Video
Check Campaign 23: UAD has updated & to Learn it's new ways I started another British Campaign
Study Check Campaign 23: UAD has updated & to Learn it's new ways I started another British Campaign, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 1 Jul 2024, with 26 time notes. Topics include Battleships, Cruisers, Force Structure.
Time notes
- 1:01Why a larger gun can be the wrong upgradeNotable Point
A 17-inch gun is rejected because it offers little benefit over the preferred 16.5-inch weapon and would slow the design.
- 1:39Submarine-heavy fleet balanceNotable Point
An opening fleet comparison weighs battlecruisers, cruisers, destroyers, submarines, and active construction rates before the campaign turn begins.
- 6:44Light-cruiser gunnery and torpedo riskNotable Point
A light-cruiser action contrasts gun volume, slightly heavier enemy guns, torpedo danger, and the chance that a torpedo hit may fail.
- 13:27ASW cruisers as a submarine screenNotable Point
A submarine contact is judged unlikely to survive because several anti-submarine cruisers are screening the target area.
- 14:23Weather, radar, and crew quality in a capital-ship duelChapter
A close capital-ship action compares gun numbers, speed, armor, weather-limited spotting, radar, and crew experience rather than reducing the result to caliber alone.
- 21:48Why veteran crews can justify modernizationNotable Point
The close result leads to an argument for upgrading proven ships so that highly trained crews remain in service rather than being discarded with an older hull.
- 40:09Cruiser building and turret-weight cautionNotable Point
A construction review covers incoming cruisers and battleships, then warns that quad turrets may overload or distort a hull design.
- 49:16Why every available turret is a logistics trapNotable Point
A joke about mounting every available turret becomes a warning about ammunition supply, engineering complexity, training, and operating manuals.
- 55:24Naval industry beyond maximum yard sizeNotable Point
A critique of the campaign's economic model asks for separate investment in welding, yards, and national construction capacity, especially for minor powers.
- 58:14What HMS Furious reveals about 18-inch-gun limitsNotable Point
HMS Furious is used to explain why a light-cruiser-sized hull could not absorb the weight and firing stresses of a twin 18-inch battleship turret.
- 58:49QuestionDid the Royal Navy conduct a full test of the intended 18-inch/45 gun?AnswerQ&A
The surviving evidence located so far does not document the full test, but the guns' installation and firing tables strongly imply that testing occurred.
- 1:01:13Secret warship projects and the limits of surviving archivesNotable Point
A discussion of a secret 1914 warship project and dual-island carrier files explains why classification history, compartmented knowledge, and weeded private papers can leave major gaps in naval archives.
- 1:10:34QuestionCould the fleet undergo a Fisher-style pruning of its old warships?AnswerQ&A
Not in this campaign: a global empire still needs distributed presence ships, invasion tonnage, and older hulls that can absorb secondary combat demands.
- 1:26:30Mine and blockade research choicesNotable Point
A research-choice moment weighs naval blockade tactics against better mines, with magnetic mines and advanced mines standing out.
- 1:30:53Capital-ship overmatch and unfair fightsNotable Point
A battlecruiser with 17.7-inch guns is outmatched by massed 16.5-inch fire, showing why concentration can matter more than single-ship size.
- 1:45:37Battenberg's resignation and factional naval politicsNotable Point
A discussion of Prince Louis of Battenberg challenges retrospective claims about public hostility and emphasizes the factional breakdown that preceded his resignation as First Sea Lord.
- 1:56:29Warhammer 40,000 and crisis command designNotable Point
A critique of the post-Heresy Imperium asks how decentralized forces coordinate, select crisis commanders, and reconnect after communications collapse.
- 2:16:36Warhammer 40,000 logistics and resilient reservesNotable Point
Gene-seed backups, stasis reserves, and local manufacturing provide redundancy when central logistics are unreliable.
- 2:25:43QuestionWhat happened to an MP who brought the royal family into a House of Commons debate?AnswerQ&A
Invoking the royal family breached a strong constitutional convention and could endanger the MP's career while creating trouble for the entire party.
- 2:37:08British and American battleship caliber stepsNotable Point
British half-inch caliber increments are contrasted with larger American steps as different ways to manage gun development and the qualitative battleship race.
- 2:45:3718-inch guns and a Washington Treaty counterfactualChapter
A counterfactual asks whether a British 18-inch battleship would have made a 16-inch Washington Naval Treaty limit politically and strategically untenable.
- 2:50:28British drug regulation and the limits of American soft powerNotable Point
A general-history discussion traces British narcotics controls from prewar international action through wartime regulation and distinguishes American advocacy from coercive power after 1918.
- 2:53:34US battleships and Grand Fleet gunnery readinessNotable Point
The US Navy's arrival with the Grand Fleet shows how budgets, training time, and institutional practice determine whether capable ships are combat-ready.
- 2:59:48Britain's wartime finance and layered postwar shocksChapter
Britain's decline is presented as the cumulative result of imperial war finance, the loss of Malayan earnings, abrupt Lend-Lease cancellation, physical damage, and cautious use of Marshall Aid.
- 3:08:25Refitting an obsolete battleship under weight constraintsChapter
A long refit sequence keeps an obsolete hull in service by balancing radar, armor, automatic secondary guns, main-battery layout, stability, weight, and dockyard time.
- 3:36:07QuestionDoes being more technologically advanced always keep a system useful for longer?AnswerQ&A
No. A mature technology can outperform its early replacement while still having less long-term development potential.