Q&A · 2:27:15 Small missile boats are most compelling when they fight from a defended coast, where numbers and geography complicate an opponent's approach.
From Patreon Video 1: What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Q&A · 2:28:54 The post-war carrier classes are presented as a gradual evolution from light-fleet concepts toward a more capable armoured strike-carrier role.
From Patreon Video 1: What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Q&A · 2:30:20 The Type 45 replacement question is becoming clearer, while LHDs are proposed as successors to Albion and Bulwark.
From Patreon Video 1: What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Q&A · 2:32:01 For a hypothetical Singapore reserve, the attraction of 15-inch guns is their stronger long-term utility, though a mix of calibres could be useful if ammunition stocks existed.
From Patreon Video 1: What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Chapter · 0:03 The exercise begins from the view that the Royal Navy largely chose its real reserves well, then asks what a 1918-23 officer could plausibly add, retain, or conceal within treaty rules.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 3:38 The exercise selects Reginald Tyrwhitt as a politically durable and sufficiently devious sponsor after rejecting Beatty's short-term style and Jellicoe's honesty.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 4:49 Four-inch guns, smaller weapons, mountings, and shells are treated as complete systems that could arm large numbers of future escorts and auxiliaries.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 6:35 Precision gun and mounting production could lag hull construction, making preserved weapons a direct way to accelerate emergency escort output.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 8:11 Gibraltar and bases across the Empire offer a dispersed network for storing old weapons beyond the close attention of treaty inspectors and the Treasury.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 9:02 Removing torpedo fittings and assigning defensive coast-guard identities could preserve useful destroyer hulls outside the main battle fleet.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 10:45 Locally operated destroyer formations could build escort experience, spread defence costs, and reduce imperial bases' dependence on distant Royal Navy reinforcements.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 11:54 Retaining mine stocks alongside minelayers would turn stored hulls into a practical means of disrupting an enemy's movement.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 12:46 Small craft retained for routine harbour work could also give the Royal Navy a practical starting point for developing landing craft and amphibious methods.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Chapter · 14:04 The most damaging consequence of transferring naval flying to the RAF is presented as the Navy's loss of direct engineering and industrial knowledge, not merely ownership of aircraft.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Chapter · 15:27 Admiralty communication seaplanes at distant stations could preserve naval aircrew and technical practice while quietly developing a maritime patrol organization.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 18:42 A surviving naval seaplane arm might have drawn Coastal Command and the Fleet Air Arm into a unified naval air service when RAF bomber priorities diverged.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 19:26 A modern aside favors joint RAF-Royal Navy ownership of the P-8 so that two services have incentives to argue for maritime-patrol capacity.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 19:49 The late-1930s priority order left Coastal Command behind bombers, fighters, and carrier aviation, without an Admiralty constituency pressing its case.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 20:41 Surplus warships converted into seaplane tenders could support remote flying boats while preserving a bridge to a stronger Fleet Air Arm.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Chapter · 25:18 The closing synthesis prioritizes escort armament, mine warfare, reconnaissance, and the Navy's aviation-industry link rather than hiding an extra battle fleet.
From Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could? · 6 Jul 2020
Chapter · 12:00 Dmitri Volkogonov's access to Soviet archives makes his Stalin biography unusually valuable, but its late-Soviet origins still require careful reading.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Chapter · 15:36 A book-led look at Stalin's intended blue-water fleet, including the immense Project 24 battleship and a proposed Soviet battlecarrier.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 22:00 A question on Stalin's fleet becomes an argument that ships provide durable global presence where land and air power depend on fixed bases.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 25:13 Graf Zeppelin's damaged and incomplete condition made the captured German carrier a poor basis for Soviet post-war carrier development.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 25:28 Britain could have found money for new battleships under acute strategic pressure, but only by changing priorities and leaning harder on imperial support.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Chapter · 29:41 Two contrasting books frame naval diplomacy as both a hopeful account of incidents at sea and a harder-edged account of coercive presence.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 32:13 The Sverdlov class is read as a Soviet post-war development of the long-range cruiser-raider role associated with Germany's Panzerschiffe.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 32:33 A question about Soviet officers leads to a warning against treating the German General Staff as a uniquely superior model.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Chapter · 35:09 Rear-Admiral J. R. Hill's Air Defense at Sea is recommended as a serious guide to the practical realities behind Cold War naval air defence.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 38:11 Larger ship-launched missiles encouraged confidence that naval systems had escaped the reliability and close-combat lessons exposed by US air fighting over Vietnam.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Chapter · 38:29 A multi-author study of Soviet naval diplomacy is recommended for its detailed account of Soviet activity and maritime signalling.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 40:35 The Plan Z battleships resemble enlarged Bismarcks assigned to a commerce-raiding role that no longer suited their size.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 43:53 A magazine, Ian Ballantyne's books, and two contrasting naval blogs form a practical reading route into the modern Royal Navy.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 45:33 The Plan Z ships demanded yard and armour capacity that Germany might expand in peace but could not realistically create during wartime.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Chapter · 47:15 Norman Polmar's guide documents Soviet ships, aircraft, marines, and command structures while also revealing how Western analysts understood the fleet.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 49:18 A modernised Iowa is judged unlikely to reach a valuable warship with its guns, but much more plausible as a heavy bombardment platform against land targets around Norway.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 51:57 A discussion of Finnish corvettes becomes a compact guide to class labels and the trade between many small hulls and fewer capable ships.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 56:45 The best treaty reference is recommended with a caveat: treaty rules could serve the Royal Navy's existing interests rather than simply constrain it.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 57:58 India's fleet is assessed against a huge land border, a major maritime frontier, crowded sea lanes, and potential resource conflicts.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Notable Point · 1:00:05 The possible Soviet naval threat was genuinely large, but the force that could be realised and employed was somewhat less formidable than its maximum potential suggested.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 1:02:19 A dispersed Soviet fleet would have complicated NATO sea denial by forcing it to hunt forces already operating beyond Soviet home waters.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 1:05:17 A heavy-gun hit is described less as a neat internal explosion than as catastrophic kinetic damage to a lightly protected modern warship.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Chapter · 1:08:29 A recommended collection restores the Pacific, Indian Ocean, Africa, and South America to a Cold War story too often narrowed to Europe.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 1:09:42 The case for a 15-inch King George V is framed around standard ammunition, existing triple turrets, and fewer development risks.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 1:12:03 Russia's nuclear-powered cruiser has a plausible presence role, but prolonged refit and incomplete renewal threaten its remaining value.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 1:14:23 Soviet naval diplomacy is described as a blend of global presence, surface-raider pressure, and efforts to make the West watch multiple theatres.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 1:16:28 Britain delayed large fleet carriers because planners expected them to arrive too late and redirected shipbuilding effort toward urgently needed escorts.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020
Q&A · 1:18:41 A larger Soviet surface fleet would not automatically force one new Western carrier concept; it would disperse combat across more seas and create more separate engagements.
From Bru Ships Episode 9: Super Power Contest (as in the nations) Themed Books to Review & a general Q/A · 5 Jul 2020