A 12-inch Lexington would have a short useful life
Reducing Lexington to 12-inch guns, even with better armour, would leave a new capital ship behind its era's preferred armament.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Complete directory
Browse all time notes.
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
Retaining or retiring Russia's large Soviet-era ships exposes the replacement problem
Retiring the Kirovs and Admiral Kuznetsov would advertise the inability to replace them, while retaining them also exposes that limitation.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
A practical ceiling for an untreatied large cruiser
The suggested cost-benefit ceiling for an unrestricted large cruiser is roughly 25,000 tons with 12-inch guns.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Kuznetsov-class sister carriers differed in dimensions
The tiny length difference is treated as measurement variation, while the added beam remains unexplained and the second carrier reflects attempts to improve the design.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
H3's six-gun battery weakened its treaty-design appeal
H3 offered speed and room for a treaty adaptation, but Royal Navy preference for at least eight or nine heavy guns counted strongly against its six-gun layout.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Renown's turrets inform the debate over the proposed Agincourt
The absence of triple 15-inch turrets from Renown and Repulse supports an 18-inch interpretation of the proposed Queen Elizabeth-class Agincourt.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Redirecting Alaska-class resources to USS Kentucky
Alaska-type ships would have been valuable earlier, but late-war resources may have produced more value by completing USS Kentucky.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Redesigning the Kuznetsov class for long service
A viable Kuznetsov-class carrier would need to be designed from the outset for decades of service, adequate propulsion, and maintainability.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
India operating six former Soviet carriers
Buying every Kiev- and Kuznetsov-class carrier would make India the world's second-largest carrier navy and transform regional planning.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Italy could answer Alaska and H-class construction
Italy's functioning maritime industry and balanced fleet program make a further battleship class more plausible than Germany's H-49 ambitions.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
A G3-sized carrier could handle twin-engine aircraft
A large British conversion could operate Mosquito-sized aircraft, but inter-service politics would be as important as deck dimensions.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
A separate 9.2-inch category leaves Britain choosing its smaller cruiser guns
In the proposed treaty system, Britain would probably pair its 9.2-inch heavy cruisers with 6-inch cruisers, with 7-inch weapons another possibility.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
A single Great Lake would make warfare more maritime
Combining the Great Lakes into one body of water would connect campaigns while encouraging sea-like battles detached from the shoreline.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Why Kirov received undersized reactors
The Soviet design began from submarine-reactor thinking and underestimated the different demands of a large surface combatant.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Sea Vixen wingtip tanks and engine changes offer doubtful gains
Wingtip tanks are rejected as an improvement, while changing engines would also require changes to the Sea Vixen's airframe.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Why a catamaran carrier complicates landings
A very wide multihull creates greater height differences across its flight deck as it moves in a seaway.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Italian and Japanese armed merchant cruisers
Their stories receive less attention because Italian raiders met British submarines and Japanese raiders often encountered full cruisers.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
A lone Vanguard would not trigger a major foreign response
A lone Vanguard would attract little alarm from Allied navies, although a class of sister ships could change their response.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Long Lance torpedoes in British destroyer night attacks
Longer-ranged weapons could support an opening salvo before British destroyers reloaded for a faster close-range attack.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Eight 16.5-inch guns offer the stronger heavy-battery choice
On a 41,000-ton battleship, the heavier eight-gun battery gains range and striking power while twelve 15-inch guns remain an attractive volume-of-fire alternative.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
A 16.5-inch treaty limit could carry G3 gun work into the Lion class
If treaties allowed 16.5-inch guns, Britain's earlier G3 turret work would provide a practical foundation for arming the later Lion class.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Britain had the beginnings of a 16-inch Mark II battery for Vanguard
Four completed 16-inch Mark II guns suggest an alternative Vanguard armament, while Nelson-class spare-barrel numbers reveal the maintenance burden behind capital-ship gunnery.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Trimaran width can magnify carrier-deck motion
A trimaran may be stable overall, yet ocean waves can create a large height difference across its exceptionally wide flight deck.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Carrier islands remain tall because direct sight still matters
Modern electronics do not remove the value of a tall island that lets crews see the bow and supervise the whole flight deck.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Battleship gun-barrel life depends on charge and powder
A rough barrel-life figure of 750 to 800 rounds hides major variation from charge strength, propellant chemistry, and inspection results.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
A larger Minotaur hull would improve the Tiger helicopter cruisers
The Tiger-class helicopter conversions were constrained above all by lack of hull volume, so a larger late-war cruiser design would help.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
The Vulcan was poorly suited to maritime patrol
The Vulcan's fuel-hungry design served high-speed strike missions rather than long, low-altitude ocean patrols.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Vanguard could dominate Falklands shore targets
A surviving Vanguard could bombard Stanley airfield and create a wide naval-gunfire umbrella around San Carlos Bay.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Audacious-class construction depended on large yards and facilities
The carriers required large construction facilities, and even suitable cruiser yards faced limits in the equipment available to complete them.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Rearming HMS Tiger with 14-inch or 15-inch guns
Tiger's existing 13.5-inch arrangements could accommodate a 14-inch adaptation, while Vanguard's 15-inch guns would require extensive reconstruction.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
A survival strategy for a 1945 U-boat captain
Survival would mean seeking an Arctic patrol area, avoiding convoys and aircraft, and using ice for concealment.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Vanguard would not guarantee Falklands deterrence
Argentina might still invade by assuming Britain would not deploy or properly maintain an old battleship, despite Vanguard's real combat power.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
A full-size 1947 Minotaur could carry four or five autoloading pairs
A full-sized postwar Minotaur hull could plausibly mount four or five twin 6-inch turrets with a similar number of twin 3-inch mounts.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Large naval guns may return under a new label
Eight-inch guns could return, with the suggested difficulty being how to present a familiar capability as a new development.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
A modern Royal Navy heavy cruiser would concentrate large guns forward
A retained heavy-cruiser tradition could produce twin autoloading 8-inch or 9.2-inch mounts forward with missile cells supporting them.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Gun choice for early JMSDF destroyers
For early JMSDF destroyers, the American 3-inch/50 suits the self-defence priority, while the British 4.5-inch gun is more versatile.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Presidential names and other US carrier-naming traditions
The comparison of British and American capital-ship names includes US presidents, other individuals and the historic name Enterprise.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Pola's isolated crew understood that disaster was approaching
The Italian cruiser's crew lost discipline after isolation and encirclement made their tactical position appear hopeless.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Treaty heavy cruisers were defined by guns and a maximum
Gun calibre identified treaty heavy cruisers, while displacement rules imposed a maximum rather than a minimum size.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Understanding the condition of Pola's crew after boarding
Understanding Pola's drunken and disorderly crew would have required time and a willingness to examine their circumstances.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Richelieu as the strongest French battleship name
Richelieu wins for the formidable historical figure behind the name and the fame the battleship itself acquired.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Alternative hull lines for British 13.5-inch-gunned ships
The proposed hull approach might produce a modest increase in speed for British 13.5-inch-gunned ships.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Fourteen 12-inch guns would push a British design to a longer hull
Accommodating fourteen heavy guns would lengthen the hull and could incidentally allow a higher speed.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Dunkerque's unlucky career and the choice of a battleship name
The question raises Dunkerque's contrasting historical associations, but the ship's bad luck leaves Richelieu as the preferred name.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Blackburn Blackburn aircraft and Béarn's lift design
A hypothetical Béarn designed around the Blackburn Blackburn would need aircraft lifts suited to that aircraft.
From Bruships 132: Questions till the Milk or Pancreas Runs Out ·
Where Britain might have placed 18-inch coastal guns
A viewer question opens a tour of the imperial bases that might have received a successful British 18-inch/45 coastal gun.
From Lexington Class: America's Battle Cruiser Dreams - KSS2 S4 Comment Response ·
Why the interwar Royal Navy inherited the Army's weakness narrative
The answer separates genuine naval personnel failures from a broader Cold War story that projected the British Army's interwar problems across all three services.
From Lexington Class: America's Battle Cruiser Dreams - KSS2 S4 Comment Response ·
Lexington as reconnaissance ship and carrier task-force guard
Rather than treating Lexington as a line-of-battle failure, the answer places her in reconnaissance, rapid-reaction, and carrier-protection roles.
From Lexington Class: America's Battle Cruiser Dreams - KSS2 S4 Comment Response ·