Chapter · 1:21:28 The recorded American-Japanese encounter remains undecided, illustrating design tradeoffs while leaving its eventual outcome unobserved.
From An Equitable Washington Treaty: Capital Ships with UAD (Long Patrol) · 28 Mar 2022
Notable Point · 1:22:10 A proposed British comparison substitutes nine-gun fast battleships for the slower twelve-gun American ships.
From An Equitable Washington Treaty: Capital Ships with UAD (Long Patrol) · 28 Mar 2022
Notable Point · 1:24:39 The proposed common ceiling would shift competition toward naval constructors, shipyards and efficient use of the permitted displacement.
From An Equitable Washington Treaty: Capital Ships with UAD (Long Patrol) · 28 Mar 2022
Notable Point · 1:25:49 Twenty-one American battleships allow three seven-ship squadrons and a different regional balance from a fleet of twenty.
From An Equitable Washington Treaty: Capital Ships with UAD (Long Patrol) · 28 Mar 2022
Notable Point · 1:30:14 Scaling the hypothetical fleets to twenty-one American and fourteen Japanese ships gives 252 main guns against 140.
From An Equitable Washington Treaty: Capital Ships with UAD (Long Patrol) · 28 Mar 2022
Notable Point · 1:33:08 Radar detection and prepared firing solutions change the risks of using speed to move into and out of contact.
From An Equitable Washington Treaty: Capital Ships with UAD (Long Patrol) · 28 Mar 2022
Notable Point · 1:35:49 The case for deterrence through perceived strength uses a schoolyard analogy to explain why an apparently capable opponent may discourage aggression.
From An Equitable Washington Treaty: Capital Ships with UAD (Long Patrol) · 28 Mar 2022
Notable Point · 1:41:32 Admirals James O. Richardson and Husband E. Kimmel illustrate why moving the Pacific Fleet to Hawaii could signal weakness unless reconnaissance, protection, logistics, and other support followed.
From An Equitable Washington Treaty: Capital Ships with UAD (Long Patrol) · 28 Mar 2022
Notable Point · 1:44:45 A modern non-proliferation analogy asks how arms control can restrict weapons while still sharing civilian technology and preserving security.
From An Equitable Washington Treaty: Capital Ships with UAD (Long Patrol) · 28 Mar 2022
Chapter · 1:47:12 The proposed replacement rhythm aims to preserve shipbuilding capacity and give each navy a proportionate reason to accept the settlement.
From An Equitable Washington Treaty: Capital Ships with UAD (Long Patrol) · 28 Mar 2022
Notable Point · 1:52:00 New Japanese battleships could reduce the pressure to overload cruisers, although the counterfactual still anticipates displacement misstatements.
From An Equitable Washington Treaty: Capital Ships with UAD (Long Patrol) · 28 Mar 2022
Chapter · 1:54:20 In this critique, disarmament terms that require routine evasion undermine confidence in the agreement and leave enforcement dependent on consent or force.
From An Equitable Washington Treaty: Capital Ships with UAD (Long Patrol) · 28 Mar 2022
Q&A · 4:15 The Spearfish Guppy may have resembled the Spearfish, but its airborne-early-warning role demanded a substantially redesigned airframe.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 7:57 A wartime 9.2-inch British heavy-cruiser programme could have changed which older ships survived into the post-war fleet.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 8:39 The Nelsons combined speed, armour and heavy firepower in a way that made American observers take notice even under treaty limits.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 9:43 A Brazilian two-power standard explicitly including Britain creates a self-reinforcing and potentially absurd naval arms race.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 10:46 A more integrated Fifth Battle Squadron could have given the German scouting force a much harder fight at Jutland.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 16:23 Damage evidence from a surviving Queen Mary could still have pushed the Admirals toward a post-Jutland redesign.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 17:03 Malcolm Wright's World War II camouflage books are useful references, but reconstruction artwork cannot perfectly recover shipboard paintwork.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 19:24 A treaty that capped destroyer numbers but not displacement would encourage larger fleets of smaller ships rather than restraint.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 20:04 A surviving Tiger-class cruiser offers heavy rapid-fire support at San Carlos and remains more capable than Argentina's older Belgrano.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 20:33 Successive pairs of Lion-class battleships would probably have incorporated newer designs rather than repeating the 1938 ship unchanged.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 22:16 An industrial Brazil could sustain a naval race, but Atlantic distance, American regional primacy and British diplomacy would shape the contest.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 23:30 Replacing the forward twin turret with a quadruple mount could produce the twelve-gun King George V originally desired, but only with hull redesign.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 24:55 Limiting capital-ship numbers without limiting displacement or guns would reward enormous N3-style battleships rather than restraint.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 25:54 Bismarck's size sits near a design sweet spot, while further growth makes incompatible ideas and weapons easier to add.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 29:15 Villeneuve's decision combined professional judgment, obedience to Napoleon and the need to salvage his own career.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 29:52 French destroyers reaching British ports in 1940 would begin with escort work and likely become especially valuable in the Mediterranean.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 31:09 Hood's overweight condition was inseparable from repeated post-Jutland design changes rather than a problem with one isolated component.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 33:54 Engineers preferred degaussed steel trawlers for performance, while crews valued wooden hulls that removed the need to manage magnetism.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 34:42 Retained Nelson-class tooling could support a nine-gun fast battleship on a King George V-related hull if Britain started early enough.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 36:09 Navies used creative tonnage accounting both to appear compliant and to preserve room for future ship modifications.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 37:49 Warspite's 1930s reconstruction cost nearly as much as building the ship had cost, showing the scale of capital-ship modernization.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 39:36 Germany could not conceal a Yamato-scale battleship as Japan did, so British intelligence would make it an immediate construction crisis.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Notable Point · 45:21 Capital-ship strength depends on numbers: a single ship is fragile, while larger groups create availability and resilience.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 47:42 Treaty enforcement tolerated a rough margin around declared displacement, making moderate overruns different from open repudiation.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 48:06 The survival of Prince of Wales and Repulse matters most because Admiral Tom Phillips and an existing fleet nucleus could organize reinforcements.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 51:17 A 350,000-ton battleship requires purpose-built dock construction, immense machinery and a force-structure case stronger than its spectacular gun battery.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 52:37 German plans might interest Japan, but they would not supply a capability Japanese naval architects lacked.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 53:53 The Grand Canal could move forces internally, but without a capable navy it also exposed Chinese cities to British riverine firepower.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 57:30 British ships repaired in American yards mixed imported and locally made parts, exposing incompatible measurement and engineering standards.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 59:05 Yamato's draft exceeded the Kiel Canal's depth limit, making dredging or drastic lightening necessary even if other dimensions could be managed.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 1:01:10 Swift's size was easier to exploit as part of a class, while an escort conversion would emphasize numerous twin 4-inch guns.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 1:01:58 Vanguard battleships, Tiger cruisers and Battle-class destroyers would combine modern guns, torpedoes and speed against the 1916 fleets.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 1:03:01 An early-1930s Hawkins retirement could make room for more County-class cruisers before the next major war.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 1:03:36 Completing Lexington and Saratoga as battlecruisers shifts carrier conversion to later hulls and creates two fast mixed task groups.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 1:07:52 British knowledge of Type 42 radar limitations would give Buccaneer electronic-warfare crews a strong route to the Argentine carrier.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022
Q&A · 1:08:53 Elswick's recurring role in British naval ordnance makes it the likely home of a 15-inch/45-calibre gun project.
From Bruships: A Special - Questions/What ifs till the Bru runs out? (11) · 27 Mar 2022