Q&A · 3:06:13 Six twin mounts would consume deck space and topweight needed for torpedoes, machinery, and a seaworthy treaty destroyer.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:07:28 No foreign design is a simple ready-made substitute for Arleigh Burke, and even an imported starting point would need extensive US changes.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 3:11:35 Cutting the Zumwalt class from a large programme to three hulls spread development, ammunition, and shipyard costs across too few ships.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 3:17:17 France's compact FDI frigate illustrates how modern tumblehome forms and dense combat systems can influence thinking about future escorts such as Type 83.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:27:38 The fictional snow cruisers prompt a real comparison: ships can support longer and heavier guns than tanks, so the strongest overlap lies in guidance packages rather than complete weapons.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:30:29 The cancelled strike-cruiser programme is presented as a lost answer to the US Navy's need for large, heavily armed surface combatants.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:34:17 The AW149 benefits from commonality with the UK's existing Leonardo and Merlin support ecosystem.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:38:15 US observation of repaired Royal Navy ships offered useful lessons in armour quality and emergency power arrangements before American entry into the war.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:40:19 A flying-only luxury carrier could operate, but the flight deck would displace the open recreation space that sells a conventional cruise ship.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:41:27 An Essex carrier might land an F/A-18 in exceptional circumstances, but it was not a viable routine operating environment for the type.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:45:45 A modern carrier with its aircraft would be an overwhelming 1940s advantage, though fuel and industrial support still shape its useful life.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:49:04 With limited warning, the first priority would be general quarters, watertight integrity, and air defence rather than a risky immediate sortie.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:55:56 A production Zumwalt air-defence variant could combine its peripheral Mark 57 cells with a large central Mark 41 battery, but three completed hulls cannot replace the Ticonderoga force.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:58:04 F-35-capable light carriers are a plausible entry point for countries that want their own naval air power without a full-size carrier.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 3:59:46 Large cutters may have basic sonar or hydrophone capability, but a full anti-submarine fit across the Coast Guard would be hard to justify.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 4:04:53 Repeated cuts followed by hurried emergency purchases can look decisive while failing to expand the yards or labour actually needed to deliver ships.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 4:06:37 Zumwalt does not need major enlargement to perform a strike-cruiser role because its hull, guns, and strategic-length cells already support that mission.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 4:07:37 A much larger postwar US gun fleet might keep big-gun ships in service longer and prompt analogous foreign projects.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 4:10:34 Triple 15-inch turrets would intensify the cost pressure on Germany more than they would shock a US Navy already building twelve-gun battleships.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 4:16:09 Adding many twin mounts to a destroyer rapidly turns a destroyer into an unstable cruiser-sized design.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 4:19:43 A modern large-calibre gun would impress observers, but its ammunition and guidance would determine whether it created real concern.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 4:22:29 Heavy anti-aircraft armament requires enough beam and hull volume; trying to preserve destroyer dimensions eventually creates a cruiser problem.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 4:26:06 Voting before the general election and participating in local party selection shape which candidates ever reach the final ballot.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 4:29:10 A worldwide cruising warship tends to settle near 10,000 to 15,000 tons because that range balances capability, endurance, and affordable numbers.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 4:29:53 Low-turnout local elections still shape national politics, while observable paper records and cross-party scrutiny provide practical safeguards for ballot handling.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 4:34:33 AI can help summarise material, but database provenance and invented citations make independent source verification essential.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 4:35:54 K31's 6-inch battery retained an established four-turret arrangement instead of multiplying the weight and machinery of eight twin 5.25-inch mounts.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 4:39:21 A firsthand account explains how party agents can monitor a paper-ballot count while leaving election officials room to work.
From Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space.... · 13 Oct 2024
Q&A · 0:51 Tirpitz's deterrent plan depended on Britain accepting German fleet expansion. British counterbuilding instead created an arms race Germany could not win.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Q&A · 5:36 Postwar American support for British naval capability shows why alliance assistance can be generous while still serving the donor's strategic interests.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 8:17 An alleged reversal over Meteor integration with the F-35 raises questions about industrial rivalry and unequal bargaining power between allies.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 10:46 American alignment with Britain during the Falklands War shows how governments rank competing alliance obligations by strategic value.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Q&A · 12:37 A carrier's ship's company and air wing do not necessarily include the embarked admiral's staff, helping explain apparently conflicting personnel totals.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Q&A · 14:35 Drone range and targeting constrain attacks on moving carriers, while production volume and stockpiles affect the cost and endurance of their defence.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 16:41 Continued Russian and Ukrainian air operations illustrate why missile and drone threats alone do not establish that airfields or carriers are unusable.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 17:37 Small missile orders spread research costs over fewer weapons and deny manufacturers dependable production volume, helping explain high interceptor prices.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 19:04 Attacking merchant traffic in a known shipping lane does not demonstrate the ability to locate and strike a carrier battle group over a wide operating area.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Q&A · 20:02 The manpower and support burden of even two retired American nuclear carriers could exceed the scale of an allied navy expected to operate them.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 21:45 A dock large enough to receive an allied nuclear ship does not give a navy the people, facilities, and routine experience needed to operate its own nuclear surface fleet.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 23:07 Navies that work ships hard as global policing forces may reach retirement with little useful service life left for a secondhand buyer.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Q&A · 25:03 A runway abroad does not replace a carrier unless it can securely support advanced aircraft and the host government permits combat operations from it.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Q&A · 25:18 Hypersonic weapons are not an entirely new defensive problem, but interception becomes harder when a missile crosses the edge of a defended area instead of flying toward the defending ship.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Q&A · 30:22 The Sea Control Ship offered a minimum naval-aviation capability, while the medium CVV proposal aimed to supplement nuclear carriers and preserve both ship numbers and an alternative building yard.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 30:47 A naval proposal can be difficult to identify when an informal name differs from the terminology used in books and archival records.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 33:52 Nuclear carriers reward continuous use but leave no economical reserve hulls to absorb an emergency surge without disrupting the active fleet's maintenance cycle.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Notable Point · 36:20 The County class looks like a high-end force today, although contemporary Royal Navy thinking treated it as a comparatively basic large cruiser.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Q&A · 38:25 A nuclear reactor is part of the carrier's propulsion plant, with refuelling and cautious maintenance built into the wider service-life calculation.
From Scuttlebutt 6: Responding to some History Hot Takes... · 12 Oct 2024
Chapter · 9:29 Beatty's wealth and political connections gave him unusual freedom over appointments, while his command strengths favoured a small, independent force.
From V.Adm Beatty is sent to Command the Mediterranean Battle Cruisers in 1914... Patreon 105 · 10 Oct 2024