Q&A · 2:16:56-2:20:17

Warspite and Tribals would need a night ambush

A lone Warspite and Tribal flotilla could threaten Yamato only by closing at night, dividing attention, and accepting severe losses.

Question

How might HMS Warspite and a Tribal-class destroyer flotilla fight Yamato?

Short answer

They would need a close night ambush with torpedoes and attacks from several bearings, probably losing heavily even if they sank Yamato.

Notes

In daylight, HMS Warspite would face Yamato's range and firepower at a crippling disadvantage. A night action offers the British force its only plausible method: Warspite closes before opening fire while Tribal-class destroyers fan out from other bearings with guns and torpedoes. Their 4.7-inch shells would not penetrate Yamato's main armor, but they could damage exposed radar equipment, create flashes, and interfere with visual night fighting. Yamato would have to divide secondary armament between many attackers while maneuvering around torpedo tracks and answering the battleship. The British might trade Warspite and much of the flotilla for Yamato, an exchange they could accept strategically but would rather avoid. A larger force of multiple British battleships and roughly thirty-two destroyers would be the preferred match rather than this desperate ambush.