Video
Check Campaign 13: UAD has updated & to Learn it's new ways I started another British Campaign
Study Check Campaign 13: UAD has updated & to Learn it's new ways I started another British Campaign, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 15 Apr 2024, with 31 time notes. Topics include Battle Of Jutland, Cruisers, Fleet…
Time notes
- 15:04Naval research must be balanced against ships in serviceNotable Point
Armor forging, fire control, radar, boilers, and minefields compete for funding, but technical investment only matters if the navy also builds enough ships to use it.
- 19:43A convoy attack succeeds by reaching the merchant shipsNotable Point
In an Ultimate Admiral: Dreadnoughts engagement, the attacker treats the transports as the mission objective and the escorts as obstacles, while the defending cruisers compound defeat by chasing a destroyer after the convoy is lost.
- 27:55Real weapon use favors compact, practical movementNotable Point
An aside on the archery feat called a Robin Hood and on economical sword movement separates practical weapon use from popular expectations and theatrical screen combat.
- 29:36Why sea control consumes cruisersNotable Point
Cruisers are needed in quantity because naval theatres have too many routes and local threats for a fleet to cover from a few concentrated positions.
- 31:07A shield is also a close-combat weaponNotable Point
A shield's boss and rim let it serve as an active close-combat weapon as well as protection.
- 35:13The Royal Navy paired cruiser numbers with Tribal flotillasNotable Point
The interwar requirement for about seventy cruisers sat alongside a plan for successive British, Australian, and Canadian flotillas of Tribal-class destroyers and follow-on ships.
- 42:15QuestionWill navies rely on dedicated drone ships, or make uncrewed systems part of ordinary warships and air groups?AnswerQ&A
Uncrewed systems are more likely to extend the sensing, endurance, and anti-submarine reach of many ships than to create a wholly separate drone fleet.
- 53:58QuestionCould underwater torpedo launchers use a partially trainable mount, or could more launchers be placed in the bow?AnswerQ&A
They are possible, but the extra firing arc must be weighed against below-waterline sealing, hull complexity, vulnerable internal volume, and disruption of the bow form.
- 1:04:56Pre-dreadnought is a retrospective labelNotable Point
Pre-dreadnought is a later category, while super-dreadnought was a contemporary term whose meaning shifted as larger-gunned battleships appeared.
- 1:12:48Jutland scouting needs reliable signalsNotable Point
A Battle of Jutland comparison shows why fast scouts must deliver usable contact reports to the battle line, not merely find the enemy.
- 1:24:35Why extended belt armor can be thinnerNotable Point
Armor beyond the main belt protects the hull ends but can be thinner because end-on hits arrive at less favorable angles and those spaces sit outside the central survival zone.
- 1:28:08Draw the torpedo attack before closing the rangeNotable Point
In the campaign battle, a deliberate closing action accepts some risk to trigger the enemy light forces' torpedo launch, leaving fewer weapons available during the decisive phase of the engagement.
- 1:30:12Churchill's histories also reveal Churchill's politicsNotable Point
Churchill's history books can be read both as accounts of the past and as evidence of an influential politician's priorities, emphases, and omissions.
- 1:45:25A beaten force must use the remaining gap to withdrawNotable Point
Once the French light forces in the campaign battle are surrounded and unable to hide in smoke, preserving ships and crews depends on recognizing defeat and escaping through the one open sector.
- 1:46:38Combat results expose warship design flawsNotable Point
In the campaign, manually observing battles reveals whether poor maneuvering and gunnery come from command choices or from a ship design that needs a targeted refit.
- 1:48:23What heavy shells can do to destroyersNotable Point
Even when a battleship's heavy shells are hard to land on a distant destroyer, a penetrating hit can inflict destructive flooding and structural damage.
- 1:51:21Replacement time shapes attrition prioritiesNotable Point
Within the campaign, the commander prioritizes enemy cruisers over destroyers because cruisers take longer to replace, while accepting destroyer losses that his own shipbuilding system can restore more readily.
- 1:52:14Speed and smoke do not guarantee escapeNotable Point
A fast destroyer can break contact by changing course and stretching a search, but smoke at the wrong range may advertise rather than hide its position.
- 2:13:54Torpedo speed can cost the range a cruiser needsNotable Point
In the campaign's design screen, a mature light-cruiser design is retained because faster torpedoes would shorten useful range and the remaining weight margin offers no improvement worth sacrificing survivability.
- 2:19:46Refitting a battleship for long-range gunfireNotable Point
In the campaign, the underperforming battleship receives radar, sonar, revised ammunition, armor changes, and longer guns to improve the long-range accuracy exposed as deficient in combat.
- 2:30:51Continuous construction keeps cruiser strength recoverableNotable Point
Within the campaign, a two-year battleship pipeline and a new order for twenty-four light cruisers illustrate why wartime fleet strength depends on construction already under way and spare industrial capacity.
- 2:34:50A needed refit still has an availability costNotable Point
In the campaign, the flawed battleships are withdrawn for modernization only after checking whether their absence would reduce the chance of completing the invasion of western France.
- 2:35:39Submarines can free the battle fleet from port defenseNotable Point
In the game's operational model, cheap submarines make attacks and blockades around home ports costly enough that the main fleet can concentrate on offensive operations elsewhere.
- 2:38:02Tillman linked political leverage to naval constructionNotable Point
Tillman's collection of personal information, Senate influence, treaty bargaining, and preferred warship programs could become parts of the same political transaction.
- 2:43:02A twelve-gun fast battleship needs a larger hullNotable Point
Keeping twelve 15-inch guns and about 28 knots would force a capital ship to grow longer and wider so it could carry both the extra armament and the boilers needed for speed.
- 3:21:13Two carriers leave little margin for availabilityNotable Point
Reducing the Royal Navy from four flight decks to two makes even a minor maintenance problem visible at the level of national operations.
- 3:22:17A radar refit forces weight and stability compromisesNotable Point
In the campaign design screen, adding radar to the Canada-class battleship requires thousands of tons of savings, careful port-starboard balance, reduced pitch, and concessions in armor, machinery, and cruising range.
- 3:22:34Leaving NATO would trigger a U.S. constitutional fightNotable Point
A 2024 political aside distinguishes presidential foreign-policy power from congressional treaty authority and argues that unilateral U.S. withdrawal from NATO would face major legal and political obstacles.
- 3:27:29Age limits do not solve candidate-selection incentivesNotable Point
The Biden-Trump rematch prompts an institutional critique of candidate age, constitutional limits, name recognition, and the barriers facing less familiar national leaders.
- 3:39:26Ideological purity can crowd out pragmatic governmentNotable Point
Ideology can supply political ideas, but party leadership still requires bargaining, adaptation, and pragmatic judgment.
- 3:48:18Combining local elections with proportional representationNotable Point
A proposed two-chamber electoral system puts constituency winners in one house and the strongest losing candidates in a proportionally allocated second house.