Q&A · 2:12:49-2:13:21

Giving Cradock the ships needed to face von Spee

The preferred solution is to retain Cradock and give him battlecruisers.

Question

Should Britain send Beatty instead of Cradock against von Spee?

Short answer

The preferred solution is to retain Cradock and give him battlecruisers.

Notes

Cradock is judged the better commander for the proposed force. His historical problem was a shortage of ships suited to the operation. The counterfactual remedy is to supply battlecruisers rather than replace him with Beatty. His reluctance to back down is also connected to the expectations placed on Royal Navy officers.