and employ her in the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
She could receive a major reconstruction and serve as another fast capital ship for raider hunting, Norway, the South Atlantic, or the Far East.
- 25:01QuestionWould War Office or Admiralty service normally earn a returning captain a plum appointment such as commodore?AnswerQ&A
It might, but only depending on his performance, the period, and his political connections; no appointment was automatic.
- 26:17How the Formidables combined earlier battleship designsNotable Point
British pre-dreadnought development included changes within classes and new designs combining features from earlier ships.
- 28:31QuestionHow did Royal Navy spending compare with the British Army budget during the pre-1914 naval race?AnswerQ&A
The Navy's central budget was often larger, but the comparison is distorted because major imperial land forces were funded outside the British Army total.
- 30:16QuestionWhich navies were most likely to enter a battleship numbers race?AnswerQ&A
Britain and America were more prone to technological competition; France and Italy were better matched for a numerical race, while Japan risked bankruptcy against the United States.
- 31:59QuestionHow might Renown and Tiger fare against Scharnhorst and Gneisenau?AnswerQ&A
The British pair could inflict severe damage, especially if both carried 15-inch guns, but the result would depend on hits, German manoeuvres, and luck.
- 32:55Why no-retreat simulations exaggerate naval battle lossesNotable Point
Standalone Ultimate Admiral: Dreadnoughts simulations exaggerate losses when neither side can withdraw; the campaign permits escape.
- 34:41QuestionHow would eight Revenge-class ships and additional retained battlecruisers affect the Royal Navy by 1939?AnswerQ&A
They would provide enough capital ships for several battle squadrons and wider fast-ship deployments, while encouraging faster reconstructions and fast Nelson-class designs.
- 39:19The component evidence behind an 18-inch Agincourt hypothesisNotable Point
An 18-inch-gun Agincourt remains a hypothesis based on machinery and gun-program timing.
- 46:23QuestionWould a 28-knot battleship count as a fast battleship?AnswerQ&A
Yes for the 1920s and 1930s: about 28 knots is the entry point, although later fast battleships were quicker.
- 47:16HMS Africa's solitary approach at TrafalgarNotable Point
HMS Africa's individual approach effectively created a one-ship third British column at Trafalgar.
- 48:29QuestionWould the Royal Navy accept a Type 22 frigate with neither Exocet nor a 4.5-inch gun?AnswerQ&A
Probably not. Batch 1 Type 22s omitted the gun because they carried Exocet; removing both would go too far.
- 49:27QuestionCould a Queen Elizabeth-derived battlecruiser move a turret from the after position to an amidships position?AnswerQ&A
Not as a simple variant: moving the turret would force a redesign of the ship's internal arrangement and hull form.
- 54:40How a gun deck shifted between combat and daily lifeNotable Point
Tables and benches on a sailing warship's gun deck were moved to clear the guns, then returned for eating and everyday work.
- 56:14QuestionCan professional naval war games use commercial rules with accurate performance data for the systems?AnswerQ&A
They can use commercial frameworks, but real performance estimates are sensitive and may be altered or withheld even when intelligence-informed assumptions are used.
- 1:00:04QuestionWhat changes if Exocet is unavailable?AnswerQ&A
Harpoon would play a larger role, alongside older anti-ship missiles and the surface-attack capabilities of air-defence missiles.
- 1:05:57A guide to the steam battleship's emergenceChapter
Andrew Lambert's Battleships in Transition is recommended for understanding how fleets moved from the Napoleonic era toward steam battleships.
- 1:11:26QuestionWould a Type 22 without anti-ship missiles be rejected and cancelled as part of a deliberate weakening of British defence?AnswerQ&A
The Navy would fit a gun instead. The criticism concerns poor funding and defence organization; the claim of a deliberate plan to weaken Britain is rejected.
- 1:13:27Why steamship scarcity forced mixed Crimean War fleetsNotable Point
Britain needed steam battleships in both the Baltic and Black Sea, but too few existed to avoid mixed fleets of steam and sailing ships.
- 1:15:46Emergency conversions for Russia, new battleships for FranceNotable Point
The Royal Navy converted available 80-gun ships for immediate war service while reserving first-rate new construction for the longer-term French challenge.
- 1:17:17How political support shaped Walker's steam-fleet programmeNotable Point
Graham's replacement by Charles Wood interrupted further construction, although Walker retained authority to direct wartime dockyard work.
- 1:17:58How Baltic bombardment needs secured new small craftNotable Point
A need for shallow-water bombardment craft finally overcame resistance to gunboat spending when the program was also justified for postwar coastal defence.
- 1:21:04QuestionDid the United States abandon dogfight training because of its Korean War experience?AnswerQ&A
No. It expected missiles to end close air combat after Korea, but Vietnam disproved that assumption and helped bring specialist dogfight training back.
- 1:22:35QuestionDid coal smoke foul the sails of ships that combined steam and sail?AnswerQ&A
Yes, but sails were furled when steaming so smoke could escape, and crews could clean the soot afterward.
- 1:27:26QuestionHow might a more successful turboprop air war in Korea affect British naval aviation?AnswerQ&A
It could slow Britain's shift toward new air-defence assumptions and make the Royal Navy reassess the value of its turboprop aircraft.
- 1:29:47The fire that destroyed HMS Glasgow at Montego BayNotable Point
A rum theft started the 1779 fire aboard HMS Glasgow, while the crew's effort to remove the powder prevented a wider disaster at Montego Bay.
- 1:31:24How Nelson's testimony corrects the HMS Glasgow rescue storyNotable Point
Nelson's own court-martial statement credits Captain Thomas Lloyd and HMS Glasgow's crew, undercutting later biographies that made Nelson the sole rescuer.
- 1:35:51Why Nelson's promotion to post-captain at twenty matteredNotable Point
A frigate appointment put the twenty-year-old Nelson on the captains' list and left him time to advance toward flag rank.
- 1:37:08QuestionWould more Soviet work on axial-flow compressors necessarily give the MiG-15 a better engine in time?AnswerQ&A
Possibly not: the engine might improve, but the extra development could delay it until after the period when it was needed.
- 1:37:29QuestionWhich naval conspiracy theory is most plausible, and which is the worst misreading of the evidence?AnswerQ&A
The Tsushima story is dismissed as baseless. Cargo fears followed by a parted boat line offer a proposed explanation for Mary Celeste's abandonment.
- 1:42:01Use battle honours to find a naval story worth pursuingChapter
David Thomas's battles-and-honours reference lets readers work from a ship, squadron, or campaign name to the action behind it.
- 1:44:49Fleet Air Arm honours connect successive warsNotable Point
The honours of 800, 801, and 809 Naval Air Squadrons trace Fleet Air Arm service from the Second World War through Korea and the Falklands.
- 1:46:35HMS Surprise recaptures Hermione at Puerto CabelloNotable Point
Captain Edward Hamilton's HMS Surprise recovered the former HMS Hermione from Spanish service in a cutting-out action at Puerto Cabello in 1799.
- 1:48:17QuestionWhat might the Royal Navy have done if the Arctic had been reliably ice-free in the Age of Sail?AnswerQ&A
It would gain new routes against Russia and toward the Pacific, substantially changing the strategic geography of northern waters.
- 1:50:29San Sebastián honours reveal naval support ashoreNotable Point
In 1813, Collier's squadron evacuated troops, supported General Graham, and blockaded the French-held town of San Sebastián.
- 2:04:33QuestionHow many additional Scharnhorst-class ships might Germany have built instead of Bismarck and Tirpitz?AnswerQ&A
Roughly four to six additional ships, given the time and resources available.
- 2:10:45QuestionHow long could eight Type 82 destroyers remain in service, given their steam machinery?AnswerQ&A
Their service life would depend on the extent of modernization. Replacing the steam installation with a second gas plant could extend it.
- 2:11:23QuestionHow would a mixed Type 82 and Type 42 fleet affect the choice between quality and quantity after Falklands losses?AnswerQ&A
Replacement orders would depend on which ships were lost and whether both designs remained in production.
- 2:16:17How piracy endangered English trade with the Mughal EmpireChapter
Indian Ocean piracy exposed the East India Company to Mughal retaliation and forced it to protect shipping attacked by other Englishmen.
- 2:16:17How William III's accession weakened the East India Company's positionNotable Point
Dynastic change exposed the East India Company to a difficult Dutch alliance and political support for competitors at home.
- 2:19:23How domestic politics narrowed English strategy before 1701Notable Point
After the Peace of Ryswick, English domestic politics constrained William III even as Caribbean, Baltic, and Spanish succession problems kept demanding maritime attention.
- 2:21:33How Louis XIV provoked another coalition over the Spanish successionNotable Point
French moves over Spain's inheritance threatened Dutch security and Anglo-Dutch commerce, then challenged England's royal succession.
- 2:23:00Why French silver convoys needed large escort squadronsNotable Point
French escorts protected Spanish silver while confronting Spanish distrust, making squadron size a political choice as well as a military one.
- 2:24:48Command of the Ocean as a broad guide to naval historyChapter
Command of the Ocean is recommended as a broad foundation for the political, commercial, and operational context of naval history.
- 2:33:54The Brest blockade beyond the famous fleet actionsChapter
A detailed study of the 1793-1815 Brest blockade shows that keeping a fleet on station was a continuing command and endurance problem.
- 2:37:29Lord Keith's request for an English peerageNotable Point
Keith's request for another peerage places his handling of the Nore mutiny alongside earlier commands and political connections.
- 2:39:05The rotation and intelligence behind the Brest blockadeNotable Point
Keeping the Channel Fleet off Brest required rotating ships for provisions, finding enough frigates, and interpreting reports of French preparations.
- 2:40:23Why experienced captains stayed in frigate commandsNotable Point
The Admiralty kept senior captains such as John Borlase Warren and Edward Pellew in specialist frigate work because their experience outweighed a conventional move to ships of the line.
- 2:42:09Prize money and the Bridport-Pellew disputeNotable Point
Prize-money rules help explain hostility between Bridport and Pellew, but competing biographies warn against treating personal greed as a settled motive.
- 2:49:05Follow a Royal Navy ship name across centuriesChapter
An interactive look-up session shows how a ship-name reference can trace repeated names across very different vessels and wars.
- 2:53:43When two Huron entries may describe the same schoonerNotable Point
Early Huron entries preserve uncertainty over a rebuilt schooner before the name continues through Canadian destroyers.
- 2:55:30QuestionDid any ships named Ardent survive long enough to be scrapped?AnswerQ&A
Yes. An earlier destroyer was sold in 1911, several wooden ships survived, and an Australian patrol boat became a museum ship.
- 3:00:15QuestionWas there ever a Royal Navy ship named Cromwell?AnswerQ&A
Yes. A C-class destroyer briefly carried the name in 1946 before transfer to Norway as Bergen.
- 3:03:53Why Royal Navy launch dates cluster in certain monthsNotable Point
Repeated launch months in ship histories can reflect the timing of government payments and shipyard finance.
- 3:08:04The many Royal Navy ships named AntelopeNotable Point
The name Antelope connects a Tudor galleon, sailing warships, small steam craft, destroyers, and the Type 21 frigate across four centuries.
- 3:12:52QuestionWhat is the most commonly reused Royal Navy ship name?AnswerQ&A
Swallow is the strongest candidate, with the reference work crediting the name to 39 vessels plus several other naval and revenue craft.
- 3:34:38Using dynastic histories when a battle study is hard to obtainNotable Point
Cambridge histories of the Song dynasty and its successor provide context when a dedicated battle study is difficult to obtain.
- 3:37:30QuestionHow can a historian research Admiral Yi when the available material is in Korean?AnswerQ&A
Seek help from Korean readers and academic contacts who can work with the material.
- 3:59:41QuestionWas the old battleship packed with cork successfully made into an unsinkable target?AnswerQ&A
Cork made the target very difficult to sink. The exercise measured confirmed hits, so firing did not have to continue until the ship was destroyed.