Video
Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space....
Study Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space...., a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 13 Oct 2024, with 80 time notes. Topics include Aircraft Carriers, Live Q&A, Naval…
Time notes
- 7:32QuestionHow was a warship keel made in the 1930s?AnswerQ&A
It was built up from heavy steel sections and plates, often with secondary keels.
- 8:19QuestionIs it illegal for the Royal Fleet Auxiliary to strike?AnswerQ&A
Not in peacetime; during wartime service it comes under Royal Navy regulations.
- 10:31QuestionWhat force would be needed to assault the Dutch East Indies in a sailing-age war?AnswerQ&A
Use infantry, fighting ships, and third rates to protect the supply convoys that sustain the force.
- 13:00QuestionDid navies besides Japan experiment with dedicated anti-submarine shells in the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
Yes. The Royal Navy and US Navy tried them, and modern concepts may be useful against underwater drones and mines.
- 14:47QuestionWho was the most influential single person in the Second World War apart from the major national leaders?AnswerQ&A
It is hard to isolate one person: the officers coordinating Allied logistics and convoys mattered as a collective system.
- 18:56Why Admiral Yonai refused a naval carNotable Point
Mitsumasa Yonai's habit of walking and using public transport is presented as a deliberate rejection of official transport and status.
- 19:54Alan Brooke, Churchill, and self-serving memoirsNotable Point
Claims that one senior officer managed Churchill are treated as memoir evidence that must be checked against authorship, incentives, and contemporary relationships.
- 22:17QuestionWhat book would you recommend on the naval and air side of the Falklands War rather than the land campaign?AnswerQ&A
The exchange recommends Air Defence at Sea, with particular attention to its appendices.
- 23:21QuestionWhich Second World War battle would the Italian Navy benefit from most if it had a carrier?AnswerQ&A
Matapan is a strong candidate, but early-war operations against British capital ships could matter more.
- 25:11QuestionWould Type 45 destroyers be better multi-role ships with Mark 41 vertical launchers?AnswerQ&A
Yes, Mark 41 would add flexibility, although wider missile roles would bring difficult procurement choices.
- 30:02QuestionWhat if Rivadavia arrived a year early and Argentina joined the Central Powers after Coronel?AnswerQ&A
The ships would be powerful locally, but Argentina would face British sea power, regional opposition, and severe economic pressure.
- 34:22QuestionWould the Malta class or CVA-01 have been better than the Midway class?AnswerQ&A
Malta would have been a broadly equivalent wartime counterpart with different priorities, while the later CVA-01 should have offered important advances.
- 36:20QuestionHow long should a Star Trek starship hull last in production and service if upgrades remain available?AnswerQ&A
Potentially centuries, provided manoeuvre loads are controlled, damaged plating can be replaced, and maintenance remains rigorous.
- 40:37QuestionHow much larger would the crews of bigger Type 45 or Type 83-style ships need to be?AnswerQ&A
Probably not dramatically larger: crew totals depend chiefly on system design and staffing rules rather than hull size.
- 48:42QuestionWhat if MacArthur won the 1944 US presidential election and controlled the nuclear button?AnswerQ&A
He would likely seek a more forceful personal role in ending both wars, with unpredictable consequences for relations with Stalin and the Pacific.
- 54:45QuestionHow effective was the Grumman AF Guardian concept of paired sensor and weapons aircraft?AnswerQ&A
It was a sensible period solution: one aircraft searched while the other attacked.
- 56:22Aerospace mergers preserve capability and cultureNotable Point
Famous aircraft firms can survive mergers through capabilities and management culture even when their independent names disappear.
- 59:39QuestionDo non-RFA merchant ships also become part of the Royal Navy in wartime?AnswerQ&A
Only in some cases: ships taken under naval control can be subject to naval rules, while ordinary convoy merchants remain merchant ships.
- 1:00:37QuestionHow useful would a battleship's very large high-angle main-gun battery and magazine be?AnswerQ&A
The ammunition would be valuable, but turret, magazine, elevation, and hull-stress constraints make the arrangement extremely demanding.
- 1:06:36QuestionWhy would the monarchy object to naming a Royal Navy ship Cromwell when the British Army used the name for a tank?AnswerQ&A
Cromwell's regicide and republican symbolism made the name awkward for the Royal Navy, while the Army's mixed royalist and parliamentary inheritance changed its institutional meaning.
- 1:11:03QuestionHow would a modern cruiser armed with modern versions of County-class guns compare with earlier cruisers?AnswerQ&A
It would have far better fire control and range, with autoloading twins plausible; gun logistics remain a significant advantage.
- 1:24:24QuestionWhat if King George V-class battleships had upgradeable main armament and uniform turret rings?AnswerQ&A
They could likely appear in batches with 14-inch, 15-inch, and eventually 16-inch guns without an initial construction delay.
- 1:27:13Why HMS Cromwell was easier to accept as a destroyerNotable Point
A wartime destroyer among hundreds of hulls carried less symbolic weight than naming a capital ship after Oliver Cromwell.
- 1:32:45QuestionWhat single supply delivery, or failure to deliver, had the greatest effect on history?AnswerQ&A
Congo uranium for the Manhattan Project is a leading candidate, but Malta relief shows the wider strategic importance of supply.
- 1:36:10QuestionWhat if USS Indianapolis had been sunk on the way to Tinian?AnswerQ&A
Another heavy cruiser would likely repeat the delivery with an escort, delaying the end of the war by about a month.
- 1:36:37QuestionHow would the pre-First World War naval race change if Germany built only fast capital ships?AnswerQ&A
Britain would build faster capital ships of its own, while German dependence on British turbine expertise would complicate the race.
- 1:39:01Mercantilism, resource control, and imperial powerNotable Point
A short economic-history aside links mercantilist control of resources to European empire building and later command-economy problems.
- 1:40:25How a speed race reshapes propulsion and treaty limitsNotable Point
A German speed challenge would push British and American propulsion choices upward and could make much larger treaty battleships politically normal.
- 1:48:58QuestionWhich Second World War ships would be most useful in the Falklands War if suitably modernised?AnswerQ&A
Large fleet carriers for Harriers, plus battleships for bombardment, would provide the largest operational gain.
- 1:55:56QuestionWould a Malta-class carrier completed after the Second World War have lasted longer than Ark Royal?AnswerQ&A
Probably yes; Malta's size and strong flight deck would make heavy-aircraft operation and long-term modernisation more practical.
- 1:57:31QuestionHow would the Second World War change if an island containing Great Britain as it existed in 1812 appeared west of Ireland?AnswerQ&A
After an authority crisis, its greatest value would be retrainable manpower, food, timber, and protected production space rather than its wooden warships.
- 2:01:57Carrier groups built around the Malta classNotable Point
Three operational Malta-class carriers, backed by a fourth in refit or reserve, could reorganise the Royal Navy around durable carrier groups.
- 2:10:35QuestionWhat would Britain do if Argentina built battleships with 12 15-inch guns and heavy 9.2-inch secondaries?AnswerQ&A
Britain would build more powerful counterweights; the heavy secondary battery is not treated as a decisive advantage.
- 2:15:21QuestionWhy would the United States not simply export the F-22 to allied countries?AnswerQ&A
Congress barred exports, the production system would have to be restarted, and allies were directed toward the F-35 instead.
- 2:24:19QuestionWhat was Indomitable's hangar height, and could it accommodate a Harrier?AnswerQ&A
With approximately 14- and 16-foot hangars, it could accommodate a Sea Harrier with a little over a foot of clearance.
- 2:26:33QuestionIs a modern torpedo simply an underwater missile?AnswerQ&A
In some ways, but its underwater medium and usual wire-guided or fire-and-forget control arrangements still distinguish it.
- 2:26:59QuestionWhat would the major naval powers do if each received a Lexington-class hull and a connected slipway in 1910?AnswerQ&A
They would probably complete the hull as a battlecruiser, but powers with the strongest supporting industry would gain most from the extra slipway.
- 2:28:51QuestionWhat is the largest-bore autoloading naval gun fitted to an active-duty ship?AnswerQ&A
The US Navy's 8-inch cruiser guns were the largest autoloading naval guns in service.
- 2:29:19QuestionCould railgun technology be combined with a VLS to boost missiles into the air as a cold-launch system?AnswerQ&A
Possibly, but existing cold-launch systems already provide that function without the extra rail mechanism.
- 2:29:53QuestionCould 6-inch naval guns return on surface combatants in response to hypersonic threats?AnswerQ&A
Possibly. A 6-inch system would be a manageable and meaningful capability increase over 5-inch guns.
- 2:32:23QuestionWill European navies beat the United States at underway VLS replenishment because Sylver is less complicated?AnswerQ&A
Not necessarily. Replenishing missiles at sea is difficult regardless of launcher family, and the US has already demonstrated part of the process.
- 2:33:29QuestionHow useful would Ning Hai-class cruisers be if they escaped to form a Free Chinese navy in Australia?AnswerQ&A
They would make useful convoy escorts and could be converted toward an anti-aircraft destroyer role.
- 2:35:12QuestionHow long can the early Arleigh Burke-class destroyers last, and could early ships retire before the last is built?AnswerQ&A
Yes. The earliest ships may retire around their mid-thirties as hard use, maintenance costs, and replacement schedules catch up with them.
- 2:41:49QuestionWhy were Iowa-class battleships not refitted with 16-inch nuclear shells during the Reagan buildup?AnswerQ&A
The shells were too large and politically problematic for the operational benefit they offered.
- 2:42:43QuestionHow much faster would Queen Elizabeth-class battleships be with small-tube boilers?AnswerQ&A
About 26 knots is plausible; reaching 28 knots would likely require a longer hull as well as the boilers.
- 2:44:11QuestionWhat naval programme is most comparable to the Atari 2600 fiasco?AnswerQ&A
The Littoral Combat Ship: it looked compelling on paper, but its speed-led design did not deliver the combat capability or endurance required.
- 2:54:39QuestionDo people underestimate why ships, aircraft, and helicopters eventually need replacement?AnswerQ&A
Often. Age is only one factor; operating intensity, upgrades, maintenance, and mission demands are equally important.
- 2:58:22QuestionWhat did you think of the Starship test flight and booster catch?AnswerQ&A
It was an impressive engineering result, and the programme's research can yield broad benefits without requiring uncritical admiration of its public figurehead.
- 3:00:13Defence systems manage risk rather than become invulnerableNotable Point
Armed forces and aircraft carriers are justified by the risks they manage, not by a promise that any platform will be impossible to defeat.
- 3:02:24QuestionHow could Nelson and Rodney be designed as fast 16-inch battlecruisers while retaining an upgrade path to heavier armour?AnswerQ&A
Build them with provision for the intended armour, operate initially near 32 knots, and accept a drop toward 29 knots when the full protection is installed.
- 3:04:13QuestionWas the Amphion class meant to replace the V and S classes over the long term?AnswerQ&A
Largely yes for the V, S, and some U-class roles, but not as a universal replacement for all wartime submarine types.
- 3:04:55QuestionIf the St Vincent class adopted triple centreline turrets, when would the Royal Navy move to all-triple battleship batteries?AnswerQ&A
Probably with the Orion class, producing an all-centreline battery of fifteen 13.5-inch guns.
- 3:06:13QuestionIf earlier US destroyers carried four or five twin mounts, should Somers-class successors receive as many as six twin 5-inch/38 mounts?AnswerQ&A
No. The deck-space, machinery, torpedo, topweight, and hull-form penalties make about three twin mounts far more realistic.
- 3:07:28QuestionShould the US Navy adopt an off-the-shelf design to replace the Arleigh Burke class?AnswerQ&A
There is no simple off-the-shelf equivalent; even a Type 83-derived option would require major US adaptation and a difficult political decision.
- 3:11:35How shrinking Zumwalt quantities broke the AGS caseNotable Point
Cutting the Zumwalt class from a large programme to three hulls spread development, ammunition, and shipyard costs across too few ships.
- 3:17:17FDI frigates and a possible Type 83 tumblehome hullNotable Point
France's compact FDI frigate illustrates how modern tumblehome forms and dense combat systems can influence thinking about future escorts such as Type 83.
- 3:27:38QuestionWhat do Valkyria Chronicles' snow cruisers suggest about using tank guns as a ship's primary weapons?AnswerQ&A
The fictional arrangement is inefficient in real engineering terms because ships can carry much larger purpose-built guns; guidance and fuzing transfer more readily than complete weapons.
- 3:30:29QuestionWhich US shipbuilding programme should have been built, and which cancelled?AnswerQ&A
Build more Constellations now, but the bigger missed opportunity was cancelling the strike-cruiser programme.
- 3:34:17QuestionHow surprising is it that the Leonardo AW149 may win the UK new-medium-helicopter competition?AnswerQ&A
Not very: commonality with existing Leonardo and Merlin systems makes it a natural British choice.
- 3:38:15QuestionHow much did information from Royal Navy ships repaired in US yards affect US Navy damage control before the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
More than zero, though probably less than it should have; British repair needs highlighted armour quality control and emergency-power backups.
- 3:40:19QuestionCould a decommissioned Second World War carrier become a 1950s luxury cruise ship accessible only by aircraft?AnswerQ&A
It could, but preserving flight operations would sacrifice much of the deck space and amenity value expected from a cruise ship.
- 3:41:27QuestionCould modernised Essex-class carriers handle the F/A-18 Hornet?AnswerQ&A
Perhaps for an exceptional landing, but not as a normal operational role; no regular Essex F/A-18 service is identified.
- 3:45:45QuestionWhat present-day ship would be most useful if sent back to the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
A Ford-class carrier with its air wing would be overwhelming; a Queen Elizabeth-class carrier is the leading British option.
- 3:49:04QuestionWhat should Admiral Kimmel do if he takes command in the early hours of 7 December 1941?AnswerQ&A
Order general quarters, secure watertight integrity and anti-aircraft defences, and push fighters airborne rather than immediately sortieing the fleet.
- 3:55:56QuestionCould the Zumwalt class have become an air-warfare cruiser replacement for the Ticonderogas?AnswerQ&A
A later production variant could have done so with more VLS cells, but the three completed ships are far too few to fill the fleet-wide gap.
- 3:58:04QuestionWill the CVL concept return through helicopter carriers that can carry and launch F-35s?AnswerQ&A
Yes, it is a plausible lower-entry route to organic naval aviation for more countries.
- 3:59:46QuestionShould modern Coast Guard cutters carry sonar?AnswerQ&A
Some basic acoustic capability is plausible, but full anti-submarine suites across the Coast Guard would be difficult to justify.
- 4:04:53QuestionHow would a British government make defence cuts if the Navy could not sensibly be reduced?AnswerQ&A
Past governments often cut until a crisis, then announce emergency procurement that cannot instantly overcome full yards, labour limits, or lost capacity.
- 4:06:37QuestionHow much larger would Zumwalt need to become to serve as a modern strike cruiser?AnswerQ&A
Very little; it already has strike-cruiser scale and strategic-length launchers, though too few ships were built to realise the concept at fleet level.
- 4:07:37QuestionWhat if the United States built all the Iowa, Alaska, and Montana classes before or just after the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
Large gunships would probably remain in service longer, supported by political prestige even as their naval utility became debatable.
- 4:10:34QuestionHow would the United States and Germany react if Queen Elizabeth and Revenge-class battleships carried twelve 15-inch guns?AnswerQ&A
The United States could answer within its existing twelve-gun design tradition, while Germany would face even greater financial and political pressure in its naval race with Britain.
- 4:16:09QuestionCould a 2,000- to 3,000-ton destroyer safely carry four or five twin 5-inch mounts?AnswerQ&A
Not realistically. Three twins may work, but additional mounts create topweight and stability problems that push the design toward a cruiser.
- 4:19:43QuestionHow would the world react if Sweden fielded a modern battleship-calibre naval gun?AnswerQ&A
Reaction would depend on the ammunition: a dumb-fire gun is impressive, while guided or rocket-assisted rounds would attract serious concern.
- 4:22:29QuestionWhy do destroyer leaders not suffer the same stability problems as the Atlanta class?AnswerQ&A
They still face the same pressures; enough beam and displacement are needed for the guns, or the design becomes a cruiser in all but name.
- 4:26:06Why primaries and local party selection matterNotable Point
Voting before the general election and participating in local party selection shape which candidates ever reach the final ballot.
- 4:29:10Why general-purpose cruisers converge near 10,000 tonsNotable Point
A worldwide cruising warship tends to settle near 10,000 to 15,000 tons because that range balances capability, endurance, and affordable numbers.
- 4:29:53Local elections, paper ballots, and public trustNotable Point
Low-turnout local elections still shape national politics, while observable paper records and cross-party scrutiny provide practical safeguards for ballot handling.
- 4:34:33QuestionCan AI be used to conduct historical research?AnswerQ&A
It can assist with summaries and orientation, but every claim and citation must be independently checked because AI can invent convincing sources.
- 4:35:54QuestionWhy was a K31 design with twelve 6-inch guns better than a K25 design with sixteen 5.25-inch guns?AnswerQ&A
The 6-inch design used fewer, established turrets and avoided the topweight, mechanical, and ammunition-handling burden of eight twin 5.25-inch mounts.
- 4:39:21Watching a paper-ballot count without disrupting itNotable Point
A firsthand account explains how party agents can monitor a paper-ballot count while leaving election officials room to work.