Video
Bruships 102: New Books, Sea Wolves & Skagerrak
Study Bruships 102: New Books, Sea Wolves & Skagerrak, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 12 Feb 2023, with 71 time notes. Topics include Anti-Submarine Warfare, Battleships, Fleet Carriers.
Time notes
- 4:22QuestionCould a battleship carry four quadruple 16-inch or 18-inch gun turrets?AnswerQ&A
It is theoretically possible, but the ship, construction facilities, dry docks, and support infrastructure would all have to be exceptionally large.
- 5:12QuestionHow would the Royal Navy in the age of sail have used a practical low-technology refrigeration device?AnswerQ&A
It would have welcomed any system that kept food, especially vegetables, fresh for longer because diet was central to health at sea.
- 12:51QuestionHow should historians judge Soviet attacks on ships carrying German civilians near the end of the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
Ships also carrying troops could qualify as military transports, the victors controlled postwar prosecutions, and moral judgment still requires the contemporary wartime context.
- 16:11Invasion, blockade, and the human cost of defeating JapanNotable Point
A discussion of the atomic bombings compares them with American invasion plans and a British blockade strategy against Japan.
- 18:09An 18-inch HMS Renown and Germany's surface fleetNotable Point
A three-turret 18-inch refit for Renown becomes a counterfactual about early German capital-ship losses and later sortie decisions.
- 19:16QuestionWould 20-inch or 21-inch guns be worthwhile on a battleship?AnswerQ&A
Their loading and maintenance burden would outrun the useful increase in firepower; only a much larger jump might justify the slower rate of fire.
- 21:52QuestionWill uncrewed ship-killing systems attack fleets in massed swarms?AnswerQ&A
They are a credible future threat, but promotional footage overstates capability by omitting jamming, defenses, reliability limits, and the difference between spectacle and realistic training.
- 27:05QuestionWhich naval story would make a good film or television adaptation?AnswerQ&A
He would adapt Richard Woodman's Nathaniel Drinkwater novels as a multi-series drama, valuing their accuracy, grit, and fidelity to naval life.
- 28:03QuestionHow could the Royal Navy field a 9.2-inch heavy cruiser in time to avoid the postwar cancellation cycle, and what would it displace?AnswerQ&A
It would need to start in 1939 and would probably consume resources otherwise used for Crown Colony-class light cruisers.
- 32:05QuestionCould the Bismarck-class hull have carried six or eight 18-inch guns?AnswerQ&A
Only after a major hull redesign, because a large displacement by itself does not guarantee the breadth, structural load paths, and support points needed for much heavier guns.
- 33:18QuestionDid the Tsingtao simulations account for Japanese Type 93 torpedoes cooking off in their launchers?AnswerQ&A
Not explicitly, but the danger reinforces the conclusion that the engaged Japanese ships would not escape undamaged.
- 35:08QuestionWhat would happen if treaty cruisers adopted 10-inch guns?AnswerQ&A
The treaty displacement would likely rise, several navies would adopt the calibre, Deutschland's 11-inch advantage would shrink, and protection would be sacrificed for speed and firepower.
- 36:43Siege customs, war-crime language, and presentismNotable Point
A discussion of siege customs shows why modern legal categories require care when they are applied to earlier warfare.
- 41:49Falklands weapons and advertised performanceNotable Point
A compact Falklands comparison warns that manufacturer claims cannot be treated as combat probabilities for either side.
- 43:59QuestionDid anyone try to create a surface ship that could serve as a tender or carrier for Zeppelins?AnswerQ&A
Britain, the United States, and Italy considered airship-tender concepts before the First World War, though it is unclear whether any progressed far beyond design work.
- 45:53QuestionWhy has television not produced a Band of Brothers-style series centered on a warship or naval unit?AnswerQ&A
Naval warfare offers less continuous contact and longer intervals between major actions, making a single-unit sea narrative harder to sustain than an infantry or bomber story.
- 49:12QuestionHow dangerous would three late-war Japanese armored-flight-deck carriers have been?AnswerQ&A
The ships and aircraft could be capable, but Japan lacked enough experienced aviators, carrier crews, and damage-control personnel to use them effectively.
- 53:37QuestionHow far could pre-Columbian societies in the Americas have traveled at sea, and why is the evidence so limited?AnswerQ&A
Large river craft and outrigger technology suggest meaningful capability, but surviving traces do not support firm long-distance claims, while epidemic loss erased much knowledge that might have clarified the picture.
- 56:48QuestionDid navies seriously pursue 9.4-inch guns instead of the more familiar 9.2-inch caliber?AnswerQ&A
Several navies experimented with the slightly larger caliber, but the designs generally returned to 9.2-inch weapons.
- 57:23QuestionHow significant was the loss associated with the Library of Alexandria?AnswerQ&A
The loss is incalculable because the institution represented a teaching and scholarly culture whose vanished works might have answered many unresolved questions about ancient knowledge.
- 1:00:11QuestionWhat proportion of ships actually engaged in combat, and how did that differ between the age of sail and the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
Many sailing warships could pass through a war without firing in anger, while global air and submarine threats exposed a much larger share of Second World War ships to attack.
- 1:01:54Royal Navy 18-inch guns before the treaty battleshipsNotable Point
A historical correction traces British 18-inch artillery from First World War capital-ship projects into shore-bombardment monitors.
- 1:03:23QuestionWhich ship or formation would make the best basis for a naval Band of Brothers-style series?AnswerQ&A
USS Enterprise (CV-6) or a Tribal-class destroyer flotilla would offer varied deployments and a large enough cast for intersecting stories.
- 1:05:13QuestionWith knowledge of future treaty cheating, how should Britain comply in appearance while preparing stronger ships?AnswerQ&A
Britain could build ships such as Nelson and Rodney for rapid machinery upgrades and exploit measurement ambiguities while preserving the appearance of compliance.
- 1:06:39QuestionWhy was there not a larger Fleet Air Arm squadron presence at Hong Kong and Singapore in the 1920s and 1930s?AnswerQ&A
Available aircraft were largely carrier-based, and wartime demand pulled scarce Fleet Air Arm resources toward active operations, especially in the Mediterranean.
- 1:09:06QuestionWhy were no British warships used as targets in the Bikini atomic-bomb tests?AnswerQ&A
Britain was not offering ships for destruction, especially as Anglo-American nuclear cooperation was already fraying after their joint wartime effort.
- 1:11:31QuestionIf a 1911 battleship had to use wing turrets, what arrangement would be the least bad choice?AnswerQ&A
He would use six turrets: two forward, two aft, and a staggered pair of wing turrets, with heavy twins on the wings and triple 14-inch centerline mounts.
- 1:12:34QuestionWhich Royal Navy base or station lost since 1945 would be most useful to retain or restore?AnswerQ&A
A shipbuilding royal dockyard, particularly Pembroke, could build ships and benchmark private-yard prices.
- 1:16:09QuestionIf all four CVA-01 carriers had entered service, would Britain still focus on anti-submarine and Norway commitments for NATO, or shift elsewhere?AnswerQ&A
Britain would probably become a major Strike Fleet Atlantic carrier contributor while retaining amphibious and anti-submarine roles around Norway.
- 1:17:27QuestionCould a Royal Navy ship carry its entire crew in its boats after abandoning ship?AnswerQ&A
The crew's survival capacity was distributed across boats, inflatable life rafts, Carley floats, and other flotation systems rather than conventional lifeboats alone.
- 1:18:30QuestionHow might the early Cold War have changed if the United States had honored its wartime atomic agreement with Britain?AnswerQ&A
Britain could have possessed an operational bomb and facilities by about 1947, deepening Anglo-American trust and placing a second Western nuclear power ahead of the Soviet test.
- 1:19:29QuestionWhich religious policy had a particularly surprising effect on naval strategy?AnswerQ&A
Louis XIV's removal of Huguenot officers stands out because it sacrificed a large share of the French Navy's best and most experienced leadership for confessional uniformity.
- 1:21:06QuestionCould Commonwealth navies use Denmark's StanFlex approach to build a common family of frigates?AnswerQ&A
The proposal favors licensing Denmark's modular approach and building ships in the Iver Huitfeldt mold, one of the Danish Navy's strongest modern procurement decisions.
- 1:21:40QuestionHow would the American Revolution have changed if the colonies that became Canada had joined the revolt?AnswerQ&A
The conflict would have become a much larger eighteen-colony war, but stronger British access, important commerce, and easier reinforcement in the north make the outcome difficult to reduce to a simple rebel advantage.
- 1:23:22QuestionWhich ship would win, HMS Vanguard or a fully refitted HMS Hood?AnswerQ&A
Vanguard has the advantage in armor and concentrated firepower, while a refitted Hood retains a small edge in speed and acceleration.
- 1:23:56QuestionDoes Britain independently build the warheads carried by its Trident submarines, and why might one missile carry fewer warheads than its capacity?AnswerQ&A
The warheads are British-built while the missile system is American, and a missile can trade warhead count for penetration aids and decoys within broadly comparable arms-control responsibilities.
- 1:28:48QuestionWas the Royal Navy dockyard at Gibraltar abolished?AnswerQ&A
No. It was privatized and opened to commercial work, while Royal Navy use remained its principal role.
- 1:30:33Skagerrak through German fleet recordsChapter
A book-review chapter introduces Gary Staff's Skagerrak as a German-side route into Jutland planning, fleet command, and the battle's sequence.
- 1:34:18Scheer, Holtzendorff, and German naval strategyNotable Point
A German High Seas Fleet passage contrasts Scheer's popularity with Holtzendorff's colder strategic professionalism and submarine-war advocacy.
- 1:40:12QuestionHow many expansion stages remain practical in a multiple-expansion marine steam engine, and why not add still more pressure stages?AnswerQ&A
Quintuple expansion is the practical upper edge because extra stages demand very high boiler pressure and introduce flow complexity and blowback risks.
- 1:40:35QuestionWhat are the major engineering problems in a large warship machinery refit?AnswerQ&A
Changing boilers and machinery also means replacing piping and cutting new routes through the ship's structure, so the work is extensive and must be executed precisely.
- 1:42:30Specialists for Japanese naval history and journal researchNotable Point
Two historian recommendations point viewers toward specialist work on Japan and research grounded in naval journals.
- 1:45:21The Roman harpax as a stand-off boarding weaponNotable Point
A discussion of the harpax shows how Roman forces used a projectile and cable to turn a sea fight into the close combat they preferred.
- 1:52:39Sea Wolves and catastrophic submarine sinkingsChapter
A reading from Sea Wolves uses the hospital ship Centaur to discuss submarine attacks, mass casualties, and what the book includes or omits.
- 1:54:25QuestionWhat if the Royal Navy had working gas turbines for its Second World War gunboats without affecting aircraft-engine development?AnswerQ&A
The result would be steam-gunboat-sized craft capable of roughly 40 to 50 knots.
- 1:56:25QuestionWere the Upholder-class boats intended to be the Royal Navy's final conventional submarines, and what would have followed them?AnswerQ&A
No. Another SSK class was expected to incorporate the next stage of technology, consistent with a British pattern of alternating conventional and nuclear attack-submarine development.
- 2:01:40QuestionWhy did the British put external torpedo tubes on Second World War submarines, especially D-class and similar boats?AnswerQ&A
The extra tubes served an ambush-predator doctrine: fire a large first salvo, then leave or use aft-facing tubes while being hunted.
- 2:03:01QuestionCould French cruise missiles remove the Royal Navy's reliance on American Tomahawks?AnswerQ&A
They would replace one foreign technology source with another, although British technical capacity gives the Royal Navy unusual freedom to maintain and support imported weapons itself.
- 2:04:12QuestionWhich navy built submarines best suited to the tactics and missions they actually used during the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
There is no universal winner: British ocean-going boats were awkward in the Mediterranean, Italian boats suited that sea better, and German or American designs are stronger candidates when matched to their intended missions.
- 2:08:23QuestionWhere should Poland buy submarines if it wants cost control and genuine technology sharing?AnswerQ&A
Swedish or Baltic partners are favored because French offers are expensive and tend to keep construction and economic benefit in France.
- 2:09:18QuestionHow good would German Type XXI submarines have been if they mostly used pattern-running torpedoes, acoustic homing torpedoes, and larger numbers?AnswerQ&A
They would be more capable and harder to handle, but Allied escort carriers, escorts, homing torpedoes, and continuing frigate production would still matter heavily.
- 2:11:18Hypersonic missiles without the hypeChapter
A World Naval Review reading defines hypersonic missiles, compares them with re-entry vehicles, and stresses speed, maneuverability, heat, and interception problems.
- 2:17:04QuestionIf a January 1939 Tsingtao incident led to war, would longer distances and Japanese air power require the Royal Navy to build stronger escort air-defense ships?AnswerQ&A
The escort demand would differ from the Atlantic because Britain could blockade from Singapore and the South China Sea, while Japan lacked the later infrastructure for many island offensives in early 1939.
- 2:20:34QuestionWhich senior naval officers were especially favored or trusted by Churchill, Roosevelt, Japan's emperor, and Stalin?AnswerQ&A
The examples are Keyes and Cunningham for Churchill, Nimitz and a working respect for King under Roosevelt, Yonai in Japan, and more tentatively Gorshkov for Stalin.
- 2:22:18QuestionWould a 1939 war with Japan justify a new cross-India railway for troops and stores?AnswerQ&A
Possibly, but planners would first compare it with the cheaper option of shipping supplies directly to eastern Indian ports closer to Burma and China.
- 2:23:10QuestionWould Britain have benefited from consolidating Rolls-Royce and Napier into a single aero-engine company?AnswerQ&A
No. Competing design teams can preserve different technical approaches, and a useful capability can create new applications of its own.
- 2:23:51QuestionWould Ark Royal have been ready for deployment if the Tsingtao crisis produced war in January 1939?AnswerQ&A
Although only recently commissioned, Ark Royal had already conducted testing with aircraft and would probably deploy quickly alongside Glorious, ready or not.
- 2:27:49Royal Escape and the origins of English royal yachtsChapter
A reading from Royal Yachts Under Sail traces Royal Escape from Charles II's flight to a small royal vessel and rare record of a mid-seventeenth-century trader.
- 2:31:31QuestionWhat would have happened if uranium bound for the Manhattan Project had been involved in a serious accident at Hunters Point?AnswerQ&A
The uranium itself would not produce a nuclear detonation, but an adjacent conventional explosion could scatter radioactive material, while the loss and secrecy breach would badly strain Anglo-American trust.
- 2:40:38QuestionHow might the Royal Navy have fitted Sea Wolf to Type 42 destroyers after the Falklands War?AnswerQ&A
The proposals included reviving Lightweight Sea Wolf and, on Batch 3 ships, adding a raised Sea Wolf launcher around the existing Sea Dart and forward gun arrangement.
- 2:43:31QuestionCould the Zumwalt hull have succeeded if the U.S. Navy had introduced its advanced systems more gradually?AnswerQ&A
Yes. Fit proven guns and missiles first, preserve modular space for later railguns or other systems, and let the hull enter service without depending on every new technology at once.
- 2:44:42QuestionHave any large Second World War merchant ships been preserved in the United Kingdom?AnswerQ&A
No large example comes to mind. Merchant ships are repeatedly resold across companies and countries until no original owner remains to preserve them.
- 2:49:04QuestionWas it inefficient for Airbus to divide A300 components, including wing work, among different European countries?AnswerQ&A
The arrangement carried coordination costs, but it distributed political and industrial support, widened the aircraft's home markets, and helped make a multinational program viable.
- 2:58:17QuestionCould the B-52 remain in service long enough to outlast the B-21 as well as earlier replacement aircraft?AnswerQ&A
It is treated as plausible because the B-52 had already survived the service lives or replacement expectations associated with the B-1, B-2, and F-117.
- 3:01:21Choosing books for public discussionNotable Point
Public book discussions emphasize worthwhile scholarship while still criticizing misleading cover design.
- 3:10:44QuestionIf the French carrier Béarn had been lost during the Second World War, what cause would have been most plausible?AnswerQ&A
A submarine attack is the likeliest cause, given the routes Béarn used between the Caribbean and the United States for conversion and aircraft-support work.
- 3:13:14QuestionHow are Patrick O'Brian's Aubrey-Maturin novels rated, and why prefer the Drinkwater series?AnswerQ&A
He regards the Aubrey-Maturin books as very good, while his personal attachment to Richard Woodman's Drinkwater series gives it the edge for him.
- 3:30:42QuestionWithout the shootdown of Korean Air Lines Flight 007, when might its navigation error have become clear, and did the disaster directly create civilian GPS access?AnswerQ&A
The deviation might only have become undeniable near the aircraft's destination, the incident prompted route and safety changes, and wider civilian GPS use resulted from a broader commercial and policy decision rather than this event alone.
- 3:37:42QuestionWhich theaters produced the most successful tank commanders of the Second World War?AnswerQ&A
The largest individual tallies generally came from the Eastern Front, while Britain developed notable armored experience in North Africa that later strengthened veteran units in northwest Europe.
- 3:45:23QuestionWhat design alternatives will the Queen Elizabeth-class discussion cover?AnswerQ&A
The proposals included 28 knots and twelve guns in triple turrets, with a 16.5-inch weapon considered before the Admiralty rejected too many simultaneous changes.
- 3:52:05Reading an international Boxer Rebellion uniform photographNotable Point
A shared historical photograph becomes a lesson in distinguishing sailors and soldiers, identifying national uniforms, and reading period equipment carefully.