Video
Fisher's Furious Flying off Ships: Courageous Class built as Aircraft Carriers
Study Fisher's Furious Flying off Ships: Courageous Class built as Aircraft Carriers, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 27 Jun 2024, with 19 time notes. Topics include Alternate History, Baltic Sea Strategy, Battlecruisers.
Time notes
- 0:38Fisher turns the Courageous class into carriersChapter
The opening frames a counterfactual where Fisher's Courageous-class ships become full fleet carriers rather than large light cruisers.
- 7:51Tsingtao and the case for naval air strikeNotable Point
The Tsingtao air attack and Royal Naval Air Service torpedo work give Fisher a plausible reason to back carrier strike ships.
- 12:24A fast carrier with a large strike air groupChapter
The design sketch combines Hermes and Eagle ideas with a battlecruiser-sized hull to create a fast carrier built around reconnaissance and torpedo strike.
- 20:22A Renown-sized carrier designed for a dash attackNotable Point
A larger Renown-derived hull could trade heavy guns and armor for roughly 90 aircraft, high speed, and reconnaissance support for North Sea or Baltic operations.
- 24:24How quickly could Fisher build the carriers?Notable Point
The construction discussion weighs how many carriers Fisher might order, how fast they could complete, and whether suitable aircraft could be ready.
- 30:59What an early purpose-built flight deck could get wrongNotable Point
The first carriers would combine a useful island and efficient funnel arrangement with immature lifts, deck shaping, launch gear, and aircraft-handling practice.
- 35:39Carrier strike against WilhelmshavenChapter
A post-Jutland carrier force could launch mass torpedo strikes at ships in Wilhelmshaven, forcing Germany to rethink harbor safety.
- 42:46Carrier aviation makes the Baltic plan less impossibleNotable Point
The Baltic plan looks different when aircraft can attack over islands, strike Kiel Canal concentrations, and help neutralize mine and submarine barriers.
- 47:49Minesweeping, Denmark, and the route into the BalticChapter
The revised Baltic operation uses expendable mine-clearing ships, Danish geography, carrier strikes, and anti-submarine work after the German fleet has already been weakened.
- 53:47Fisher's Baltic idea needed a real staff systemNotable Point
The strategic aim of severing Germany's Baltic imports could be powerful, but Fisher's personal working style was poorly suited to the information and coordination demands of modern war.
- 59:19A carrier-heavy Royal Navy changes the postwar settlementChapter
Successful wartime strikes could turn Hood's sisters into carriers and leave the Royal Navy with several distinct carrier types in service or under construction.
- 1:05:26Combat-proven carriers protect naval aviation from the RAF mergerNotable Point
If carrier squadrons have already shaped operations, Royal Navy leaders have a much stronger case for retaining them when the Royal Air Force is created.
- 1:07:10A mature carrier fleet breaks Washington treaty arithmeticChapter
British carrier tonnage already approaching 300,000 tons would force negotiators to reconsider limits, exemptions, and parity before Washington-style talks even begin.
- 1:13:38Baltic blockade could end the war before American entryNotable Point
Loss of Baltic food and material imports could collapse Germany before April 1917, reducing both British debt and American leverage over the peace settlement.
- 1:15:31Treaties may invent three carrier categories earlyNotable Point
Negotiators might distinguish fleet, light-fleet, and cruiser carriers to preserve British wartime ships while setting usable limits for future construction.
- 1:19:23Carrier categories spill into battlecruiser limitsNotable Point
Separate fleet-carrier categories could prompt negotiators to create distinct battlecruiser and battleship allowances around ships such as Hood and the Lexington class.
- 1:21:05Admiral-class hulls favor hangars, islands, and perhaps deck-edge liftsNotable Point
Converting Hood's sisters avoids the difficult fast-battleship redesign and redirects their volume toward aircraft support, speed, and deck handling.
- 1:24:28A 35,000-ton carrier ceiling drives bigger battleshipsNotable Point
Allowing ten carriers of up to 35,000 tons could push capital-ship limits upward, preserve Hood, and leave Britain room for more or faster battleships.
- 1:26:18Tsingtao echoes Fisher's response to TsushimaNotable Point
The closing causal link compares a successful Tsingtao air attack with Fisher's earlier habit of using Japanese naval success at Tsushima to validate ideas he already favored.