Video

Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space....

Study Bruships 166: As I walk through the library of Naval History, I take a look at my shelf space...., a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 13 Oct 2024, with 80 time notes. Topics include Aircraft Carriers, Live Q&A, Naval…

Date
Runtime4:42:16
Guide points80 time notes

Time notes

  1. 7:32
    QuestionHow was a warship keel made in the 1930s?Answer

    It was built up from heavy steel sections and plates, often with secondary keels.

    Q&A
  2. 8:19
    QuestionIs it illegal for the Royal Fleet Auxiliary to strike?Answer

    Not in peacetime; during wartime service it comes under Royal Navy regulations.

    Q&A
  3. 10:31
    QuestionWhat force would be needed to assault the Dutch East Indies in a sailing-age war?Answer

    Use infantry, fighting ships, and third rates to protect the supply convoys that sustain the force.

    Q&A
  4. 13:00
    QuestionDid navies besides Japan experiment with dedicated anti-submarine shells in the Second World War?Answer

    Yes. The Royal Navy and US Navy tried them, and modern concepts may be useful against underwater drones and mines.

    Q&A
  5. 14:47
    QuestionWho was the most influential single person in the Second World War apart from the major national leaders?Answer

    It is hard to isolate one person: the officers coordinating Allied logistics and convoys mattered as a collective system.

    Q&A
  6. 18:56
    Why Admiral Yonai refused a naval car

    Mitsumasa Yonai's habit of walking and using public transport is presented as a deliberate rejection of official transport and status.

    Notable Point
  7. 19:54
    Alan Brooke, Churchill, and self-serving memoirs

    Claims that one senior officer managed Churchill are treated as memoir evidence that must be checked against authorship, incentives, and contemporary relationships.

    Notable Point
  8. 22:17
    QuestionWhat book would you recommend on the naval and air side of the Falklands War rather than the land campaign?Answer

    The exchange recommends Air Defence at Sea, with particular attention to its appendices.

    Q&A
  9. 23:21
    QuestionWhich Second World War battle would the Italian Navy benefit from most if it had a carrier?Answer

    Matapan is a strong candidate, but early-war operations against British capital ships could matter more.

    Q&A
  10. 25:11
    QuestionWould Type 45 destroyers be better multi-role ships with Mark 41 vertical launchers?Answer

    Yes, Mark 41 would add flexibility, although wider missile roles would bring difficult procurement choices.

    Q&A
  11. 30:02
    QuestionWhat if Rivadavia arrived a year early and Argentina joined the Central Powers after Coronel?Answer

    The ships would be powerful locally, but Argentina would face British sea power, regional opposition, and severe economic pressure.

    Q&A
  12. 34:22
    QuestionWould the Malta class or CVA-01 have been better than the Midway class?Answer

    Malta would have been a broadly equivalent wartime counterpart with different priorities, while the later CVA-01 should have offered important advances.

    Q&A
  13. 36:20
    QuestionHow long should a Star Trek starship hull last in production and service if upgrades remain available?Answer

    Potentially centuries, provided manoeuvre loads are controlled, damaged plating can be replaced, and maintenance remains rigorous.

    Q&A
  14. 40:37
    QuestionHow much larger would the crews of bigger Type 45 or Type 83-style ships need to be?Answer

    Probably not dramatically larger: crew totals depend chiefly on system design and staffing rules rather than hull size.

    Q&A
  15. 48:42
    QuestionWhat if MacArthur won the 1944 US presidential election and controlled the nuclear button?Answer

    He would likely seek a more forceful personal role in ending both wars, with unpredictable consequences for relations with Stalin and the Pacific.

    Q&A
  16. 54:45
    QuestionHow effective was the Grumman AF Guardian concept of paired sensor and weapons aircraft?Answer

    It was a sensible period solution: one aircraft searched while the other attacked.

    Q&A
  17. 56:22
    Aerospace mergers preserve capability and culture

    Famous aircraft firms can survive mergers through capabilities and management culture even when their independent names disappear.

    Notable Point
  18. 59:39
    QuestionDo non-RFA merchant ships also become part of the Royal Navy in wartime?Answer

    Only in some cases: ships taken under naval control can be subject to naval rules, while ordinary convoy merchants remain merchant ships.

    Q&A
  19. 1:00:37
    QuestionHow useful would a battleship's very large high-angle main-gun battery and magazine be?Answer

    The ammunition would be valuable, but turret, magazine, elevation, and hull-stress constraints make the arrangement extremely demanding.

    Q&A
  20. 1:06:36
    QuestionWhy would the monarchy object to naming a Royal Navy ship Cromwell when the British Army used the name for a tank?Answer

    Cromwell's regicide and republican symbolism made the name awkward for the Royal Navy, while the Army's mixed royalist and parliamentary inheritance changed its institutional meaning.

    Q&A
  21. 1:11:03
    QuestionHow would a modern cruiser armed with modern versions of County-class guns compare with earlier cruisers?Answer

    It would have far better fire control and range, with autoloading twins plausible; gun logistics remain a significant advantage.

    Q&A
  22. 1:24:24
    QuestionWhat if King George V-class battleships had upgradeable main armament and uniform turret rings?Answer

    They could likely appear in batches with 14-inch, 15-inch, and eventually 16-inch guns without an initial construction delay.

    Q&A
  23. 1:27:13
    Why HMS Cromwell was easier to accept as a destroyer

    A wartime destroyer among hundreds of hulls carried less symbolic weight than naming a capital ship after Oliver Cromwell.

    Notable Point
  24. 1:32:45
    QuestionWhat single supply delivery, or failure to deliver, had the greatest effect on history?Answer

    Congo uranium for the Manhattan Project is a leading candidate, but Malta relief shows the wider strategic importance of supply.

    Q&A
  25. 1:36:10
    QuestionWhat if USS Indianapolis had been sunk on the way to Tinian?Answer

    Another heavy cruiser would likely repeat the delivery with an escort, delaying the end of the war by about a month.

    Q&A
  26. 1:36:37
    QuestionHow would the pre-First World War naval race change if Germany built only fast capital ships?Answer

    Britain would build faster capital ships of its own, while German dependence on British turbine expertise would complicate the race.

    Q&A
  27. 1:39:01
    Mercantilism, resource control, and imperial power

    A short economic-history aside links mercantilist control of resources to European empire building and later command-economy problems.

    Notable Point
  28. 1:40:25
    How a speed race reshapes propulsion and treaty limits

    A German speed challenge would push British and American propulsion choices upward and could make much larger treaty battleships politically normal.

    Notable Point
  29. 1:48:58
    QuestionWhich Second World War ships would be most useful in the Falklands War if suitably modernised?Answer

    Large fleet carriers for Harriers, plus battleships for bombardment, would provide the largest operational gain.

    Q&A
  30. 1:55:56
    QuestionWould a Malta-class carrier completed after the Second World War have lasted longer than Ark Royal?Answer

    Probably yes; Malta's size and strong flight deck would make heavy-aircraft operation and long-term modernisation more practical.

    Q&A
  31. 1:57:31
    QuestionHow would the Second World War change if an island containing Great Britain as it existed in 1812 appeared west of Ireland?Answer

    After an authority crisis, its greatest value would be retrainable manpower, food, timber, and protected production space rather than its wooden warships.

    Q&A
  32. 2:01:57
    Carrier groups built around the Malta class

    Three operational Malta-class carriers, backed by a fourth in refit or reserve, could reorganise the Royal Navy around durable carrier groups.

    Notable Point
  33. 2:10:35
    QuestionWhat would Britain do if Argentina built battleships with 12 15-inch guns and heavy 9.2-inch secondaries?Answer

    Britain would build more powerful counterweights; the heavy secondary battery is not treated as a decisive advantage.

    Q&A
  34. 2:15:21
    QuestionWhy would the United States not simply export the F-22 to allied countries?Answer

    Congress barred exports, the production system would have to be restarted, and allies were directed toward the F-35 instead.

    Q&A
  35. 2:24:19
    QuestionWhat was Indomitable's hangar height, and could it accommodate a Harrier?Answer

    With approximately 14- and 16-foot hangars, it could accommodate a Sea Harrier with a little over a foot of clearance.

    Q&A
  36. 2:26:33
    QuestionIs a modern torpedo simply an underwater missile?Answer

    In some ways, but its underwater medium and usual wire-guided or fire-and-forget control arrangements still distinguish it.

    Q&A
  37. 2:26:59
    QuestionWhat would the major naval powers do if each received a Lexington-class hull and a connected slipway in 1910?Answer

    They would probably complete the hull as a battlecruiser, but powers with the strongest supporting industry would gain most from the extra slipway.

    Q&A
  38. 2:28:51
    QuestionWhat is the largest-bore autoloading naval gun fitted to an active-duty ship?Answer

    The US Navy's 8-inch cruiser guns were the largest autoloading naval guns in service.

    Q&A
  39. 2:29:19
    QuestionCould railgun technology be combined with a VLS to boost missiles into the air as a cold-launch system?Answer

    Possibly, but existing cold-launch systems already provide that function without the extra rail mechanism.

    Q&A
  40. 2:29:53
    QuestionCould 6-inch naval guns return on surface combatants in response to hypersonic threats?Answer

    Possibly. A 6-inch system would be a manageable and meaningful capability increase over 5-inch guns.

    Q&A
  41. 2:32:23
    QuestionWill European navies beat the United States at underway VLS replenishment because Sylver is less complicated?Answer

    Not necessarily. Replenishing missiles at sea is difficult regardless of launcher family, and the US has already demonstrated part of the process.

    Q&A
  42. 2:33:29
    QuestionHow useful would Ning Hai-class cruisers be if they escaped to form a Free Chinese navy in Australia?Answer

    They would make useful convoy escorts and could be converted toward an anti-aircraft destroyer role.

    Q&A
  43. 2:35:12
    QuestionHow long can the early Arleigh Burke-class destroyers last, and could early ships retire before the last is built?Answer

    Yes. The earliest ships may retire around their mid-thirties as hard use, maintenance costs, and replacement schedules catch up with them.

    Q&A
  44. 2:41:49
    QuestionWhy were Iowa-class battleships not refitted with 16-inch nuclear shells during the Reagan buildup?Answer

    The shells were too large and politically problematic for the operational benefit they offered.

    Q&A
  45. 2:42:43
    QuestionHow much faster would Queen Elizabeth-class battleships be with small-tube boilers?Answer

    About 26 knots is plausible; reaching 28 knots would likely require a longer hull as well as the boilers.

    Q&A
  46. 2:44:11
    QuestionWhat naval programme is most comparable to the Atari 2600 fiasco?Answer

    The Littoral Combat Ship: it looked compelling on paper, but its speed-led design did not deliver the combat capability or endurance required.

    Q&A
  47. 2:54:39
    QuestionDo people underestimate why ships, aircraft, and helicopters eventually need replacement?Answer

    Often. Age is only one factor; operating intensity, upgrades, maintenance, and mission demands are equally important.

    Q&A
  48. 2:58:22
    QuestionWhat did you think of the Starship test flight and booster catch?Answer

    It was an impressive engineering result, and the programme's research can yield broad benefits without requiring uncritical admiration of its public figurehead.

    Q&A
  49. 3:00:13
    Defence systems manage risk rather than become invulnerable

    Armed forces and aircraft carriers are justified by the risks they manage, not by a promise that any platform will be impossible to defeat.

    Notable Point
  50. 3:02:24
    QuestionHow could Nelson and Rodney be designed as fast 16-inch battlecruisers while retaining an upgrade path to heavier armour?Answer

    Build them with provision for the intended armour, operate initially near 32 knots, and accept a drop toward 29 knots when the full protection is installed.

    Q&A
  51. 3:04:13
    QuestionWas the Amphion class meant to replace the V and S classes over the long term?Answer

    Largely yes for the V, S, and some U-class roles, but not as a universal replacement for all wartime submarine types.

    Q&A
  52. 3:04:55
    QuestionIf the St Vincent class adopted triple centreline turrets, when would the Royal Navy move to all-triple battleship batteries?Answer

    Probably with the Orion class, producing an all-centreline battery of fifteen 13.5-inch guns.

    Q&A
  53. 3:06:13
    QuestionIf earlier US destroyers carried four or five twin mounts, should Somers-class successors receive as many as six twin 5-inch/38 mounts?Answer

    No. The deck-space, machinery, torpedo, topweight, and hull-form penalties make about three twin mounts far more realistic.

    Q&A
  54. 3:07:28
    QuestionShould the US Navy adopt an off-the-shelf design to replace the Arleigh Burke class?Answer

    There is no simple off-the-shelf equivalent; even a Type 83-derived option would require major US adaptation and a difficult political decision.

    Q&A
  55. 3:11:35
    How shrinking Zumwalt quantities broke the AGS case

    Cutting the Zumwalt class from a large programme to three hulls spread development, ammunition, and shipyard costs across too few ships.

    Notable Point
  56. 3:17:17
    FDI frigates and a possible Type 83 tumblehome hull

    France's compact FDI frigate illustrates how modern tumblehome forms and dense combat systems can influence thinking about future escorts such as Type 83.

    Notable Point
  57. 3:27:38
    QuestionWhat do Valkyria Chronicles' snow cruisers suggest about using tank guns as a ship's primary weapons?Answer

    The fictional arrangement is inefficient in real engineering terms because ships can carry much larger purpose-built guns; guidance and fuzing transfer more readily than complete weapons.

    Q&A
  58. 3:30:29
    QuestionWhich US shipbuilding programme should have been built, and which cancelled?Answer

    Build more Constellations now, but the bigger missed opportunity was cancelling the strike-cruiser programme.

    Q&A
  59. 3:34:17
    QuestionHow surprising is it that the Leonardo AW149 may win the UK new-medium-helicopter competition?Answer

    Not very: commonality with existing Leonardo and Merlin systems makes it a natural British choice.

    Q&A
  60. 3:38:15
    QuestionHow much did information from Royal Navy ships repaired in US yards affect US Navy damage control before the Second World War?Answer

    More than zero, though probably less than it should have; British repair needs highlighted armour quality control and emergency-power backups.

    Q&A
  61. 3:40:19
    QuestionCould a decommissioned Second World War carrier become a 1950s luxury cruise ship accessible only by aircraft?Answer

    It could, but preserving flight operations would sacrifice much of the deck space and amenity value expected from a cruise ship.

    Q&A
  62. 3:41:27
    QuestionCould modernised Essex-class carriers handle the F/A-18 Hornet?Answer

    Perhaps for an exceptional landing, but not as a normal operational role; no regular Essex F/A-18 service is identified.

    Q&A
  63. 3:45:45
    QuestionWhat present-day ship would be most useful if sent back to the Second World War?Answer

    A Ford-class carrier with its air wing would be overwhelming; a Queen Elizabeth-class carrier is the leading British option.

    Q&A
  64. 3:49:04
    QuestionWhat should Admiral Kimmel do if he takes command in the early hours of 7 December 1941?Answer

    Order general quarters, secure watertight integrity and anti-aircraft defences, and push fighters airborne rather than immediately sortieing the fleet.

    Q&A
  65. 3:55:56
    QuestionCould the Zumwalt class have become an air-warfare cruiser replacement for the Ticonderogas?Answer

    A later production variant could have done so with more VLS cells, but the three completed ships are far too few to fill the fleet-wide gap.

    Q&A
  66. 3:58:04
    QuestionWill the CVL concept return through helicopter carriers that can carry and launch F-35s?Answer

    Yes, it is a plausible lower-entry route to organic naval aviation for more countries.

    Q&A
  67. 3:59:46
    QuestionShould modern Coast Guard cutters carry sonar?Answer

    Some basic acoustic capability is plausible, but full anti-submarine suites across the Coast Guard would be difficult to justify.

    Q&A
  68. 4:04:53
    QuestionHow would a British government make defence cuts if the Navy could not sensibly be reduced?Answer

    Past governments often cut until a crisis, then announce emergency procurement that cannot instantly overcome full yards, labour limits, or lost capacity.

    Q&A
  69. 4:06:37
    QuestionHow much larger would Zumwalt need to become to serve as a modern strike cruiser?Answer

    Very little; it already has strike-cruiser scale and strategic-length launchers, though too few ships were built to realise the concept at fleet level.

    Q&A
  70. 4:07:37
    QuestionWhat if the United States built all the Iowa, Alaska, and Montana classes before or just after the Second World War?Answer

    Large gunships would probably remain in service longer, supported by political prestige even as their naval utility became debatable.

    Q&A
  71. 4:10:34
    QuestionHow would the United States and Germany react if Queen Elizabeth and Revenge-class battleships carried twelve 15-inch guns?Answer

    The United States could answer within its existing twelve-gun design tradition, while Germany would face even greater financial and political pressure in its naval race with Britain.

    Q&A
  72. 4:16:09
    QuestionCould a 2,000- to 3,000-ton destroyer safely carry four or five twin 5-inch mounts?Answer

    Not realistically. Three twins may work, but additional mounts create topweight and stability problems that push the design toward a cruiser.

    Q&A
  73. 4:19:43
    QuestionHow would the world react if Sweden fielded a modern battleship-calibre naval gun?Answer

    Reaction would depend on the ammunition: a dumb-fire gun is impressive, while guided or rocket-assisted rounds would attract serious concern.

    Q&A
  74. 4:22:29
    QuestionWhy do destroyer leaders not suffer the same stability problems as the Atlanta class?Answer

    They still face the same pressures; enough beam and displacement are needed for the guns, or the design becomes a cruiser in all but name.

    Q&A
  75. 4:26:06
    Why primaries and local party selection matter

    Voting before the general election and participating in local party selection shape which candidates ever reach the final ballot.

    Notable Point
  76. 4:29:10
    Why general-purpose cruisers converge near 10,000 tons

    A worldwide cruising warship tends to settle near 10,000 to 15,000 tons because that range balances capability, endurance, and affordable numbers.

    Notable Point
  77. 4:29:53
    Local elections, paper ballots, and public trust

    Low-turnout local elections still shape national politics, while observable paper records and cross-party scrutiny provide practical safeguards for ballot handling.

    Notable Point
  78. 4:34:33
    QuestionCan AI be used to conduct historical research?Answer

    It can assist with summaries and orientation, but every claim and citation must be independently checked because AI can invent convincing sources.

    Q&A
  79. 4:35:54
    QuestionWhy was a K31 design with twelve 6-inch guns better than a K25 design with sixteen 5.25-inch guns?Answer

    The 6-inch design used fewer, established turrets and avoided the topweight, mechanical, and ammunition-handling burden of eight twin 5.25-inch mounts.

    Q&A
  80. 4:39:21
    Watching a paper-ballot count without disrupting it

    A firsthand account explains how party agents can monitor a paper-ballot count while leaving election officials room to work.

    Notable Point