Video
Why the Royal Navy's Type 45s Daring Class Destroyers are what they are & what their future is?
Study Why the Royal Navy's Type 45s Daring Class Destroyers are what they are & what their future is?, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 31 Mar 2026, with 37 time notes. Topics include Air Defence, Destroyers, Fleet…
Time notes
- 0:00NFR-90 and the magazine-depth problemChapter
The Type 45 story starts with NFR-90, the Arleigh Burke comparison, and Royal Navy concern that a 48-missile air-defense magazine was too shallow for Cold War escort work.
- 5:04NFR-90's order book could not overcome cost and delayNotable Point
Britain and America expected to buy most of NFR-90's 52 ships, yet further development costs and approaching replacement deadlines helped break the coalition.
- 7:29Why NFR-90's common frigate coalition broke apartChapter
NFR-90's partners disagreed over national work share, expensive combat systems, and competing American-led and European-led air-defence programmes.
- 10:48The Type 42 replacement clock could not be pausedNotable Point
NFR-90's collapse left Britain with aging Type 42 destroyers whose hull life and Falklands service imposed a replacement deadline that diplomacy could not extend.
- 13:50What one missing Mark 41 module costs a frigateNotable Point
Adding one eight-cell Mark 41 module would increase a 40-cell frigate's magazine by 20 percent, raising a question about savings after radar and command systems have been paid for.
- 16:36Horizon, radar quality, and destroyer expectationsChapter
Britain, France, and Italy could share air-defense systems within Horizon yet still disagree over ship configuration, radar ambition, and the endurance expected of a deployable destroyer.
- 19:36How the 48-cell limit returned after the Cold WarNotable Point
Horizon revived the same 48-cell missile limit Britain had challenged in NFR-90, showing how post-Cold War savings reshaped the requirement.
- 22:56S1850M gives European air-defense ships their distant viewNotable Point
The Type 45's S1850M belongs to the Smart-L family used across European air-defense ships and supplies the long-range search picture behind the fleet-defense mission.
- 25:52PAMS cooperation split over SAMPSON and EMPAR radar fitsChapter
Britain joins Horizon and PAMS but chooses the active-array SAMPSON radar while France and Italy retain EMPAR, preserving common missiles without a common sensor fit.
- 28:07Leaving Horizon did not deliver an earlier destroyerNotable Point
British withdrawal from Horizon reflected size, launcher, work-share, and schedule disputes, yet the Franco-Italian ships reached service before or alongside HMS Daring.
- 31:19A hurried destroyer design combined several unproven systemsNotable Point
Type 45 combined a hurried design schedule with ambitions for new propulsion and other advanced systems, increasing the risk that integration problems would emerge in service.
- 33:29QuestionWhat would you do if the leaders of a destroyer project demanded all the latest technology in the first ships?AnswerQ&A
Introduce the equipment progressively across successive batches, while designing every ship so it can receive the final proven arrangement.
- 36:24A 36-escort fleet made 48 cells look less riskyChapter
An expected force of about 36 escorts made 48-cell magazines workable through multi-ship deployments, continuous construction, and regular replacement.
- 38:10Twenty-year frigates and forty-year refit demandsNotable Point
Type 23's intended service life illustrates why ships expected to remain useful for thirty or forty years need room for major changes.
- 42:01Mark 41 options and the SAMPSON advantageNotable Point
Reserved Mark 41 space offered possible SM-3 and Tomahawk loads, but missile integration still needed software development and the chosen hull constrained installation.
- 46:21Propulsion trouble and lost design slackChapter
WR-21 turbines, mismatched intercoolers, and limited diesel generation left the Type 45 power system with less resilience than the ship could have had.
- 50:35Electric propulsion promised flexibility but lacked redundancyChapter
Integrated electric propulsion could distribute machinery, isolate equipment for maintenance, and accept future loads, but Type 45 entered service with too little generating redundancy to exploit those strengths.
- 55:08First-of-class accounting and the cost of unfitted equipmentNotable Point
Front-loaded tooling and training costs complicate ship-price comparisons, while omitting equipment can leave expensive supporting systems underused.
- 57:48Extra drones and a stern boat ramp remained unfittedNotable Point
A larger hangar could have paired crewed helicopters with drones, while a rejected stern ramp offered boat launch and recovery at speed and possible future sonar space.
- 59:35Measure defence spending by the capability it buysNotable Point
Procurement totals become useful when they explain how many ships, missiles, and self-defence systems the money buys.
- 1:01:06Construction stretch and the six-ship forceChapter
Construction from Daring through Duncan shows how the planned 12-ship destroyer force narrowed to six while build times grew longer.
- 1:05:36The HMS Diana and HMS Decoy story remains unconfirmedNotable Point
The last two Type 45s may have been intended as HMS Diana and HMS Decoy, but the account rests on one private document and remains unconfirmed.
- 1:09:05The six-ship readiness model assumed a predictable worldChapter
The case for six Type 45s assumed chosen wars, two ships always available, and maintained dry docks. Later deployments and simultaneous upgrades broke those assumptions.
- 1:12:08HMS Daring's trials, coalition deployments, and disaster reliefChapter
Daring's service ranged from Sea Viper trials and Gulf patrols to multinational command, Typhoon Haiyan relief, and Black Sea exercises.
- 1:16:07Daring's completed power refit did not guarantee a return to seaNotable Point
Daring completed her power improvements in January 2023, but supplying parts to other Type 45s complicated her return and exposed the cost of having little reserve capacity.
- 1:19:06HMS Duncan carried NATO duties in a de facto five-ship forceChapter
Duncan's carrier, NATO, Black Sea, Mediterranean, and Ukraine-related deployments show the demand placed on the class after Daring's absence reduced six hulls to five in practice.
- 1:22:49Reserved machinery space made a stronger diesel installation possibleChapter
The Power Improvement Project uses the forward machinery room for a third generator, raising diesel output to nine megawatts while retaining gas turbines for maximum speed.
- 1:24:20Sea Ceptor takes over the shorter-range role from Aster 15Notable Point
Adding Sea Ceptor lets the main missile battery concentrate on Aster 30, while the explanation of Aster commonality includes booster and software changes.
- 1:26:59Twenty-four Sea Ceptors and the alternative Mark 41 loadNotable Point
A proposed Mark 41 fit would offer a larger quad-packed Sea Ceptor load and other missile options, while the separate 24-missile installation uses reserved forward space.
- 1:28:42BAE offered land-attack and anti-submarine Type 45 variantsNotable Point
Land-attack and ASW proposals explored other uses for the Type 45 hull, including more flight-deck and launcher space.
- 1:30:05QuestionIf Britain is short of air-defence destroyers, why not restart Type 45 production?AnswerQ&A
Britain could build something better using the naval architecture and shipyard skills developed through continuing construction since Type 45.
- 1:31:44Six land-attack variants could have retained a twelve-hull programmeChapter
A hypothetical mix of six air-defence destroyers and six Mark 41-armed land-attack ships could have preserved hull numbers and distributed fleet duties.
- 1:33:24Fewer destroyers also increased the burden on Type 23 frigatesNotable Point
Cutting destroyer hulls transferred duties to Type 23s, which had been planned as light frigates within a larger escort fleet.
- 1:34:45Uncrewed escorts still need endurance and shipboard maintenanceChapter
Small uncrewed craft face ocean endurance and maintenance demands, while an unarmed vessel directing them would still be a wartime target.
- 1:38:03A dock-equipped command ship could help rearm uncrewed vesselsNotable Point
A dock could bring uncrewed craft aboard for rearming, while exposed crane transfers leave conventional VLS replenishment constrained by handling, weather, and combat risk.
- 1:40:10Type 83's development leaves time for another Type 45 upgradeNotable Point
The long Type 42 replacement history supports planning another Type 45 upgrade, including power for future laser weapons, while Type 83 develops.
- 1:41:36QuestionWhat might the next generation of Type 45 upgrades require?AnswerQ&A
Possibly a hull section for additional power and VLS capacity, although the port shaft complicates that idea and a faster Type 83 programme could make it unnecessary.