Video
Check Campaign 15: UAD has updated & to Learn it's new ways I started another British Campaign
Study Check Campaign 15: UAD has updated & to Learn it's new ways I started another British Campaign, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 29 Apr 2024, with 29 time notes. Topics include Naval Aviation, Naval Infrastructure…
Time notes
- 1:38Confined seas and blue-water assetsNotable Point
Queen Elizabeth and Prince of Wales illustrate a caution about deploying large carriers in the Baltic or Black Sea, with somewhat more room available in the Mediterranean.
- 5:32Operations matter more than sink countsNotable Point
Jutland illustrates why a fleet's objectives and the outcome of its operations matter when assessing victory.
- 8:54Ukraine's maritime campaign beyond ship lossesNotable Point
The Black Sea discussion identifies preventing amphibious attack, disrupting Russian supplies, and protecting Ukrainian exports as operational objectives.
- 25:41Torpedo-heavy designs need speedNotable Point
Choosing a torpedo-heavy game design makes speed a requirement for reaching an effective launch position.
- 29:34Repairs compete with fleet constructionNotable Point
A campaign budget check separates new construction from the heavy recurring costs of repairs, ammunition, fuel, and shipyard development.
- 40:19Close-range 2-inch fire against torpedo boatsNotable Point
Closing to 2-inch gun range brings a high volume of light-gun fire against a torpedo boat.
- 42:09QuestionDid dock size limit the maximum size of the Royal Navy's G3 and N3 designs?AnswerQ&A
Yes. Dock size was the limiting factor until the next round of infrastructure investment.
- 43:00Royal Navy infrastructure cycles and wartime delayNotable Point
The G3 and N3 answer expands into the Royal Navy's recurring infrastructure investment and the upgrades disrupted by the First World War.
- 56:55An 85,000-ton battleship built around overwhelming firepowerNotable Point
A campaign battleship combines nine 16.5-inch guns, twenty-seven 6-inch guns, heavy armor, and 28-knot speed on an 85,000-ton hull.
- 1:08:20Graf Zeppelin and carrier aircraft without an operational carrierNotable Point
The uncompleted Graf Zeppelin prompts the observation that Germany still developed and completed aircraft intended for carrier operations.
- 1:08:47Building a screened battle line for long-range fireChapter
Six battleships are organized into divisions with cruiser and destroyer screens for a deliberate long-range engagement.
- 1:14:29Secondary batteries turn battleships into anti-destroyer screensChapter
The battle demonstrates how extensive 6-inch batteries can protect capital ships from destroyers while adding an exceptional weight of fire against larger targets.
- 1:21:17QuestionDid Italy gain an advantage over France because Italian ships could concentrate on the Mediterranean while French ships needed longer range for overseas commitments?AnswerQ&A
Yes. Italy could optimize for a concentrated Mediterranean role, while France had to choose between ships suited to that theatre and ships able to operate worldwide.
- 1:25:09QuestionDoes the battleship have enough ammunition storage for its exceptionally large gun battery?AnswerQ&A
Yes for this game design. Its 85,000-ton displacement is used to explain the space available for ammunition.
- 1:26:10QuestionWhich of the new books stand out, and why?AnswerQ&A
The US Navy squadron books stand out for their patches and organizational material. Another academic book has good content, but its unexplained jargon and high price make it difficult to recommend to a general reader.
- 1:33:11Smoke, weaving, and torpedoes in cruiser tacticsChapter
A light cruiser uses speed, smoke, course changes, and torpedoes to disrupt a stronger formation and draw it toward supporting heavy cruisers.
- 1:42:18Closing the range can surrender a fire-control advantageNotable Point
A campaign battleship gives up its fire-control advantage by closing on a maneuverable light cruiser.
- 1:45:53A fifteen-torpedo broadside explains repeated hitsNotable Point
Inspecting an opposing ship's launchers reveals how it can put fifteen torpedoes into one broadside during the game battle.
- 1:46:35Fishguard and the planned Newcastle diversionNotable Point
The Fishguard landing prompts discussion of a planned French diversion near Newcastle and doubts about the prospects of a force of roughly 1,500 men.
- 1:50:21Research links mines, screens, and fire controlNotable Point
Two campaign research checks connect electromagnetic minesweeping, upgraded mines, formation control, rangefinding, and radar development.
- 1:51:50Mining the English Channel from both shoresNotable Point
Control of southern England and northern France lets the campaign fleet mine the Channel while French convoys continue attempting the constrained route.
- 1:57:24QuestionDo people in Britain still hunt with dogs?AnswerQ&A
Some hunts used scent trails laid by people after the earlier Labour government's ban on hunting foxes with dogs.
- 2:01:24Six giant battleships at Denmark Strait and North CapeNotable Point
A deliberately game-based counterfactual places the campaign's six 85,000-ton battleships into familiar Royal Navy actions of the Second World War.
- 2:28:45Gunfire can give away a ship hidden by smokeNotable Point
An enemy ship's ineffective firing gives away its position when remaining hidden by smoke would offer better protection.
- 2:32:09Britain's warship preservation gapNotable Point
A mention of Olympia prompts criticism of how few ships survive from Britain's exceptionally large historical fleets.
- 2:35:50Concentrating fleets before moving into the MediterraneanNotable Point
Three fleets are brought together against western France before a planned transfer of large forces into the Mediterranean.
- 2:38:39An Alaska-inspired cruiser meets the game's hull limitsChapter
A new heavy cruiser starts with a 12-inch-gun ambition, but the available hull and machinery force compromises in armament, protection, and speed.
- 2:46:53Reducing gun calibre to balance a cruiserNotable Point
The cruiser design moves through smaller gun options and changes in fittings as its centre of mass and displacement remain difficult to balance.
- 2:52:56A stable cruiser can still exceed its displacement limitNotable Point
The closing design remains overweight despite a stable profile, leading to a decision to wait for further cruiser and hull research.