Video

Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could?

Study Patreon Video 1: Intro - What would you put in warehouses at the end of WWI for WWII if you could?, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 6 Jul 2020, with 16 time notes. Topics include Alternate History, Interwar Naval…

Date
Runtime26:02
Guide points16 time notes

Time notes

  1. 0:03
    Planning postwar reserves within treaty limits

    The exercise begins from the view that the Royal Navy largely chose its real reserves well, then asks what a 1918-23 officer could plausibly add, retain, or conceal within treaty rules.

    Chapter
  2. 3:38
    Why Reginald Tyrwhitt fits the scheme

    The exercise selects Reginald Tyrwhitt as a politically durable and sufficiently devious sponsor after rejecting Beatty's short-term style and Jellicoe's honesty.

    Notable Point
  3. 4:49
    Stockpiling complete light-gun systems

    Four-inch guns, smaller weapons, mountings, and shells are treated as complete systems that could arm large numbers of future escorts and auxiliaries.

    Notable Point
  4. 6:35
    Naval guns as long-lead mobilization items

    Precision gun and mounting production could lag hull construction, making preserved weapons a direct way to accelerate emergency escort output.

    Notable Point
  5. 8:11
    Imperial naval bases as dispersed reserve depots

    Gibraltar and bases across the Empire offer a dispersed network for storing old weapons beyond the close attention of treaty inspectors and the Treasury.

    Notable Point
  6. 9:02
    Reclassifying old destroyers as coast-guard ships

    Removing torpedo fittings and assigning defensive coast-guard identities could preserve useful destroyer hulls outside the main battle fleet.

    Notable Point
  7. 10:45
    Coast guards as imperial escort reserves

    Locally operated destroyer formations could build escort experience, spread defence costs, and reduce imperial bases' dependence on distant Royal Navy reinforcements.

    Notable Point
  8. 11:54
    Mine reserves make minelayers useful

    Retaining mine stocks alongside minelayers would turn stored hulls into a practical means of disrupting an enemy's movement.

    Notable Point
  9. 12:46
    Harbour craft as a base for amphibious capability

    Small craft retained for routine harbour work could also give the Royal Navy a practical starting point for developing landing craft and amphibious methods.

    Notable Point
  10. 14:04
    RAF control severed naval aviation's engineering link

    The most damaging consequence of transferring naval flying to the RAF is presented as the Navy's loss of direct engineering and industrial knowledge, not merely ownership of aircraft.

    Chapter
  11. 15:27
    Keeping a naval seaplane network alive

    Admiralty communication seaplanes at distant stations could preserve naval aircrew and technical practice while quietly developing a maritime patrol organization.

    Chapter
  12. 18:42
    A naval home for Coastal Command

    A surviving naval seaplane arm might have drawn Coastal Command and the Fleet Air Arm into a unified naval air service when RAF bomber priorities diverged.

    Notable Point
  13. 19:26
    Joint P-8 ownership as a case for stronger advocacy

    A modern aside favors joint RAF-Royal Navy ownership of the P-8 so that two services have incentives to argue for maritime-patrol capacity.

    Notable Point
  14. 19:49
    Coastal Command at the bottom of Air Ministry priorities

    The late-1930s priority order left Coastal Command behind bombers, fighters, and carrier aviation, without an Admiralty constituency pressing its case.

    Notable Point
  15. 20:41
    Converting old ships into seaplane tenders

    Surplus warships converted into seaplane tenders could support remote flying boats while preserving a bridge to a stronger Fleet Air Arm.

    Notable Point
  16. 25:18
    Stockpile bottlenecks, not a second battle fleet

    The closing synthesis prioritizes escort armament, mine warfare, reconnaissance, and the Navy's aviation-industry link rather than hiding an extra battle fleet.

    Chapter