Q&A · 1:55:59 An Admiralty adviser should argue that Britain can improvise around battleship shortages more readily than it can replace canceled carrier flight decks.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 1:57:57 Reginald McKenna is the likeliest First Lord if Churchill never receives the Admiralty in 1911, because he was competent, trusted, and already held the office.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:01:32 Smaller weapons can fire for effect, but sustained support of troops ashore points toward a 4.5- or 5-inch naval gun.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:02:04 A capital-ship order could preserve a yard for World War I and leave Britain with more construction capacity.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:02:23 France is the tentative choice because of its extensive cruiser construction. No dated fleet totals are supplied.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:02:41 HMS Captain's loss confirmed a danger many naval professionals already understood and exposed their inability to stop a politically protected design.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:03:04 Without Panama the US Navy becomes two separated fleets, while without Suez Britain treats Gibraltar and Middle Eastern land routes as even more decisive.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:05:23 Continued armored-cruiser construction would place more such ships at sea and could change battles such as Coronel.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:05:53 British sea power tacitly helped enforce the Monroe Doctrine because excluding rival European powers from the Americas also served British interests.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:06:09 They demonstrated the need for numbers, while each successive class carried lessons from its predecessors.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:06:45 The Royal Navy answers to Parliament as the US Navy answers to Congress, but the political and budgetary mechanisms differ.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:07:26 An alternative treaty could preserve ratios by allowing each power a small number of new capital ships per multi-year period instead of stopping construction entirely.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:10:02 British 6-, 7.5-, and 9.2-inch cruiser choices reflected manual shell handling and senior preferences as well as lessons inherited from earlier cruisers.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:10:55 A Japan that avoided war in China could join Britain without facing the historical oil sanctions, bringing battleships and carriers into the Mediterranean struggle.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:12:49 The preferred solution is to retain Cradock and give him battlecruisers.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:13:27 The Swordfish torpedo-aiming arrangement would need modification for Barracuda or Spearfish because of their different speeds and structures.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:13:58 Fisher would probably survive his 1915 dispute only to have another rupture later, potentially removing additional senior figures before Jellicoe succeeded him.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:14:19 Those differences are treated as sufficient: the 6-inch gun fired faster, while the 8-inch gun delivered a heavier shell.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:14:43 France promoted the Suez Canal to improve access to India and offset British power, only for Britain to purchase control and turn the route to its own advantage.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:15:35 A 16.5-inch battery remains the likeliest upper step for Hood because 18-inch and still larger shells impose severe rate-of-fire and handling penalties.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:16:41 British adoption of triple turrets from Orion and Lion would not make every rival follow immediately, especially Germany.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:18:01 The Queen Elizabeth class represents the earliest practical 15-inch battleship, though a battlecruiser path might marginally advance adoption.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:19:21 The December 2023 assessment expects repeated missile and drone attacks eventually to penetrate a purely defensive response.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:19:54 Four triple 12-inch turrets cannot fit a useful 10,000-ton treaty cruiser without violating limits or sacrificing speed and protection.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:21:22 Japanese entry on Britain's side would threaten Italy with the world's largest and third-largest fleets and greatly strengthen Allied forces in the Mediterranean.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:23:22 A 10,000-ton cruiser can carry a triple 8-inch turret, but turret count and the remaining ship capabilities determine whether the design is workable.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:23:34 Japanese troops and aircraft could serve in North Africa, while the fleet reinforces the Mediterranean and Atlantic.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:25:20 No. Britain welcomed their construction and preferred others to meet the cost.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:25:33 In the World War II case, immediate US entry could bring forces to France during the phoney war and produce earlier landings in French North Africa. The World War I case receives less detail.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:26:54 It wanted their agreement but did not expect to obtain it.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:27:07 Sending most B-29s to Europe would open long-range bombing options there while slowing the Pacific war effort.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:27:20 They could simply be called the forward turret and aft turret.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:27:41 Renown-type ships look more attractive in World War II, while the Revenge-class battleships better served the Royal Navy's First World War needs.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:28:00 That is judged impractical: the turret and its supporting installation are too large and costly to treat as a simple later addition.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:28:42 The fifty transferred American destroyers were useful because they performed the escort and patrol work Britain urgently needed from them.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:31:57 The suggested explanation is that she was small enough to pass unnoticed.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:32:15 A steel with the same qualities at half the weight could support super-sized destroyers or much stronger ships of familiar dimensions.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:32:57 Extremely large; three or four triple 12-inch turrets are judged an easier design choice.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:33:43 Only slightly, because three-gun salvos would help ranging; a Renown-type ship is still preferred.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:34:00 Hood's loss is treated as an exceptionally fortunate German hit in a battle whose odds strongly favored the British force.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:35:22 Possibly, but the proposed meeting requires an extended route and unusual movements by both ships.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:35:47 The all-forward arrangement is judged slightly more useful.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:36:27 The Halifax class is the preferred Canadian warship because it is well suited to the Royal Canadian Navy's requirements.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:36:39 Circuits are a common Royal Navy exercise routine, with a designated group aboard ensuring sailors complete the work.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:37:01 Probably, according to the brief assessment.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:37:09 They offered wider operational lessons, with Renown linked to the development of the battlecruiser idea.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:37:36 British planners expected to move through the South China Sea and a chain of regional bases rather than cross the central Pacific as American fleets did.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:37:59 Britain could oppose a total building holiday by emphasizing its older fleet and the need to maintain strength across four major maritime theaters.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023