Video
Action of the 18th June 1799: How to Lose Frigates and Influence (Live)
Study Action of the 18th June 1799: How to Lose Frigates and Influence (Live), a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 18 Jun 2022, with 54 time notes. Topics include Action of 18 June 1799, Age Of Sail Frigates, French Navy.
Time notes
- 4:04QuestionWhy could a battleship with apparently substantial deck armor still be penetrated while another ship survived a direct hit?AnswerQ&A
Armor layout matters as well as total thickness, because plate joints can become weak points and staggered layers can prevent those gaps from lining up.
- 6:50QuestionWhich ship was supposed to carry regimental colours back to Britain after they were removed from the regiment at Waterloo?AnswerQ&A
They were apparently taken to a port and placed on the first ship ready to sail, with no specific vessel assigned in advance.
- 7:07Why losing five frigates matteredChapter
The opening explains how frigates supported scouting, charting, and blockade-running, and why repeated losses hollowed out French naval skill.
- 17:20Gibraltar and the uncertainty of Napoleon's expeditionChapter
Napoleon's route through Malta to Egypt created a strategic guessing game in which Gibraltar remained Britain's essential Mediterranean gateway.
- 22:00Why Egypt was a poor route to IndiaChapter
The proposed advance from Egypt towards India depended on hazardous overland conquest or an improvised ocean crossing that French naval power could not reliably support.
- 26:06QuestionHow were Catholics treated while serving in British forces during this period?AnswerQ&A
Formal restrictions existed, but many commanders pragmatically ignored them when Catholic, especially Irish, personnel were essential to their crews and regiments.
- 28:26Why Hitler could not attack Gibraltar through SpainNotable Point
A Second World War comparison links Gibraltar's value to Hitler's failed efforts to obtain Franco's permission for a German attack through Spain.
- 28:50QuestionHow long did Nelson miss the French fleet by when he first reached Egypt?AnswerQ&A
Accounts differ between hours and days, but he missed them by only a short interval.
- 30:20Released French sailors become an improvised support poolNotable Point
Nelson avoided the cost of feeding captured French sailors by releasing them, leaving Napoleon to employ the survivors on Nile craft, galleys, and the expedition's remaining frigates.
- 31:31Perrée's depleted frigate squadron in EgyptChapter
Three frigates and two brigs carried supplies and artillery through loose British and Ottoman blockades after surrendering weapons and ammunition to the French army.
- 37:25QuestionHow capable was Sidney Smith, especially during the Acre campaign?AnswerQ&A
He was a brilliant practical operator filling an undeveloped special-operations role, though some short-term successes could create later problems.
- 41:15Perrée rises from merchant service to French flag commandNotable Point
Revolutionary France drew Jean-Baptiste Perrée's merchant experience into a navy short of trained leaders and promoted him with exceptional speed.
- 43:34John Markham connects sea command to Admiralty leadershipNotable Point
Markham's path from a well-connected schoolboy and wartime midshipman to First Naval Lord combined operational experience with patronage and Admiralty service.
- 45:32Junon links peacetime training to expeditionary warNotable Point
Junon's career runs from a peacetime training squadron and West African diplomacy to Sardinian landings, ammunition delivery at Acre, and British service as Princess Charlotte.
- 48:24QuestionDid British sailors really call Napoleon "Boney," as they do in the Hornblower novels?AnswerQ&A
Yes; "Boney" was used alongside many ruder names.
- 48:43QuestionWhy does Europe seem to produce one would-be conqueror in every century?AnswerQ&A
It is not really once per century; most centuries have several expansive rulers, although only one or two make a serious attempt at much wider conquest.
- 49:42Centaur's broadside and littoral reachNotable Point
HMS Centaur combines the heavy broadside of a versatile 74-gun ship with a later connection to the improvised British fortification of Diamond Rock.
- 53:44Why Courageuse had a short Royal Navy careerNotable Point
Courageuse served France for about eleven years and Britain for only four, showing that capture did not guarantee a long active career under a new flag.
- 54:20Hermione reconstructed as an eighteenth-century frigateNotable Point
The full-size Hermione reconstruction puts the frigate type that carried Lafayette to America into working, seagoing form.
- 59:01Different approaches to warship standardizationNotable Point
Bellona's design family reflects the incremental experiments permitted by British building depth while France sought standardized output.
- 1:01:38QuestionWas the Bellona class a 64-gun ship type in Royal Navy service, as labelled in Ultimate Admiral: Age of Sail?AnswerQ&A
No; the Royal Navy's Bellona class consisted of 74-gun ships and represented an early form of the 74.
- 1:01:53QuestionWhat was the French Navy good at besides supplying captured ships to the Royal Navy?AnswerQ&A
It had real skill, but political upheaval and losses repeatedly broke the transmission of institutional knowledge between generations.
- 1:02:44Alceste changes hands across three naviesNotable Point
Alceste's French, British, Sardinian, French, and British service captures the fluid ownership of warships in the Revolutionary Wars.
- 1:07:20QuestionWere captured ships ever swapped back to their original nations for an equivalent vessel?AnswerQ&A
Equivalent ship exchanges were generally absent; vessels changed hands through capture, recapture, and allied transfer.
- 1:08:40HMS Captain's guns and uncertain commander in 1799Notable Point
Captain had an immense gunnery advantage over Alerte, while surviving command dates identify Richard Strachan as the probable captain in the June 1799 chase.
- 1:11:07QuestionIf Bismarck had struck her colors, would the crew still have scuttled her before the Royal Navy could take possession?AnswerQ&A
Possibly, but a nighttime surrender could have allowed destroyers to board and secure the engineering spaces before the crew organized a scuttling attempt.
- 1:12:27QuestionWhy was the name HMS Captain not reused for a major twentieth-century warship?AnswerQ&A
The 1870 loss of the unstable turret ship HMS Captain probably made the name too closely associated with disaster to reuse.
- 1:14:08Salamine and Emerald show two kinds of cruiser careerNotable Point
The captured Spanish brig Salamine and the purpose-built British frigate Emerald contrast a repeatedly renamed prize with a heavily armed cruiser that served for four decades.
- 1:18:18Alerte and Santa Teresa return to sea as prizesNotable Point
Alerte was burned, salvaged, rebuilt, and captured again, while Santa Teresa joined the Royal Navy only months before helping pursue Perrée's squadron.
- 1:19:43QuestionWho would be preferable in command of a frigate, Thomas Cochrane or Edward Pellew?AnswerQ&A
Cochrane was probably more aggressive, but Pellew was the better frigate officer and the preferred commander.
- 1:20:04How blockade trade reduced local resistanceNotable Point
British ships blockading Cádiz obtained fresh food and laundry services from local boats, making civilian commerce part of the squadron's endurance.
- 1:22:50QuestionHow much were local civilians charging the British blockaders for laundry?AnswerQ&A
Apparently little enough that ordinary sailors as well as officers could afford the service.
- 1:23:25Blockade commerce gave civilians reasons to discourage gunfireNotable Point
Money earned from provisioning and washing British ships gave local civilians an interest in keeping shore batteries from forcing the blockade farther offshore.
- 1:25:13QuestionDid local civilians realize they were trading with the ships blockading their port?AnswerQ&A
Yes; they knew about the blockade and sustained a limited small-boat trade while the British kept more dangerous shore contact at arm's length.
- 1:27:01The official dispatch records five capturesChapter
Keith and Markham's dispatches identify the captured French frigates and brigs and assign the British ships that took possession.
- 1:30:00Evan Nepean's dispatch desk led to an imperial careerNotable Point
The Admiralty secretary who received the 1799 dispatch later served in Ireland, Bombay, Parliament, the Privy Council, and the Royal Society and left place names across the empire.
- 1:32:40Markham holds together a 28-hour pursuitChapter
Weak wind stretched the chase overnight, while Markham anticipated French evasive moves and kept his heavier squadron together.
- 1:35:33Bellona's broadside ends the first resistanceNotable Point
Two French frigates strike when Bellona closes to a quarter mile, and Courageuse yields after Centaur and Bellona bring overwhelming guns to bear.
- 1:42:29Official and commercial reports disagree on the prizesNotable Point
Lloyd's List and Markham's official return give sharply different gun and crew totals, demonstrating why even near-contemporary naval records require comparison.
- 1:44:24QuestionDid local resupply and laundry make the harbour much easier for the British squadron to blockade?AnswerQ&A
Yes; reliable supply and clean clothing reduced both logistical strain and the risk of disease disrupting the blockade.
- 1:46:39Why small cruisers underpin a fleet's real reachChapter
Fleet totals reveal that frigates and smaller cruisers supplied the surveying, scouting, communications, escort, and security work that let ships of the line operate effectively.
- 1:54:57Limited-role ships still enter dangerous watersNotable Point
Alerte's helpless encounter with HMS Captain becomes a wider lesson that small patrol and auxiliary ships need proportionate self-defense even when they cannot fight major combatants.
- 2:00:25Perrée is acquitted while Britain sorts the prizesChapter
A French court accepted the squadron's shortages and overwhelming opposition, while British reuse favoured the small brigs over the damaged frigates.
- 2:03:16QuestionWhat kind of gun armament did wartime trawlers carry for surface threats such as surfaced submarines?AnswerQ&A
One cited vessel had a six-pounder, while many World War II trawlers carried single three- or four-inch guns.
- 2:03:37Push and pull logistics trade certainty for responsivenessNotable Point
A comparison of Russian pre-planned delivery and NATO on-call supply explains why resilient logistics can conserve communications yet still send units the wrong material.
- 2:04:44QuestionDoes the case for better-armed offshore patrol vessels mean navies should recreate a sloop-like intermediate combatant?AnswerQ&A
Not necessarily; the key is giving patrol ships proportionate self-defence for prolonged and grey-zone conflicts, not changing their label or making them full frigates.
- 2:06:51QuestionWhat armament and capabilities would make sense for a future Canadian offshore patrol vessel?AnswerQ&A
Use helicopter and UAV capacity plus existing 57 mm, close-range gun, and defensive missile systems to provide self-protection with fleet-wide commonality.
- 2:10:23QuestionAfter seeing one up close, what was the biggest surprise about a Tribal-class destroyer?AnswerQ&A
Its physical size and cruiser-like profile were far more striking in person than photographs or the modest displacement difference suggested.
- 2:12:47QuestionWhy prefer a 57 mm gun for a Canadian patrol vessel and a 40 mm gun for a British one instead of adopting a different weapon such as the 76 mm?AnswerQ&A
Because those choices match systems already used or being bought by each navy, reducing separate training and logistics burdens.
- 2:13:48QuestionHow did Royal Navy supply affect French attempts to besiege defended ports?AnswerQ&A
Naval delivery kept ports supplied in large quantities, preventing the French from fully isolating them and undermining the siege.
- 2:15:03QuestionWould a United States transfer of Harpoon anti-ship missiles be useful to Ukraine?AnswerQ&A
Yes, if the missiles were delivered in usable form, because Ukraine needed additional stocks.
- 2:15:25QuestionWas the Royal Navy planning to give all five Queen Elizabeth-class battleships the same major reconstruction?AnswerQ&A
No; only part of the class was expected to receive that standard because major refits competed with new battleship construction for the same yards and resources.
- 2:23:56QuestionDid sailing frigates of the Napoleonic Wars come close to design perfection?AnswerQ&A
They were highly refined, and Hermione's reconstruction showed that several attempted modern improvements worked worse than the historical solutions.
- 2:24:34QuestionCould the Royal Canadian Navy use the Bofors 40 mm through its Type 26 and Type 31 partnership with Britain?AnswerQ&A
Potentially yes; the non-deck-penetrating mount could support a joint purchase and shared logistics with the British programme.