Could submarines in Indochina threaten Japan?
French and British submarines could not level Japanese dockyards, but they would create an ambush threat in the Far East.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Complete directory
Browse all time notes.
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
Scenario two: France continues the land war
The second branch keeps metropolitan France fighting after the German advance reaches the limit of its supply system.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Could France sustain a national redoubt?
A narrow Breton redoubt is rejected, while France as a whole retained reserves, supplies, and access to British reinforcement.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Would Malta become a larger Axis target?
A question about increased pressure on Malta leads to a discussion of the island's difficult geography and Axis limitations.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Would spare battleships be used for shore bombardment?
An enlarged Anglo-French fleet creates more bombardment options, but availability alone does not justify risking capital ships.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
The Atlantic campaign without French U-boat bases
Operating only from Germany or Norway shortens U-boat reach and concentrates Allied patrols across a northern bottleneck.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Where could Bismarck return without French ports?
A viewer asks where German capital ships could recover after an Atlantic sortie without occupied French bases.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Toulon and French industry remain in the war
France retaining Toulon and its industrial base strengthens Mediterranean operations beyond the advantages of an exile fleet.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Why Spain probably still stays out of the war
Even under heavier German pressure, Canaris's influence and Spanish reluctance would probably preserve nonbelligerence.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Would an Anglo-French atomic project end the war?
France's continued scientific contribution might support joint research, though the European war would probably end before a weapon could be completed.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
French ports remove the D-Day problem
Open Allied ports turn Operation Torch's troops into direct reinforcement for France instead of requiring a new amphibious lodgment.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Could Germany rely more on merchant raiders?
Converted merchant raiders still have to cross the concentrated northern patrol barrier, where radar can direct cruisers and destroyers against them.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Would Germany seek Japanese naval design help?
A question about Japanese carrier and long-range-submarine expertise becomes a lesson in institutional confidence and racial barriers inside the Axis.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Italian defeats could end the Mediterranean war
Losing Libya, Albania, and Greece could remove Mussolini and push Italy toward neutrality or the Allied side.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
No eastern front redirects Allied resources
A continuing western war removes the Arctic convoy effort and concentrates matériel in France while denying Germany captured French trucks.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
An earlier European victory reshapes the Far East
If Germany is defeated or contained by late 1941, a large Anglo-French fleet can assemble in the Indian Ocean before Japan moves south.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
The Burma Road stays open to China
A stronger Britain has less reason to close the Burma Road, keeping Nationalist China supplied and the Japanese Army committed there.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Japan loses the Indochina springboard to Singapore
Without secure bases in French Indochina, Japan cannot mount the historical drive through Malaya under the same conditions.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Would the Soviet Union attack Germany?
Possible Soviet intervention raises a second question about Poland, Allied commitments, and the transport limits on any advance west.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Did Britain underestimate Japan?
A viewer's claim about British underestimation is answered with the distinction between knowledge and available resources.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Which heavy ships could form the Eastern Fleet?
The counterfactual Eastern Fleet could include the Queen Elizabeths, Nelson and Rodney, Renown, a refitted Hood, and several carriers.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Which Royal Navy losses would still occur?
Royal Oak remains lost, while removed Mediterranean and French-base threats change many later casualties without making the fleet invulnerable.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Can Japan reach Dutch East Indies oil without Indochina?
Without the Indochina-Malaya springboard, Japan faces a longer and more strongly opposed route toward the oil fields of the Dutch East Indies.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Cunningham and Somerville become available in the east
A shorter Mediterranean struggle releases experienced commanders as well as ships for an Indian Ocean fleet.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Why the United States still joins a Far Eastern war
Even without a Pearl Harbor-first sequence, American interests make neutrality during a Japanese attack on Allied Asia unlikely.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
French aircraft and a larger carrier air arm
French carrier construction and a twin-engine naval aircraft could influence Allied carrier design and procurement.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Reversing the Royal Navy's 1940 nightmare
The conclusion explains why the simultaneous loss of Norway, France, and the French fleet shattered British prewar assumptions.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Churchill did not rule out war with Japan
The claim that Churchill promised Britain would never fight Japan is corrected by placing prewar concern about Japan alongside Germany and Italy.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Were Hood, Renown, and Repulse flush-decked?
A naval-architecture question receives a deliberately tentative answer that the British battlecruisers used broken or split-level main decks.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
Could safer shipping alter the Bengal famine?
Lower Atlantic losses and a safer Indian Ocean could preserve coastal food transport, though the deeper infrastructure failure remains colonial.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
How long would Tirpitz survive?
The final naval question asks whether Germany could preserve or even finish its largest battleships during a continuing French war.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
A different postwar naval balance
The closing thought replaces the familiar Cold War with a stronger Anglo-French bloc and a Soviet Union outside Eastern Europe.
From Patreon 62: What If The French Navy in 1940 Fought On? ·
The Northern Fleet grows from Russia's Arctic lifeline
Russia's Arctic coast remained a strategic lifeline, leading to the Northern Flotilla's creation and its wartime protection of Allied supply routes.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
The Baltic Fleet from Peter the Great to besieged Leningrad
Russia's rise as a Baltic power leads into revolution, Kronstadt, and the fleet's gunfire role during the siege of Leningrad.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
Black Sea shipbuilding survives empire, mutiny, and civil war
Sevastopol, wars with the Ottoman Empire, the Potemkin mutiny, and civil war all shaped the Soviet Black Sea Fleet inherited in 1941.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
Perry opens Japan partly to pre-empt Russia
The United States' forced opening of Japan appears here as great-power competition, with Perry moving before a Russian squadron could secure its own treaty.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
The Pacific Fleet rebuilds after Tsushima
Russia's Pacific story moves from Far Eastern expansion and the disaster of 1905 to the Soviet fleet's amphibious support against Japan in 1945.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
A Soviet missile battleship could have reshaped Western fleets
A counterfactual shows how an armored Soviet capital ship with missiles might have forced Western navies to retain or modernize their own gun ships.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
Why the Soviet Navy became cruiser-centered
The Soviet Union repeatedly planned battleships but completed cruisers, compelling rival navies to answer the ships that actually appeared.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
Hull efficiency limits the appeal of distributed flotillas
A comparison between integrated small-ship flotillas and larger combatants shows why communications and usable hull volume constrain distributed fleet concepts.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
Fighting the peace means shaping alliances before war
Cruisers give a defensive-minded state offensive diplomatic reach by appearing regularly, reassuring allies, and influencing neutral governments.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
Project 68 trades Kirov's 180 mm guns for twelve six-inch weapons
The Chapayev design evolves from the Kirov class but adopts a four-triple-turret, twelve-gun battery that resembles British light-cruiser practice.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
Names, purges, and war complicate the Chapayev class
The class name reflects Soviet political memory, while invasion and occupied shipyards postpone every completed cruiser until 1950.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
Chapayev combines fleet command, destroyer killing, range, and speed
Project 68 pairs twelve six-inch guns with command facilities, armor, torpedoes, 33.5-knot speed, and long cruising range.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
Kuznetsov's navy plans Project 68 against Japan
A young Nikolai Kuznetsov and surviving Imperial-era specialists revise Soviet plans around the Japanese threat, assigning twelve Project 68 cruisers to the future Pacific Fleet.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
An impossible battlefleet leaves Project 68 as the cornerstone
The battleships and battlecruisers exceed Soviet industrial capacity, but completed Project 68 cruisers become the practical instruments of power projection.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
Cruiser-centered fleets may be designed to shape the peace
The Soviet and later Russian cruiser pattern offers a warning against judging every fleet through Western expectations of wartime combat.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·
The Cold War lens understates early Soviet cruiser value
Judged only by later missile-era combat standards, the Chapayev class looks obsolete; judged as a command and presence asset, it served a wider strategic purpose.
From Chapyev Class (Projekt 68 of the Soviet Navy): Fighting the Peace ·