Video
Admirals, Lexingtons & Tosa; What if the Washington Naval Treaty built them?
Study Admirals, Lexingtons & Tosa; What if the Washington Naval Treaty built them?, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 31 Jan 2023, with 22 time notes. Topics include Alternate History, Battlecruisers, Fleet Carriers.
Time notes
- 5:40The Admirals and Lexingtons break the treaty premiseChapter
The counterfactual starts by showing why keeping all Admirals and Lexingtons forces a different Washington Naval Treaty settlement.
- 8:58British finance and procurement shape the treaty bluffNotable Point
Britain keeps the Admiral-class hulls as bargaining counters and bets that U.S. legislators will not fund the balanced fleet needed to exploit nominal parity.
- 13:45Jellicoe's three-fleet plan supplies the deployment modelNotable Point
A Mediterranean, Atlantic, and Indian Ocean structure gives the counterfactual fast capital ships and carriers a plausible peacetime role.
- 14:22A Wilhelmshaven raid proves the carrier-strike ideaChapter
A partly successful First World War torpedo attack on Wilhelmshaven gives Beatty and Sueter evidence that shipborne aviation can strike a fleet in harbor.
- 19:40The Fleet Air Arm remains under naval controlChapter
A proven carrier-strike role lets Beatty and Jellicoe keep fleet aircraft naval, with long-term effects on organization and engine development.
- 22:40Battlecruiser tonnage becomes trade-protection politicsNotable Point
A revised capital-ship settlement uses heavy battlecruisers and trade protection to keep the arms-control deal politically plausible.
- 26:53Tosa gives Japan a visible treaty winChapter
Japan's incentive in the altered settlement is completing Tosa, gaining a prestige battleship without making the treaty collapse.
- 27:18The revised fleet lists let every navy claim a victoryNotable Point
The altered settlement gives Britain five new 16-inch capital ships, the United States its desired six-gunship total, and Japan a larger share than it received historically.
- 30:24A strike-carrier category solves the conversion problemChapter
The carrier side of the counterfactual creates a larger conversion-only strike-carrier category alongside smaller standard carriers.
- 35:07Six Lexington hulls become a logistics advantageNotable Point
The U.S. gains a common Lexington machinery pool, but the paired battlecruiser-and-carrier force complicates carrier armament choices.
- 37:51Britain turns Admirals into carriers and keeps G3 logicChapter
The Royal Navy's cleanest path is three Admiral-class carriers plus new fast capital ships rather than a mixed one-off carrier fleet.
- 44:19An F3 turret layout trims weight and opens the sternNotable Point
Shrinking the G3 into a treaty-compliant F3 favors a compact all-forward battery and leaves useful space for secondary and anti-aircraft weapons.
- 46:45Five new capital ships produce a three-tier battle fleetChapter
A larger 16-inch construction program could yield faster Nelson-type battleships and a layered force of mobile, deployable, and presence ships.
- 49:10Tosa becomes Japan's ten-gun prestige battleshipNotable Point
Completing Tosa gives Japan the world's largest battleship in the early 1920s and a ten-gun symbol of parity despite Anglo-American numerical superiority.
- 50:16Early fast task forces reshape naval aviationChapter
British strike carriers sailing with battlecruisers create an early fast task-force model and could change Fleet Air Arm organization.
- 54:34The London Treaty risks triggering a new building spreeChapter
With most expendable ships already gone, reducing fleet numbers in 1930 could release enough replacement tonnage to stimulate new fast-capital-ship construction.
- 58:47Carrier groups open the war from three oceansChapter
Fifteen years of strike-carrier practice distributes British carrier groups across the Atlantic, Mediterranean, and Indian Ocean and makes an early attack on German naval bases plausible.
- 1:03:40Pacific carrier teams require fast oilers and heavy escortsChapter
Routine Lexington carrier-battlecruiser groups drive fast-oiler construction and recast the battlecruiser as a carrier guardian and escort flagship.
- 1:07:01A worked-up carrier group reverses the Glorious encounterNotable Point
A large carrier operating with airborne reconnaissance and a battlecruiser escort turns the historical loss of Glorious into a dangerous interception for the Germans.
- 1:09:24Multi-carrier practice enlarges Taranto and Pacific cooperationChapter
More large decks and established tandem doctrine make early-war multi-carrier strikes and Anglo-American Pacific task groups more likely.
- 1:12:30A larger 1920s program preserves capital-ship infrastructureNotable Point
Building and supporting more large ships sustains design experience, enlarges docks, and changes later modernization and construction choices.
- 1:16:20A perceived treaty victory could redirect Japanese naval thinkingNotable Point
The closing counterfactual asks how leaving Washington with Tosa and a sense of success might alter Japan's carrier program, strike force, and national outlook.