Video

Bruships 82: New Books, Fun Books & Random Books

Study Bruships 82: New Books, Fun Books & Random Books, a Dr. Alex Clarke video from 24 Jul 2022, with 42 time notes. Topics include Historical Method, Live Q&A, Military History Books.

Date
Runtime2:48:25
Guide points42 time notes

Time notes

  1. 1:52
    QuestionWhat should we make of a website claiming to have discovered a wreck without publishing images or sonar scans?Answer

    Ask for the evidence; a claim cannot displace archival documentation until comparable supporting material is available.

    Q&A
  2. 5:12
    QuestionHow could CVA-01 solve the lift problem if the E-2 Hawkeye was too large?Answer

    Modify the deck-edge lift and operating arrangement; the design appears adaptable enough to handle an E-2.

    Q&A
  3. 9:50
    QuestionHow many battleships based on the UP.41 concept might Italy have planned and completed?Answer

    Italy might aim for four, but a three-ship batch is the more plausible completed program.

    Q&A
  4. 10:50
    Why UP.41's aft turret complicated the design

    The Italian concept retained an aft main turret even as all-forward batteries offered a potentially simpler arrangement.

    Notable Point
  5. 12:40
    QuestionWhat Rolls-Royce engine might the P.139B have used if the aircraft had been made to work?Answer

    Probably a customized derivative of an available turbojet, with the choice driven by whether cruise efficiency or top speed took priority.

    Q&A
  6. 13:20
    QuestionWas the British Army ever large enough to conquer Russia?Answer

    No; Britain could undertake limited operations or exploit a civil war, but that is very different from fielding an army able to take Russia.

    Q&A
  7. 17:08
    QuestionHow large would an Italian 18-inch-gun battleship need to be to retain the desired speed?Answer

    About Yamato size once the design also carries useful armour and the required machinery.

    Q&A
  8. 26:02
    QuestionWhy do most modern warships still sail at roughly 30 knots?Answer

    Going faster becomes disproportionately expensive in power, machinery volume, and total hull size.

    Q&A
  9. 31:04
    QuestionWhat did Type 12 frigates offer the Royal Navy and foreign operators from the late 1960s onward?Answer

    A reliable, capable platform that could be modified to suit individual navies, even if it was not the most upgradeable design.

    Q&A
  10. 36:16
    Why a battleship hull is denser than a battlecruiser

    Similar external dimensions can conceal very different displacement because heavy armour consumes weight and internal volume.

    Notable Point
  11. 37:36
    QuestionIs 28 knots really the Queen Elizabeth class's maximum speed?Answer

    Probably not; the Royal Navy's use of 28 knots plus indicates that the plus sign is concealing a meaningful margin.

    Q&A
  12. 43:13
    QuestionHow thick was the planned armour on the N3 class?Answer

    Extremely heavy: up to about 15 inches on the belt and barbettes, with six to eight inches of deck armour and heavily protected turrets.

    Q&A
  13. 44:03
    QuestionCould today's large passenger ships serve in war as liners did during the world wars?Answer

    Generally not: modern cruise ships are slower and less conversion-friendly, although Queen Mary 2 is a notable possible exception.

    Q&A
  14. 44:58
    The teams that sampled D-Day beaches

    Clandestine beach sampling for D-Day drew on Royal Marine and Royal Navy personnel, with possible Army participation.

    Notable Point
  15. 48:48
    A faster Nelson and Rodney under a looser treaty limit

    A few thousand extra treaty tons might have turned Nelson and Rodney into the first true fast battleships.

    Notable Point
  16. 55:30
    QuestionWhich bodies of water are unsuitable for certain warship classes?Answer

    Exposed oceans such as the South Atlantic and broad Pacific are hard on small ships, encouraging larger hulls with better seakeeping.

    Q&A
  17. 58:39
    QuestionWas a test gun produced for the N3, and why does its proposed shell weight appear unusually light?Answer

    The evidence is contested; no settled answer is offered, and the subject requires further investigation.

    Q&A
  18. 1:01:39
    QuestionHow much must a ship's bow be strengthened when its speed increases?Answer

    Both speed and intended waters matter; a South Atlantic high-speed requirement demands more strength than the same speed in the Mediterranean.

    Q&A
  19. 1:04:21
    QuestionCould a government simply requisition civilian airliners for military airlift during a war?Answer

    It may have legal powers to do so, but dispersed aircraft, international ownership, and competing jurisdictions make modern requisition much less straightforward.

    Q&A
  20. 1:08:02
    QuestionAre stories that USS Enterprise reached 50 knots believable?Answer

    The claim is plausible in view of the carrier's eight reactors, although no documented speed trial is presented here.

    Q&A
  21. 1:10:40
    F-14 and Sea Harrier beyond-visual-range interception

    The F-14/Phoenix combination and the post-Falklands Sea Harrier illustrate two naval routes to certified beyond-visual-range interception.

    Notable Point
  22. 1:14:06
    Operating USS Enterprise's eight-reactor plant

    Enterprise's exceptional power came with the burden of coordinating eight reactor plants whose operating chemistry could differ.

    Notable Point
  23. 1:20:33
    The Templars at War: organization and battlefield discipline

    A book tour introduces Templar heraldry and organization as practical evidence for how the military order identified and structured itself.

    Chapter
  24. 1:23:35
    What Templar rations reveal about military status

    Measured allocations of meat, wine, and oil reveal both an organized supply system and the value placed on Turcopole auxiliaries.

    Notable Point
  25. 1:24:20
    Templar alarms, banners, and battlefield discipline

    Detailed rules for alarms, formations, banners, and charges show how the Templars controlled armed cavalry under battlefield pressure.

    Notable Point
  26. 1:28:17
    QuestionHow complicated were late-World-War-II night carrier operations?Answer

    Very complicated: pilots needed considerable lighting to manage already difficult deck operations, exposing the carrier in the process.

    Q&A
  27. 1:30:50
    Burma Victory 1944 and the forgotten Allied army

    Photographs and campaign narrative recover the multinational Allied fighting in Burma during 1944.

    Chapter
  28. 1:32:47
    The multinational Allied advance in Burma, 1944

    A campaign extract follows West African, British, Chinese, and American-directed forces through monsoon operations, Japanese resistance, and command turmoil.

    Notable Point
  29. 1:37:32
    QuestionDid Slim's competence and later public attention improve recognition of the Fourteenth Army?Answer

    Slim's professionalism may have made the campaign less dramatic, but later publicity still did little to give the Fourteenth Army the recognition it deserves.

    Q&A
  30. 1:40:38
    Scale-model warships for carrier-battle reconstruction

    A modeling reference supports plans to reconstruct Mediterranean and Pacific carrier battles with photographable ship models.

    Chapter
  31. 1:48:53
    The symbolism of sinking USS America

    The durability lessons from USS America are set against the political symbolism of using a nationally resonant ship name in destructive tests.

    Notable Point
  32. 1:59:54
    The Walls of Justinian and the sixth-century Roman army

    The Walls of Justinian introduces a source-rich but contested picture of the sixth-century Roman army and challenges a simple narrative of military decline.

    Chapter
  33. 2:03:54
    Procopius and incomplete battle evidence

    Procopius records the troops needed for his narrative rather than supplying the complete order of battle modern historians would prefer.

    Notable Point
  34. 2:07:12
    QuestionHow should historians read the demon imagery in Procopius's Secret History?Answer

    As imagery rather than a literal description, although this brief answer does not explain the work's full reception history.

    Q&A
  35. 2:07:35
    Justinian's layered military command system

    Court armies, regional magistri militum, provincial duces, and campaign appointments formed a flexible hierarchy across the empire.

    Notable Point
  36. 2:11:07
    QuestionDid British, French, and US carrier strike forces test themselves against one another in exercises?Answer

    Yes; examples from the 1960s and 1970s showed Buccaneers causing particular trouble by flying too low for easy radar locks.

    Q&A
  37. 2:13:04
    Limitanei, comitatenses, and defence in depth

    Property-holding frontier troops and regional mobile forces formed complementary layers rather than proof of an army collapsing into part-time militia.

    Notable Point
  38. 2:17:43
    Non-Roman troops in Justinian's army

    Huns, Lombards, and other allied formations were recruited for skills and dangerous assignments rather than simply replacing ineffective Romans.

    Notable Point
  39. 2:21:08
    USS New York and the politics of ship names

    A nationally charged name and World Trade Center steel give an amphibious ship political durability as well as symbolic meaning.

    Notable Point
  40. 2:25:50
    QuestionWhich undiscovered Mediterranean wreck would you choose to search for?Answer

    The nearest Tribal-class destroyer wreck, preferably HMS Cossack.

    Q&A
  41. 2:29:18
    Poodles as working and war dogs

    A pet discussion sketches the poodle's older roles as a flock guardian and war dog before modern colour-focused breeding.

    Notable Point
  42. 2:43:45
    QuestionWhat were effective firing ranges for cruiser and destroyer guns?Answer

    Roughly 18,000 yards for cruiser weapons and about 14,000 yards for 4.7-inch destroyer guns, with destroyers preferring closer action near 10,000 yards.

    Q&A