Q&A · 2:23:56-2:24:28

Had sailing frigates reached perfection?

Napoleonic frigates were highly refined, but Hermione's reconstruction showed that seemingly obvious modern alterations did not necessarily improve the design.

Question

Did sailing frigates of the Napoleonic Wars come close to design perfection?

Short answer

They were highly refined, and Hermione's reconstruction showed that several attempted modern improvements worked worse than the historical solutions.

Notes

Napoleonic frigates were very good and aesthetically impressive, though they had not reached perfection. Builders of the reconstructed Hermione identified features they expected to improve, only to find that some alterations failed in practice and had to be reversed. Testing the full-size reconstruction exposed interactions between hull, rig, and working practice that were less apparent from plans alone. Accumulated craft knowledge can preserve solutions that are not obvious to modern builders.