Notable Point · 3:38:32 An announcement of Yamato's capabilities could have provoked political demands for larger Allied battleships after existing construction plans were committed.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 3:40:22 Open-ocean interception is difficult, but operational requirements draw capital ships into approaches and confined waters where submarines can threaten them.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 3:45:18 An interpretation of Force Z's communications failure distinguishes the Navy's request for fighters from the Air Force's understanding of strike support.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 3:46:59 A surviving Force Z could anchor a stronger ABDA fleet, with British carriers attacking at night and Saratoga following at dawn.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 3:50:07 A hypothetical T-class screen trades scarce submarine availability and a large torpedo salvo against the chance of hitting Japanese capital ships.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:00:00 Preventive magazine flooding would begin when penetration or an imminent threat made ignition likely.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:00:42 A larger German building program would give Britain an earlier reason to fund shipyards, armour production, battleships, and carriers.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 4:04:04 A participant's account links the nationality of industrial ownership to efforts to resist Nazi seizure of steel-making assets.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 4:05:41 A proposed 20-inch battery raises the cost of increasing calibre in reload time and distinguishes a prestige flagship from practical fleet construction.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:07:50 Eagle's better accident record than Ark Royal's is attributed to chance rather than an identified design advantage.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:09:01 An all-forward main battery would improve the design without settling what the Deutschland class should be used for.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 4:12:11 An alternate-history British flagship exposes conflicts between heavy-gun blast, Sea Dart readiness, Sea Wolf launch paths, and satellite communications.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:19:56 Japan's supply of trained maintainers limited how widely the Navy could adopt labor-saving machinery.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:21:04 Powered shell handling illustrates how machinery could reduce work aboard a battleship while retaining people to supervise it.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:23:23 Turret weight remained a serious objection to the Roc even if it was intended as a stopgap.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:25:03 The Roc's fighter requirement came from interservice procurement bargaining surrounding the Skua and RAF turret fighters.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:25:45 A simple anti-submarine escort with single 5-inch guns, depth charges, and 40 mm weapons fits the American destroyer-escort role.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:26:22 A proposal for two Tigers depends on orders predating a First Sea Lord who would favor fast battleships.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:27:03 Four improved Hosho-type carriers could add scouting and fighter decks, but combining those duties with strike aircraft would strain protection and fuel safety.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:28:58 Continued investment in the CL-84's tilt-wing concept offered more promise than adapting its four experimental aircraft directly for combat service.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:30:53 Labor-saving rigging, rerigged French prizes, and mechanized block manufacture reduced the people and provisions a ship needed.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 4:32:40 Magazine capacity and the short time available to engage an aircraft can justify more expensive VT-fuzed ammunition.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:34:28 Thirty-three Skuas could provide Finnish interception and close air support, with an explicit limitation against Soviet I-15 and I-16 fighters.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:41:15 A wide carrier flight deck makes dry-dock clearance depend on hull support height and water level as well as displacement.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 4:42:34 A hypothetical carrier's lift arrangement trades sortie generation against weather limits on moving aircraft.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:43:28 A Pacific assignment gives an experimental Soviet carrier a place to develop doctrine away from the Atlantic conditions raised as an objection.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:44:42 Dutch engineers sabotaged useful oilfields despite threats against themselves and their families, obstructing Japan's access to fuel.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 4:45:35 Magazine position can favor flooding over fire after an underwater hit, while loss of a bow or stern need not sink the remaining hull.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:48:12 Earlier German shipbuilding would expose the buildup sooner and give stronger industrial rivals a reason to retain yards and expand their fleets.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:51:05 Bogue-class escort carriers earned their value through rapid construction and timely availability of usable flight decks.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 4:51:31 Imagined Soviet refits show why heavy guns, missile launchers, and anti-submarine helicopter facilities compete for safe deck space.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:54:16 The objection to the King George V class's 14-inch guns concerns supplying three battleship calibers during wartime.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 4:54:47 Varied calibers and old gun stocks complicated standardization while providing weapons for wartime merchant armament.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 4:56:23 Stored naval guns offered tempting replacements after Dunkirk, but adapting them for field use presented practical obstacles.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:57:03 Men rescued alive who later died of wounds are one possible explanation for differing Queen Mary survivor totals.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 4:57:53 Mission, independent deployment, and self-maintenance explain why many modern frigates and destroyers perform cruiser work despite changes in classification.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 5:02:42 A possible testbed role connects the tail-jet Barracuda proposal with the takeoff difficulties of early carrier jets.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 5:03:47 A preference for the P-8 Poseidon rests on the contemporary price advantage attributed to its Boeing 737 airframe.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 5:04:36 Japan planned liner-to-carrier conversions, but additional flight decks outpaced the expansion of its naval air service.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 5:05:33 The US-2's suitability for Japan suggests possible uses in Philippine resupply and other countries with dispersed maritime territory or limited land.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 5:07:50 An extra 1,800 tons for machinery could support a faster Nelson without accepting the damage risk of concentrating its guns in two turrets.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 5:08:38 Matching Halifax's explosion is rejected for conventional battleship magazines; the proposed nuclear exception requires deliberate detonation.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 5:11:24 A hypothetical carrier battle shows how missile versions, rules of engagement and airborne warning could shape the outcome before opposing fighters reach dogfighting range.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 5:14:53 An unrestricted naval buildup beginning in 1935 could accelerate British and American production enough to change European deterrence and the distribution of Britain's defence budget.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 5:18:13 Without treaty limits, Britain could combine armour and two full-height hangars while using smaller or older carriers for less demanding duties.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 5:23:36 A command-cruiser proposal expands missile capacity, aviation facilities and staff accommodation around the Type 45 design.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Q&A · 5:24:41 A longer-lived Reginald Henderson could combine carrier-command experience with procurement continuity, leaving Cunningham free to concentrate on fleet operations.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024
Notable Point · 5:27:10 The Norway command arrangements illustrate a criticism of political appointments that bypass established operational authority, followed by the dispute over Somerville.
From Bruships 154: Ship-Shape's Scandi Ship 2024... answering naval history questions... · 2 Jun 2024