Notable Point · 52:45 Lloyd's List and the London Gazette give different strengths for the same captured ships, limiting how precisely the forces can be reconstructed.
From Action of the 18th of June 1799: How to Lose Frigates & Influence (Long Patrol) · 17 Jun 2022
Chapter · 53:51 France and its allies lost five scarce cruising ships and their crews while Britain's strength in smaller warships remained comparatively steady.
From Action of the 18th of June 1799: How to Lose Frigates & Influence (Long Patrol) · 17 Jun 2022
Notable Point · 56:50 British prisoner policy targeted the navigators and junior officers France needed to rebuild an effective seagoing institution.
From Action of the 18th of June 1799: How to Lose Frigates & Influence (Long Patrol) · 17 Jun 2022
Chapter · 57:33 A French court accepted Perrée's reasons for retreat and surrender, while Britain retained, repurposed, or later disposed of the captured vessels.
From Action of the 18th of June 1799: How to Lose Frigates & Influence (Long Patrol) · 17 Jun 2022
Notable Point · 59:23 The Trafalgar counterfactual asks whether a damaged victorious fleet could survive further British interception, then explains why Britain wanted to fight far from its blockade stations.
From Action of the 18th of June 1799: How to Lose Frigates & Influence (Long Patrol) · 17 Jun 2022
Notable Point · 1:01:08 Frigates mattered as fleet scouts, messengers, presence ships, and escorts for the supply convoys that kept blockading squadrons at sea.
From Action of the 18th of June 1799: How to Lose Frigates & Influence (Long Patrol) · 17 Jun 2022
Chapter · 1:02:41 Attacking Gibraltar with Spanish support is considered as an alternative to Napoleon's Egyptian expedition and its uncertain onward route to India.
From Action of the 18th of June 1799: How to Lose Frigates & Influence (Long Patrol) · 17 Jun 2022
Notable Point · 1:04:00 Poor material condition and limited crew experience prevented Perrée's sailing manoeuvres from defeating a prolonged British pursuit.
From Action of the 18th of June 1799: How to Lose Frigates & Influence (Long Patrol) · 17 Jun 2022
Chapter · 2:02 An equitable baseline exposes the domestic politics and strategic assumptions hidden inside naval treaties.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 3:44 An additional operational carrier could increase the Taranto strike, improve maintenance margins, and release fast battleships for other theaters.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 11:39 More and larger carriers would create the orders and institutional demand needed to modernize Fleet Air Arm aircraft earlier.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 12:56 Replacement age and construction-rate rules can restrain fleet turnover more directly than an arbitrary 35,000-ton hull ceiling.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 14:39 A modest fixed displacement allowance was more negotiable than repeatedly increasing treaty limits by percentage.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 16:39 A question about giving Japan more ships leads to an explanation of how perceived respect and security could strengthen diplomatic factions.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Notable Point · 19:54 The 35,000-ton limit is linked to postwar horror and the belief that weaker battleships could make another war less likely.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 21:29 A proposed capital-ship ratio illustrates why easily understood whole-number allocations are more durable in negotiation.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 24:17 The effort to halt an arms race could encourage future challengers to believe a frozen fleet was vulnerable to newer ships.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Notable Point · 27:30 The proposed 8,000-ton cruiser combines Leander-class speed with Amphion-class armour before appearing in the later force calculation.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 28:18 Newer Admiral-class conversions could displace Courageous and Glorious, while experimental Furious might remain temporarily or release treaty tonnage.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Chapter · 33:12 A 20:20:14:8:8 allocation opens a plausible Italian mix of Francesco Caracciolo battleships and carrier conversions.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 34:16 Larger 1922 dockyard infrastructure could let Britain lengthen the N3 hull, add machinery, and retain its 18-inch armament at higher speed.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Chapter · 36:59 The proposed schedule phases replacement by laying-down date and gun caliber instead of imposing a blanket building holiday.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 40:01 A neutral calendar cutoff is easier to administer than an emotionally charged armistice anniversary.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 45:37 Removing one or both midships turrets could make room for enough modern machinery and fuel to approach 27 knots, but only through a difficult reconstruction.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 46:56 The proposed replacement schedule would concentrate modernisation on Queen Elizabeth-class ships while replacing other old capital ships quickly.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 47:31 Layered armor can be weaker plate-for-plate yet improve hull survival by preventing seams from forming a continuous path.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Notable Point · 50:01 A more equitable settlement might not prevent war, but it could keep European and Pacific conflicts from merging into one world war.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Notable Point · 50:27 John Maynard Keynes is identified as a contemporary British critic of the Washington settlement's industrial damage.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 50:56 Radically rebuilt R-class ships could add speed and nine 15-inch guns, but thinner protection would make them battlecruisers dependent on maneuver.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 52:21 Aircraft size changes too much over time for a fixed embarked count to define a carrier's rate reliably.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 54:14 The County-class cruisers illustrate designing below a limit when later armor and armament growth is expected.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 55:58 Without treaty rebuild limits, British First World War battleships might receive Warspite-scale reconstructions and approach 28 knots.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Notable Point · 57:43 G3 orders placed nineteen days before the Washington conference left negotiators comparing familiar wartime programmes with less familiar British postwar designs.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 59:13 More and larger carriers could strengthen the institutional case for naval control of aviation and support an eight-carrier interwar force.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Chapter · 1:03:18 The treaty restricted Japan's defensive depth while Britain and the United States retained distant homelands and established bases.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 1:08:29 Replacing the class's extreme 15-inch armament with 9.2-inch guns could turn the lightly protected hulls into useful large cruisers.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Chapter · 1:09:01 The historical settlement is summarized as weakening industrial capacity without resolving the signatories' security fears.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 1:10:16 The treaty did not specify that turrets removed from scrapped ships had to be destroyed, leaving room to retain mountings or their components.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Notable Point · 1:13:23 France's capital-ship program addressed Italian competition in the Mediterranean rather than an unwinnable race with Britain or Germany.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Chapter · 1:14:55 Treaty rules allowed large numbers of slow, lightly armed sloops, but governments failed to exploit them before the Battle of the Atlantic.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 1:21:21 Adding torpedoes would distract sloops from anti-submarine escort work and duplicate missions better left to destroyers.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 1:24:21 A 27,500-ton treaty carrier would approach Audacious scale, leaving a Malta-class equivalent as a plausible wartime successor once limits ended.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 1:26:13 Continued replacement could redirect unemployment spending into industrial capacity while sustaining a stronger deterrent fleet.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 1:28:54 A larger independent naval air service could demand higher-powered engines and a dedicated single-seat fighter, though its exact design remains unknowable.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Notable Point · 1:29:51 An early-built sloop would not become useless before 1939 because its slow escort role left room to add ASDIC and radar.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 1:31:50 Completed Italian fast battleships could prompt Britain to build a roughly 40,000-ton F3-derived design with nine 16-inch guns.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Q&A · 1:35:38 HMS Unicorn's aviation-support mission and 24-knot design created a plausible argument that she fell outside carrier tonnage.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022
Notable Point · 1:38:40 The counterfactual keeps the Wall Street crash but changes selected electoral outcomes to isolate how different governments might negotiate.
From Equitable Naval Treaties Discussion (Live) · 16 Jun 2022