Video
A Ultimate Admiral Dreadnoughts Campaign: Building a Battle Cruiser Navy... part 4
Study A Ultimate Admiral Dreadnoughts Campaign: Building a Battle Cruiser Navy... part 4, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 21 Aug 2023, with 29 time notes. Topics include 16.5-inch Guns, Battlecruisers, Battleships.
Time notes
- 1:59Rearward fire and speed preserve an isolated battlecruiserNotable Point
An isolated Hedgehog-class battlecruiser uses maximum speed and an aft-heavy gun layout to escape a larger Japanese force without damage.
- 23:40Battlecruisers as a fast pursuit forceNotable Point
A fast battlecruiser group uses its speed, heavy guns, and crossfire to hunt a slower opponent in the intended pursuit role.
- 33:00QuestionWould public knowledge of Japan's Yamato-class construction push Russia toward greater emphasis on battleships and battlecruisers?AnswerQ&A
Probably. The scale of the Japanese ships would revive Russian concern rooted in Tsushima and the Russo-Japanese War, despite later land victories against Japan in Manchuria.
- 53:31Screens buy time in an unfavourable fightNotable Point
A difficult engagement trades escort losses against damage to enemy capital ships and the survival of the wider force.
- 1:03:50Oil and industrial capacity as campaign objectivesChapter
The American campaign targets oil-producing regions to reduce the opponent's ability to sustain and replace its fleet.
- 1:08:37Capital-ship cover makes a blockade force credibleNotable Point
A battleship joins a battlecruiser and destroyer group so an enemy battleship cannot break the local blockade on favourable terms.
- 1:14:18Using naval concentration to pressure an economyNotable Point
Warships and submarines concentrate in the North Sea to make German operations dangerous and strain the enemy economy.
- 1:22:26Why a battlecruiser should avoid a battleship escortNotable Point
A battlecruiser declines a convoy engagement because a battleship escort makes it a poor risk compared with easier prey.
- 1:24:03A destroyer screen creates an opening against capital shipsChapter
A larger battlecruiser force uses scouts and destroyers to absorb risk while seeking a favourable exchange against German battleships.
- 1:44:25QuestionAre these destroyers armed with 6-inch guns?AnswerQ&A
No. They use 4-inch guns, which are more appropriate for destroyers of the period, although some French and German designs experimented with weapons around 5.9 inches.
- 1:50:02Organising a mixed-speed battlecruiser forceNotable Point
The force is divided into fast, medium, and slow battlecruiser groups so the quickest ships can pursue while others avoid torpedoes.
- 1:56:24QuestionShould the British Army bring back the Royal Irish Rangers?AnswerQ&A
The historic identity is attractive, but reviving another regiment would worsen the administrative problem created by too many single-battalion formations.
- 1:59:32Rebuilding British forces for peer conflictChapter
A discussion of British force design contrasts adaptable intervention forces with the requirements of a costly return to peer warfare.
- 2:03:19Defence industry survives through political geographyNotable Point
British shipbuilding retains political protection because naval yards are major employers in constituencies central to the union, unlike industrial capacity discarded after shorter procurement runs.
- 2:08:02Amphibious mobility over isolated vehicle performanceNotable Point
The Boxer and US Marine Corps amphibious-carrier comparison turns on the strategic mobility each would give a British expeditionary force.
- 2:09:42British suspicion of armies and preference for naval fundingNotable Point
The English Civil War provides a long historical backdrop for Britain's greater comfort with funding navies than maintaining large standing armies.
- 2:10:39Joint command for a British expeditionary forceNotable Point
A proposed expeditionary structure assigns distinct land, amphibious, carrier, and air roles, then confronts the problem of choosing one theatre commander.
- 2:27:04QuestionAfter a German victory over France, could Germany have avoided invading Russia, consolidated Europe, and built a durable position?AnswerQ&A
Only with radically different leadership, a sustainable occupation strategy, and concessions - especially naval disarmament - likely too severe for the German system to accept.
- 2:33:31QuestionDid the Royal Navy experiment with automated small-calibre or all-angle gun systems?AnswerQ&A
Yes, but an experimental system was only worthwhile if it stayed within weight limits and proved at least as fast and reliable as trained crews.
- 2:36:49QuestionWho made the gun turrets for Royal Navy cruisers: the shipyards or the ordnance companies?AnswerQ&A
Both. Royal Navy yards could do major turret work, Vickers was a leading manufacturer, and other firms built to Vickers or Admiralty patterns.
- 2:38:29Reconstructing shipyard history across fragmented archivesNotable Point
Researchers must visit several regional and national repositories to reconstruct the history of one shipyard whose papers were scattered.
- 2:51:10Choosing 16.5-inch guns for fast capital shipsChapter
The refit programme settles on 16.5-inch guns, heavy armour, and 30-knot speed as a practical standard for the next generation of ships.
- 2:59:50A 36-knot battlecruiser refitNotable Point
A battlecruiser refit combines nine 16.5-inch guns, 36-knot speed, and unusually heavy belt and deck protection.
- 3:04:46Automation trades crew for machineryNotable Point
Warship automation can reduce crew demand, but its machinery may use up the saved weight and consume more internal space.
- 3:05:30Balancing a 61,000-ton fast battleshipChapter
A 61,000-ton campaign design shows how speed, armour, main-gun range, stability, and displacement compete inside one fast-battleship hull.
- 3:22:52Trading short-range torpedoes for refit survivabilityNotable Point
A refit drops practically unusable short-range torpedo tubes, freeing roughly 300 tons for protection and a more coherent modernization.
- 3:28:05QuestionWhat might Jackie Fisher have designed if he had modern naval CAD software and people who could use it?AnswerQ&A
Probably a very fast, powerful dreadnought: a longer, narrower hull could support roughly 24 knots and perhaps heavier 12- or 14-inch armament.
- 3:33:15Refitting or retiring an ageing battlecruiser fleetChapter
The late-game fleet review weighs costly upgrades against retirement as older battlecruisers are brought toward a 16.5-inch-gun standard.
- 3:45:50Keeping an obsolete Tiger useful at 33 knotsNotable Point
A final Tiger refit combines 33-knot speed, 16.5-inch long-range firepower, revised secondary armament, and better underwater survivability.