The Commando Order was a written war crime
The Hague rules and 1929 Geneva Convention protected surrendered troops, while Hitler's Commando Order explicitly commanded their killing.
Complete directory
Browse all time notes.
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
What is known - and uncertain - about the raiders' deaths
Six captured Marines were executed and two died from exposure, even though locations and dates in the surviving execution record remain uncertain.
Was Operation Frankton worth its cost?
The raid's shipping and logistical effects made it strategically worthwhile, although eight deaths remain a severe human cost.
High-risk orders also burden the commanders
Commanders who authorize necessary operations may also carry the knowledge that volunteers will probably die.
Why simply enlarging the raid might have failed
Sending more submarines and kayaks could have produced diminishing returns by making the force easier to discover and revealing the true nature of the attack.
HMS Cossack's original L03 pennant number
Cossack's original pennant was L03, before the more familiar F03 and G03 numbers.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
The proposed sister ship to HMS Unicorn
HMS Seahorse was the intended name for a sister to HMS Unicorn, with HMS Ocean also mentioned as an option.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Extra Tribal and J/K/N destroyers or more escort sloops
Extra sloops are preferred to more Tribal- and J/K/N-class destroyers because of their expected effect on submarine losses early in World War II.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
The source problem behind incomplete German carriers
Incomplete German carrier projects are difficult to compare because surviving detail is sparse and much of the usable technical record rests on a small source base.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Bligh and Codrington in a modern navy
Codrington's outlook might translate to a Cold War navy, while Bligh is judged too closely shaped by the command culture of his own era.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
How an expanded Tribal class might be named
Further Tribal-class ships would probably continue drawing names from peoples across the British Empire rather than immediately switching to ancient British tribes.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Why the Royal Navy rejected a torpedo cruiser
A proposed torpedo-cruiser conversion of HMS Eagle illustrates why the Royal Navy did not pursue a Kitakami-style ship.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Comparing American, Italian, and Japanese naval failures
The three navies' shortcomings arose from different constraints, with the United States drawing the sharpest criticism because it began from the strongest position.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
The 1939 Royal Navy against the High Seas Fleet
A 1939 British fleet sent to Jutland would combine longer-ranged guns, radar, and carrier reconnaissance against an opponent unable to answer naval aviation.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Forty County-class cruisers and the treaty system
A Royal Navy with all forty desired County-class cruisers would force a different 1930 treaty bargain and confront Japan with harder choices between battleships and cruisers.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
The wartime Ark Royal reappears during the Falklands War
The wartime Ark Royal, saved from her torpedo loss and returned for the Falklands War, could probably operate Harriers and helicopters after modifications.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
How the US Navy might answer a 1941 carrier warning
Advance warning of the 1942 carrier crisis would push the US Navy to accelerate whichever ships were already closest to completion.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Germany's missing Atlantic reconnaissance network
Aircraft-carrying submarines would not solve Germany's Atlantic problem; it needed far more long-range patrol aircraft to find convoys and direct U-boats.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Why the Admiral Hipper class used tonnage inefficiently
The Admiral Hipper design accumulated specialized systems where simpler general-purpose equipment could have saved weight and support burden.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Why a Zeppelin scout carrier would be short-lived
A Zeppelin carrying scouts over the Atlantic could extend German reconnaissance, but radio emissions, low speed, and limited aircraft capacity would make it a priority British target.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
County-class cruisers at Denmark Strait
A forty-ship County-class fleet would probably put more cruisers alongside Hood and Prince of Wales at Denmark Strait.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Why there is no simple first frigate
The frigate emerged through an evolution of hull form and terminology, making it difficult to identify one universally accepted first class.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Tribal-class destroyers with Taffy 3
Tribal-class destroyers would greatly increase Taffy 3's shellfire, although Japanese cruisers would retain a major combat advantage.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
How Bofors and pom-poms might divide the fleet
With both weapons available early, Bofors would suit screening cruisers and destroyers while pom-poms supplied dense inner fire around capital ships and carriers.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
HMS Sheffield's repeated battleship encounters
Sheffield is tentatively accepted as a leading candidate, but the comparison is made from memory.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Why Britain retained a large navy after 1945
Britain's postwar fleet reflected maritime trade and imperial commitments rather than a secret Anglo-American arrangement, while rapid US demobilization temporarily increased the British burden.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
A Royal Navy built around triple turrets
Making triple turrets standard from HMS Tiger onward would reshape British capital ships and provoke heavier American gun layouts.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Choosing advanced radar or working gas turbines in the 1930s
Knowledge that mature 1943 radar works would reinforce development already under way, while a complete gas-turbine package in 1933 would introduce a more radical propulsion opportunity.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Beatty's circular searches after losing contact
The reply associates circular searching with the Jutland runs south and north and other occasions, without locating a precise manoeuvre.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Hunting Moltke with the East Asia Squadron
A German battlecruiser in the East Asia Squadron would draw multiple British battlecruisers, and possibly Japanese Kongos, into a much larger hunt.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Why Renown did not need ten torpedo tubes
A ten-tube Renown was physically possible but operationally misguided because torpedoes were insurance, not the battlecruiser's principal weapon.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Would the US Navy retain the Montanas after the war?
Probably, although the reply does not specify how many ships would remain or in what status.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Starting points for British submarine history
Norman Friedman's technical work, studies of the Malta-based Tenth Submarine Flotilla, and Periscope Patrol are recommended starting points.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
German success against Royal Navy codes
Germany achieved some codebreaking successes, but frequent British code changes and weaker German intelligence access limited their value.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Why Italian torpedo boats did well against submarines
Italian torpedo boats combined a small target profile with close familiarity with Mediterranean waters, making them awkward opponents for submarines.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Clemenceau-class carriers in the Falklands
Replacing the Invincible-class ships with French Clemenceau-class carriers would give the Falklands task force substantially more capacity for Harriers and helicopters.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Frigate options after HMS Trent's Venezuela deployment
A Constellation-class frigate or Type 31 is suggested as a suitable next step, if available.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Swordfish aircraft against Falklands-era defenses
A counterfactual tests slow Swordfish aircraft against Argentine defenses and highlights their possible utility against helicopters.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Why Bofors did not replace the pom-pom before 1939
The Royal Navy did not simply reject Bofors; existing pom-pom production and the timing of newer weapons constrained adoption.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
The Royal Navy's most powerful commissioned battleship
Vanguard was the most powerful British battleship actually commissioned, while the Queen Elizabeth class made the strongest impact relative to its own era.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Japan's independent submarine tradition
The Imperial Japanese Navy developed its own submarine technology and operating ideas rather than simply copying German practice.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
The risk of bypassing Luzon and the Philippines
Theoretically yes, but the resulting risk to the force is judged too great.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Peak wartime equipment at Pearl Harbor
Giving both Pearl Harbor forces their best later-war equipment would not save a fleet that remained tactically surprised and unprepared.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
A carrier raid on the High Seas Fleet
A successful First World War carrier raid would establish a precedent for harbor attack without preventing later planners from believing newer defenses had solved the problem.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Brigs as the age of sail's unsung workhorses
Small 18-gun brigs performed much of the routine work commonly associated with frigates but receive far less historical attention.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Why European rivals did not simply outgun Nelson
Treaty limits constrained the response, while greater speed offered a way to avoid an unfavourable encounter.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
Why navies build specialized support ships
Purpose-built tenders become economical when the workshops, stores, and internal arrangements needed for support would require rebuilding most of a merchant hull.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·
A new quad Bofors or a reworked pom-pom?
A quadruple Bofors would be acceptable; developing the newer weapon is preferred to rebuilding the old pom-pom concept.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! ·