Video
Bruships 82: New Books, Fun Books & Random Books
Study Bruships 82: New Books, Fun Books & Random Books, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 24 Jul 2022, with 42 time notes. Topics include Historical Method, Live Q&A, Military History Books.
Time notes
- 1:52QuestionWhat should we make of a website claiming to have discovered a wreck without publishing images or sonar scans?AnswerQ&A
Ask for the evidence; a claim cannot displace archival documentation until comparable supporting material is available.
- 5:12QuestionHow could CVA-01 solve the lift problem if the E-2 Hawkeye was too large?AnswerQ&A
Modify the deck-edge lift and operating arrangement; the design appears adaptable enough to handle an E-2.
- 9:50QuestionHow many battleships based on the UP.41 concept might Italy have planned and completed?AnswerQ&A
Italy might aim for four, but a three-ship batch is the more plausible completed program.
- 10:50Why UP.41's aft turret complicated the designNotable Point
The Italian concept retained an aft main turret even as all-forward batteries offered a potentially simpler arrangement.
- 12:40QuestionWhat Rolls-Royce engine might the P.139B have used if the aircraft had been made to work?AnswerQ&A
Probably a customized derivative of an available turbojet, with the choice driven by whether cruise efficiency or top speed took priority.
- 13:20QuestionWas the British Army ever large enough to conquer Russia?AnswerQ&A
No; Britain could undertake limited operations or exploit a civil war, but that is very different from fielding an army able to take Russia.
- 17:08QuestionHow large would an Italian 18-inch-gun battleship need to be to retain the desired speed?AnswerQ&A
About Yamato size once the design also carries useful armour and the required machinery.
- 26:02QuestionWhy do most modern warships still sail at roughly 30 knots?AnswerQ&A
Going faster becomes disproportionately expensive in power, machinery volume, and total hull size.
- 31:04QuestionWhat did Type 12 frigates offer the Royal Navy and foreign operators from the late 1960s onward?AnswerQ&A
A reliable, capable platform that could be modified to suit individual navies, even if it was not the most upgradeable design.
- 36:16Why a battleship hull is denser than a battlecruiserNotable Point
Similar external dimensions can conceal very different displacement because heavy armour consumes weight and internal volume.
- 37:36QuestionIs 28 knots really the Queen Elizabeth class's maximum speed?AnswerQ&A
Probably not; the Royal Navy's use of 28 knots plus indicates that the plus sign is concealing a meaningful margin.
- 43:13QuestionHow thick was the planned armour on the N3 class?AnswerQ&A
Extremely heavy: up to about 15 inches on the belt and barbettes, with six to eight inches of deck armour and heavily protected turrets.
- 44:03QuestionCould today's large passenger ships serve in war as liners did during the world wars?AnswerQ&A
Generally not: modern cruise ships are slower and less conversion-friendly, although Queen Mary 2 is a notable possible exception.
- 44:58The teams that sampled D-Day beachesNotable Point
Clandestine beach sampling for D-Day drew on Royal Marine and Royal Navy personnel, with possible Army participation.
- 48:48A faster Nelson and Rodney under a looser treaty limitNotable Point
A few thousand extra treaty tons might have turned Nelson and Rodney into the first true fast battleships.
- 55:30QuestionWhich bodies of water are unsuitable for certain warship classes?AnswerQ&A
Exposed oceans such as the South Atlantic and broad Pacific are hard on small ships, encouraging larger hulls with better seakeeping.
- 58:39QuestionWas a test gun produced for the N3, and why does its proposed shell weight appear unusually light?AnswerQ&A
The evidence is contested; no settled answer is offered, and the subject requires further investigation.
- 1:01:39QuestionHow much must a ship's bow be strengthened when its speed increases?AnswerQ&A
Both speed and intended waters matter; a South Atlantic high-speed requirement demands more strength than the same speed in the Mediterranean.
- 1:04:21QuestionCould a government simply requisition civilian airliners for military airlift during a war?AnswerQ&A
It may have legal powers to do so, but dispersed aircraft, international ownership, and competing jurisdictions make modern requisition much less straightforward.
- 1:08:02QuestionAre stories that USS Enterprise reached 50 knots believable?AnswerQ&A
The claim is plausible in view of the carrier's eight reactors, although no documented speed trial is presented here.
- 1:10:40F-14 and Sea Harrier beyond-visual-range interceptionNotable Point
The F-14/Phoenix combination and the post-Falklands Sea Harrier illustrate two naval routes to certified beyond-visual-range interception.
- 1:14:06Operating USS Enterprise's eight-reactor plantNotable Point
Enterprise's exceptional power came with the burden of coordinating eight reactor plants whose operating chemistry could differ.
- 1:20:33The Templars at War: organization and battlefield disciplineChapter
A book tour introduces Templar heraldry and organization as practical evidence for how the military order identified and structured itself.
- 1:23:35What Templar rations reveal about military statusNotable Point
Measured allocations of meat, wine, and oil reveal both an organized supply system and the value placed on Turcopole auxiliaries.
- 1:24:20Templar alarms, banners, and battlefield disciplineNotable Point
Detailed rules for alarms, formations, banners, and charges show how the Templars controlled armed cavalry under battlefield pressure.
- 1:28:17QuestionHow complicated were late-World-War-II night carrier operations?AnswerQ&A
Very complicated: pilots needed considerable lighting to manage already difficult deck operations, exposing the carrier in the process.
- 1:30:50Burma Victory 1944 and the forgotten Allied armyChapter
Photographs and campaign narrative recover the multinational Allied fighting in Burma during 1944.
- 1:32:47The multinational Allied advance in Burma, 1944Notable Point
A campaign extract follows West African, British, Chinese, and American-directed forces through monsoon operations, Japanese resistance, and command turmoil.
- 1:37:32QuestionDid Slim's competence and later public attention improve recognition of the Fourteenth Army?AnswerQ&A
Slim's professionalism may have made the campaign less dramatic, but later publicity still did little to give the Fourteenth Army the recognition it deserves.
- 1:40:38Scale-model warships for carrier-battle reconstructionChapter
A modeling reference supports plans to reconstruct Mediterranean and Pacific carrier battles with photographable ship models.
- 1:48:53The symbolism of sinking USS AmericaNotable Point
The durability lessons from USS America are set against the political symbolism of using a nationally resonant ship name in destructive tests.
- 1:59:54The Walls of Justinian and the sixth-century Roman armyChapter
The Walls of Justinian introduces a source-rich but contested picture of the sixth-century Roman army and challenges a simple narrative of military decline.
- 2:03:54Procopius and incomplete battle evidenceNotable Point
Procopius records the troops needed for his narrative rather than supplying the complete order of battle modern historians would prefer.
- 2:07:12QuestionHow should historians read the demon imagery in Procopius's Secret History?AnswerQ&A
As imagery rather than a literal description, although this brief answer does not explain the work's full reception history.
- 2:07:35Justinian's layered military command systemNotable Point
Court armies, regional magistri militum, provincial duces, and campaign appointments formed a flexible hierarchy across the empire.
- 2:11:07QuestionDid British, French, and US carrier strike forces test themselves against one another in exercises?AnswerQ&A
Yes; examples from the 1960s and 1970s showed Buccaneers causing particular trouble by flying too low for easy radar locks.
- 2:13:04Limitanei, comitatenses, and defence in depthNotable Point
Property-holding frontier troops and regional mobile forces formed complementary layers rather than proof of an army collapsing into part-time militia.
- 2:17:43Non-Roman troops in Justinian's armyNotable Point
Huns, Lombards, and other allied formations were recruited for skills and dangerous assignments rather than simply replacing ineffective Romans.
- 2:21:08USS New York and the politics of ship namesNotable Point
A nationally charged name and World Trade Center steel give an amphibious ship political durability as well as symbolic meaning.
- 2:25:50QuestionWhich undiscovered Mediterranean wreck would you choose to search for?AnswerQ&A
The nearest Tribal-class destroyer wreck, preferably HMS Cossack.
- 2:29:18Poodles as working and war dogsNotable Point
A pet discussion sketches the poodle's older roles as a flock guardian and war dog before modern colour-focused breeding.
- 2:43:45QuestionWhat were effective firing ranges for cruiser and destroyer guns?AnswerQ&A
Roughly 18,000 yards for cruiser weapons and about 14,000 yards for 4.7-inch destroyer guns, with destroyers preferring closer action near 10,000 yards.