Nelson-class machinery, weapons, and armor
A compact technical profile sets the Nelson class's 23-knot machinery against nine 16-inch guns and heavy concentrated armor.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Complete directory
Browse all time notes.
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
Nelson's claimed speed versus likely service performance
The answer distinguishes the class's nominal 23-knot figure from an estimate of roughly 20 knots in ordinary service.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Waterline protection limited extreme citadel economies
The US Navy's required armoured share of the waterline exposed a weakness in extreme citadel economies, and later British designs moved toward broader belt coverage.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Why balanced firing arcs mattered in the Mediterranean
A proposed Nelson redesign moves one turret aft to make the ship more adaptable in fast-changing Mediterranean actions.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Concentrated firepower also concentrated risk
All-forward batteries saved protected length but exposed a ship to losing much of its firepower in one damaged area.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Nelson-class freeboard and North Atlantic seakeeping
Freeboard figures show that Nelson and Rodney could work in the North Atlantic, while the larger G3 and N3 hulls promised better seakeeping.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Main-battery blast disrupted Nelson's flag facilities
The placement of Nelson's command spaces made the shock of firing the main battery a practical headquarters problem as well as a structural one.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Why moving the G3 bridge aft complicated ship control
A proposed weight-saving layout is tested against the Royal Navy's preference for keeping the navigating bridge well forward.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Why navies retained wooden weather decks
Wooden decking as a sacrificial, salt-resistant surface that protected steel while remaining practical for shipboard life.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
G3 speed versus N3 gun power
The two designs used nearly equal displacement for sharply different combinations of speed, armor, and gun caliber.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Why the G3 reached the order stage before the N3
The G3 was ordered first because its design matured sooner and the Royal Navy saw a more urgent need to replace battlecruisers than existing battleships.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
How older battleships could still alter Japanese planning off Malaya
A counterfactual carrier-supported Force Z uses several older battleships to show how visible fleet numbers can compel a larger enemy response.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Why additional G3s might have been more useful than N3s
The G3's ability to operate with cruisers and carriers is weighed against the N3's exchange of speed for heavier armor and 18-inch guns.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Why the Revenge class survived while the G3s disappeared
Treaty limits and the timing of British concessions preserved the older Revenge class while the much larger G3 programme was surrendered.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
The G3's layered torpedo-defense concept
A cross-section reveals alternating air, steel, and liquid layers backed by compressed-air counter-flooding measures.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
A fast battleship compromised by its center turret
The G3 combined battlecruiser speed with battleship protection, but its machinery and center-turret arrangement limited firing arcs and future use.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Why North Sea evidence could distort conclusions about aft fire
A study finding that Royal Navy ships rarely fired aft is qualified because its evidence came from the Grand Fleet's North Sea engagements.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Surviving G3s could have raised the treaty battleship ceiling
Keeping 48,000-ton G3s in service might have made their size the legal baseline for interwar capital ships and enlarged every navy's design margin.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Capital-ship orders as employment and national policy
Battleship procurement connected shipyard employment and public prestige with the Navy's role as the shield of empire.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
The N3's 18-inch guns and the escalation trap
Nine 18-inch guns promised British superiority but risked setting a new baseline that rival navies would immediately exceed.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Technology exchange did not create common British-American ship designs
The answer distinguishes wartime technical cooperation from joint ship design, emphasizing persistent differences in British and American design philosophy.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Gun caliber eventually loses to rate of fire
A gunnery comparison explains why heavier shells and machinery sharply reduce output as caliber climbs beyond 15 or 16 inches.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Visibility limited the practical value of 8-inch cruiser range
Before radar, the ability to see and track a target could erase the nominal range advantage of an 8-inch cruiser gun over a faster-firing 6-inch battery.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Why quadruple 6-inch turrets were more workable than heavy quads
The lighter 6-inch ammunition and handling machinery kept a quadruple cruiser turret within a more manageable engineering scale than 14- to 18-inch mounts.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Why British 16-inch gun development slowed after Nelson
Treaties did not ban gun development directly, but Treasury-Admiralty funding disputes still prevented sustained work on a post-Nelson 16-inch weapon.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
How G3 carrier conversions might have transformed naval aviation
Treaty conversion could have produced four large, fast British carriers and established senior carrier commands a decade earlier.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
M3 was an earlier step toward the N3 battleship
The letter-number labels mark successive design iterations, with M3 representing an earlier stage on the path to the final N3 concept.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
G3 and N3 value depended on the battle context
A comparison with the South Dakota class separates one-on-one maneuver from the constraints of a fleet action.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Could treaty construction quotas have preserved shipyard employment?
The discussion contrasts a recurring construction quota with the less developed arms-control thinking that shaped the actual Washington negotiations.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
A G3 carrier would have approached Lexington dimensions
Hull length, beam, and likely British secondary armament place a hypothetical G3 conversion in the same broad fleet-carrier scale as Lexington and Saratoga.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
A notional 72-aircraft G3 carrier air group
The proposed air group combines 36 Swordfish with 18 Fulmars and 18 Skuas to show the scale of aviation a G3 conversion might support before the Second World War.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
The N3's likely Second World War value
The closing assessment treats an N3 as a larger expression of the same heavy-gun, heavily protected fleet value supplied by Nelson and Rodney.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
How G3 conversions could redistribute the older British carriers
Four first-line G3 carriers would free Courageous, Glorious, Furious, Hermes, and Eagle for secondary fleets and persistent overseas stations.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
The G3's likely Second World War role
The closing answer assigns surviving G3 battlecruisers the same global interception role performed by HMS Hood.
From Patreon 15 - Washington’s cherry trees: the G3 and N3 classes ·
Roosevelt's marriages and his wives' agency
A biographical aside links Roosevelt's second marriage to early death while emphasizing the intelligence and independence of both women he married.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·
What a modern Theodore Roosevelt would need
A modern equivalent of Roosevelt would need to combine large ambitions with the practical judgment to turn them into policy.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·
Why armored cruisers barely joined the Great White Fleet
The armored cruisers collected on the West Coast do not count as full participants in the Great White Fleet's voyage because they joined it too briefly.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·
Reading Roosevelt's naval legacy selectively
The video separates Roosevelt's enduring standards of public leadership from policies that do not fit the modern world.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·
The Great White Fleet warned more than Britain
The fleet's itinerary reveals a broad signal aimed at rising German and Japanese power rather than a demonstration directed only at Britain.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·
Judging Ho Chi Minh's leadership by effectiveness
A brief answer separates approval of Ho Chi Minh from an assessment of whether he was effective against his American opponents.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·
Debt, gunboats, and Germany's informal imperial reach
A response connects German lending and coercive debt collection to American and British fears about informal colonial control in the Western Hemisphere.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·
British colliers sustained the Great White Fleet
The fleet's coal supply exposed weak American merchant capacity and made British shipping support part of the strategic message received abroad.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·
British coal support hinted at a three-power alignment
With the Anglo-Japanese treaty still recent, British help for the American voyage could suggest a possible British-Japanese-American maritime alignment.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·
Why Anglo-American affinity eased coal cooperation
Shared language and workable relations between British merchant crews and American sailors helped turn commercial coal contracts into a diplomatic signal.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·
Swagger made American naval presence credible
The voyage mixed friendly diplomacy with a visible demonstration that the United States could move a battle fleet and could no longer be ignored.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·
Robust debate improves naval choices
A methodological aside explains why respectful disagreement is essential when judging what a navy should build and how it should be used.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·
Why SSBNs make poor flag-showing visitors
A discussion of Polaris and a fictional Stockholm visit explains why revealing a ballistic-missile submarine undermines the platform's strategic purpose.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·
The Bull Moose Party's progressive platform
The closing answer surveys Roosevelt's 1912 Progressive Party, the Square Deal, political reform, social insurance, and international naval-arms limits.
From Great White Fleet: Long Patrol Part 3 of 3 - Some Questions Answered ·