Q&A · 2:07:21 Leaving the Third Carrier Division behind saved tanker support but also omitted experienced aviators who could enlarge the strike.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:08:28 A third strike promised further damage, but uncertainty about the missing carriers and growing American defenses altered the risk.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:11:06 Counting only specialist repair ships misses depot and stores ships that also carried useful repair facilities.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:13:42 Britain was unlikely to retain pre-dreadnoughts, but modernized 13.5-inch dreadnoughts could still deter German raiders from attacking convoys.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:15:14 Restricting Japan's opening attacks to British and Dutch possessions would complicate Roosevelt's case but would not guarantee American neutrality.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:16:56 A lone Warspite and Tribal flotilla could threaten Yamato only by closing at night, dividing attention, and accepting severe losses.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 2:22:14 Export-oriented railways and scarce wartime shipping made it difficult to move rice internally when Bengal's food crisis struck.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:25:12 A viable Far Eastern force required carriers, fast capital ships, cruisers, destroyers, and oilers rather than battleships alone.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:29:14 The depth and speed of Japanese planning were impressive, but even a better-executed plan could only buy time against American industry.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:29:53 Whether cruise missiles can reproduce a Pearl Harbor-scale shock depends on detection, defensive depth, salvo size, range, and the attacker's ability to fire repeated waves.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:32:11 An encounter with the Japanese covering force would expose Force Z to torpedoes, but breaking through to the invasion transports could produce a massacre.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:33:59 Renown, Repulse, and Hood could fight other battlecruisers, but confined waters would strip away their ability to dictate range by speed.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:34:34 Larger facilities at Trincomalee, Darwin, and Cape Town would give British forces fallback positions and widen control of the Indian Ocean and South Atlantic.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 2:39:01 Italy and Japan suffered from poorly organized industrial systems, while Britain relied on scale and the United States combined scale with efficient expansion.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:41:21 Keeping Courageous and Glorious could enlarge early carrier strikes, reduce Mediterranean demands, and release a stronger fleet for the Indian Ocean.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:48:03 Satellites make a Pearl Harbor-style approach harder, shifting the problem toward cyberattack, spoofing, camouflage, and disguised missile platforms.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:49:08 The Jutland refight puts Horace Hood in Beatty's role and sends Jellicoe faster, more accurate reports.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:51:55 The surviving Standards were still seen as obsolete working hardware, while preservation costs competed with newer ships and postwar priorities.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 2:56:17 Even limited night damage to Japanese carriers could create difficult scouting and retaliation decisions for the Kido Butai.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Chapter · 3:04:48 The discussion distinguishes limited-war objectives from total-war aims and shows how naval action can be decisive without conquering a state.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 3:08:57 A conflict can span the globe without involving most major powers, while total war describes how societies mobilize rather than where fighting occurs.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 3:11:31 American and British carriers resemble floating towns, but their very different crew requirements reveal different designs and operating concepts.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 3:14:50 Sea power and strategic distance let island states limit some wars in ways unavailable to land powers fighting on their borders.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 3:17:37 Japan expected Germany and Italy to keep Britain busy while Pearl Harbor bought time against the United States.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 3:19:21 Sailors resisted pay cuts after divisional officers failed to convey their grievance, while outside movements later tried to claim the event.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Chapter · 3:22:14 A state can mobilize fully for its period without assigning the same share of people to armies as an industrial twentieth-century power.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 3:25:11 The Yamato class could not deter opponents effectively while Japan concealed the very capability meant to impress them.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 3:27:14 UAV controls can resemble familiar simulations, shortening basic operator training and removing stresses that accompany flight in the aircraft itself.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 3:32:01 Home dockyards could accommodate a Yamato-scale ship, while overseas constraints would drive new construction and a revised Lion design.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 3:33:35 Releasing officers on parole could save food and guards, recover friendly prisoners, and move experienced manpower to theaters where the parole terms allowed service.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Chapter · 3:37:50 The closing discussion argues that historical actors should be understood from the information and capacities available to them at the time.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Q&A · 3:43:29 By the second year of the Seven Years' War, Britain was directing government, finance, trade, and allied subsidies toward the fullest war effort its economy could sustain.
From Take 2: Pearl Harbour – A product of the Kantai Kessen Doctrine or something to do? (Live) · 12 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 0:35 A history of the Tribal, Battle, and Daring destroyer classes opens by explaining how access to archives shaped its final scope.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Chapter · 2:35 A reading on the Battle of the Barents Sea shows how Captain Robert Sherbrooke's destroyers protected convoy JW 51B through smoke, torpedo threat, and aggressive manoeuvre.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 3:44 An aside during the Barents Sea account explains how Deutschland's politically charged name influenced Hitler's caution and British targeting priorities.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 8:06 The convoy's survival provoked a German command crisis whose outcome kept surface raiders in service and tied major Royal Navy forces to northern waters.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Chapter · 8:23 The North Cape setup reveals how convoy escorts, cruisers, and Duke of York combined to trap Scharnhorst after the German destroyers lost contact.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 12:05 This account of the final North Cape action follows Fraser's radar-led interception, Duke of York's close-range fire, and the destroyer torpedo attacks that finished Scharnhorst.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 16:23 A counterfactual about heavier guns becomes a lesson in the close-range night-fighting approach shared by Bruce Fraser and Willis Lee.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 17:50 Destroying Scharnhorst reduced the German surface threat and helped free Fraser and Home Fleet units for the British Pacific Fleet.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 18:19 Well-trained general-purpose destroyers gave commanders the confidence to detach heavy ships while still protecting Arctic convoys.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 19:24 The discussion distinguishes a supported published argument from a historian's continuing wish to consult more archives and develop later research.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Chapter · 23:34 Steve Dunn's history introduces how the Royal Navy requisitioned fishing craft and converted civilian crews and working practices into wartime capability.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Chapter · 24:19 A passage from Steve Dunn's history shows how the requisitioned drifter Bracoden moved from anti-submarine net work to transport and support tasks under fire at Gallipoli.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 25:32 Fishing crews' rope-handling skills made trawlers and drifters useful balloon tenders, but a 1917 US Navy study also identified the limits of a tethered convoy lookout.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 26:16 Loch Broom's Gallipoli service traces a requisitioned trawler from troop and supply transport through casualty duties, minesweeping, and an improvised island raid.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Chapter · 29:10 Andrew Lambert's study of Julian Corbett presents strategy as a national and historical problem, not a doctrine to be copied unchanged from one country or era to another.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021
Notable Point · 31:50 Corbett's strategy emerged through War College collaboration, Whitehall relationships, clubs, and continuing revisions aimed at officers and statesmen.
From Tribals, Battles & Darings/British Trawlers & Drifters in 2 World Wars: A Book or Two To Review (36) · 11 Dec 2021