Naval Historywith Dr. Alex

Q&A · 2:24:15-2:24:37

Gun choice for early JMSDF destroyers

For early JMSDF destroyers, the American 3-inch/50 suits the self-defence priority, while the British 4.5-inch gun is more versatile.

Anti Aircraft WeaponsDestroyersJapan Maritime Self-Defense ForceNaval Gunnery
Watch at this timeFull video guide
Question

Would a British 4.5-inch gun have been better than the American 3-inch/50 for first-generation JMSDF destroyers?

Short answer

The 4.5-inch is more versatile, but the 3-inch/50 is the better anti-aircraft weapon and probably suits their self-defence role better.

Notes

The 4.5-inch gun is preferred as a general-purpose weapon. The 3-inch/50 is judged the better anti-aircraft weapon. On a destroyer intended primarily for self-defence, that gives the American gun the advantage. The choice depends on the expected task.