Q&A · 2:39:02 An American entry in May 1941 after a clash with Bismarck would reorient modern US ships toward the Atlantic and could make Pearl Harbor a less valuable target.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:41:35 Yes. The propulsion choice would need a corresponding support system overseas.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:41:48 T-class submarines would wait near a port or constrained channel where a Japanese carrier's route could be predicted.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:42:14 A renewed Anglo-Japanese alliance would accelerate Allied success in the Mediterranean and North Africa while making continued US neutrality politically difficult.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:43:32 A successful Italian special-forces attack on New York Harbor would transform American coastal-defense priorities.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:44:06 Canada would have a much stronger navy, with a Red Sea deployment considered likely in the December 2023 scenario.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:45:19 The earlier wording is corrected: club swingers is the Royal Navy nickname, while beaters may be older Royal Marines usage.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:47:43 The final Monmouth and additional Topaze cruisers lost priority when the Admiralty found more useful demands for the money.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:47:58 Britain fielded Duplex Drive Shermans and other specialized amphibious vehicles rather than leaving swimming tanks as an unrealized idea.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:48:27 The 9.2-inch choice follows from a suitable gun becoming available after Hawkins, rather than simply repeating late nineteenth-century armoured-cruiser practice.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:48:51 The preference is to argue for F3 and the 15-inch/50 gun because the gun and turret work could also improve existing ships.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:49:26 HMS Resolution is proposed as a more thoroughly forgotten World War II battleship than USS Indiana despite the name's long Royal Navy history.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:52:29 Japanese escorts could contribute usefully in the Atlantic if Britain supplied Asdic sets or helped retrofit the ships for Allied anti-submarine work.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:53:41 Fisher removed nine third-class torpedo cruisers because he considered other ships more useful and wanted the savings.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:54:00 Often both the propellant composition and the number of powder bags change.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:54:15 The French fleet needed more ships, more training, and far more time at sea, but those reforms still had to operate through the existing French system.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:54:40 It judged them against contemporary threats and also had other vessels available.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:55:39 Maintaining and expanding shipyards during the 1930s would let Britain exploit more of its maritime industrial potential and enter the war with more ships.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:55:53 The Admiralty expected another generation after Lion but deliberately waited for experience and foreign developments before fixing a design.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:56:22 No. The suggested preference was closer to forty of each type, driven by requirements rather than a fixed replacement ratio.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:57:17 Russia needed stronger port defenses, deeper supply stocks, better garrisons, and ships designed for reliable long-range movement before war with Japan.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:58:10 Turning the Mediterranean into an enclosed fresh-water lake would transform settlement, transport, Roman history, and the global distribution of usable water.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:59:33 The account describes mutual respect expressed through teasing and practical jokes.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 2:59:59 Without treaty definitions, the Royal Navy would have little reason to create the specific category 'heavy cruiser.'
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:01:27 The proposed pair is light cruiser for the later heavy-cruiser type and scout cruiser for the smaller category.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:01:43 Moving British Shetland into the central North Sea would create a valuable but heavily contested air and naval base that changes both world wars.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:02:30 Forty Counties, four Hawkins-class cruisers, and a comparable smaller-cruiser force would allow stronger hunting groups. Harwood could have six ships at the River Plate.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:03:23 In the counterfactual, Canaris uses his institutional access to eliminate Hitler early, supplies a political culprit, and then manages the succession.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:03:58 Domestic oil sufficient to support Britain would dramatically change both world wars.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:04:14 The Royal Navy preferred teak for decks because it was strong and hard wearing.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:04:54 An anecdote describes painting the Parachute Regiment's name under boats so it would be visible if one capsized.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:06:02 The counterfactual offers 4.7-inch, 5-inch, and 5.5-inch guns as options for a larger British destroyer without selecting one.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:06:28 Occasionally, although they were not normally part of the ships' crews.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:07:43 No Union ship could meet HMS Warrior on the open sea; the only plausible answer was an ambush in confined coastal waters that the Royal Navy would avoid.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:08:24 The December 2023 discussion connects the Royal Marines' longstanding recruitment message with an excess of applicants, while describing recruitment difficulties elsewhere in the armed forces.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:09:25 Preserving Reginald Henderson, Roger Backhouse, and Christopher Cradock would strengthen senior command. Removing Beatty, Lord Sempill, and Arthur Henderson is proposed to change leadership and treaty policy.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:16:45 Probably not; no further tactical explanation is offered.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:20:16 A continuous US cruiser-building programme during the 1910s is judged likely to have produced a better Omaha class.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:21:33 Planned gun calibers show a Royal Navy designing distinct ship types for global duties and possible future opponents.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:23:22 An earlier practical torpedo would accelerate torpedo craft and the destroyers built to counter them, pushing both types toward larger designs sooner.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:23:42 James O. Richardson is identified as the strongest alternative to Ernest King, although his return would renew a serious conflict with Roosevelt.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:24:48 An imperial nuclear-carrier programme would aim to provide dismantling facilities, possibly in India, though a plan would still need practical means of execution.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:25:44 The US Navy has administrative specialists comparable to Royal Navy writers, but British service culture gives writers a more visibly formidable reputation.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:26:49 An earlier passage could let Britain establish itself there before the United States.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:28:13 The same distinction could apply: having a plan does not ensure that disposal facilities are ready in practice.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:29:14 Far Eastern plans would use carriers to ferry RAF aircraft, then send them back for their naval air groups. That delay supports the case for Admiralty control of naval aviation.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:30:53 The Courageous class and Furious are selected as wartime failures; HMS Captain is distinguished as a peacetime experiment.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023
Q&A · 3:31:12 It would have created more contacts and goodwill, without a wider political outcome being specified.
From Bruships(New Years Eve): Naval History Questions answered till the Bru runs out! · 31 Dec 2023