Q&A · 2:22:08 There is no fixed speed because geometry and depth matter; roughly forty-five knots is offered only as a tentative estimate of where suppressing cavitation becomes especially difficult.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 2:25:47 A carrier needs an air-operations command system, while Aegis is built chiefly to control the escort's missile-defence battle.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 2:28:07 Britain has an interest in Irish security, but limited forces would be used first for the United Kingdom, so Ireland cannot safely depend on British protection.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Notable Point · 2:31:38 The discussion connects Britain's limited ground air defence to assumptions about fighters and allied support, then proposes sharing Aster stocks between land forces and Type 45 destroyers.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Notable Point · 2:34:14 A standing defensive capability can deter weaker attackers and make a stronger opponent spend more time and money preparing an attack.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 2:36:59 The central failure is approving necessary commitments without funding them, which creates small-batch costs, capability gaps, and expensive emergency purchases.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Notable Point · 2:42:18 A hospital example illustrates the extra cost of delaying a cheaper service while authorities decide which budget should pay for it.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Notable Point · 2:43:27 Crown Estate income goes to the government, while the Sovereign Grant and broader estimates of official royal costs are much smaller.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 2:44:51 The large amphibious ships provide a visible status and presence asset, even where smaller vessels could perform routine support work.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 2:45:26 The comparison fits their scale, but dry-docking and manoeuvrability raise basic doubts about operating such enormous ships.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 2:46:18 A sustained four-ship logistics cycle could require twelve to fifteen auxiliaries or more overall, supporting the proposed order of magnitude of a fourfold expansion.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 2:47:58 The proposed battleship already resembles a very large missile cruiser, while modern Burkes are more useful than recreating an older Ticonderoga flight.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 2:49:31 Clarke proposes a study or limited steam installation as an industrial fallback while EMALS matures, and interprets it as potential pressure on the supplier.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 2:54:48 Probably a Type 80-series project number, because the number encodes role while the completed ship could still be called a cruiser.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 2:57:13 Longer loiter time is suggested as the next priority, following earlier competition over torpedo speed.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Notable Point · 2:57:50 The British fit favours thirty-two larger strike-length cells, while Indonesia's sixty-four-cell layout favours a smaller air-defence missile.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 2:59:09 Mission, cost, and quad-packed missiles can make sixteen cells adequate, although a larger battery would offer more margin.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:00:04 Britain would build its own eighteen ships and probably several exports, although Australian and Dutch yards could compete for orders and regional maintenance.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:03:33 The principle was old, but practical microelectronics make the late 1950s or, more realistically, the 1960s the earliest useful period.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:05:19 Saint Barbara is identified, with a related association with armourers.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:05:35 The discussion speculates about administration backing and industrial lobbying; it does not establish how Congress would decide.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:06:28 The discussion offers several possible explanations for the battleship label, but establishes no single reason for congressional resistance to a new cruiser.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:07:55 It can provide presence and, if suitably equipped, anti-submarine work, but lacks its intended missile-based surface-strike capability.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:09:04 It is a plausible leading option, although its size may be marginal and the final decision remains open.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:10:16 Probably not. Command, logistics, and drone maintenance could push the vessel toward roughly 10,000 tons.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:12:08 European defence cooperation could favour the Italian weapon, which is also considered a capable gun with useful ammunition options.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:13:19 Canada would face a harder negotiation over domestic construction because the Korean offer is described as favouring ships built in South Korea.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:15:15 It is the recurring claim that surface ships or carriers are obsolete, an argument already being made for submarines in the 1890s.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:20:29 Probably, if the purchases actually happened; announcements alone would not establish the need.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:20:59 Its trained, adaptable people are the strength, while their repeated success makes dangerous under-resourcing look sustainable.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:25:47 Reconnaissance and mine-countermeasure drones are likely, with their support needs driving growth in the host ship's size and mission.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Notable Point · 3:28:04 Italy's planned 14,000 ton DDX already approaches cruiser scale, with several gun mounts and multiple VLS groups visible in the concepts.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:31:01 Multiple mounts preserve firing arcs after failures and provide a flexible middle layer of defence. Their effectiveness depends on ammunition and the threat, and the illustrated mount count remains uncertain.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:33:57 The suggested target is a small uncrewed underwater vessel, not a full-sized modern submarine.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:40:34 Possibly. A run that large would almost certainly contain variants, and some could carry the larger gun.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:41:19 F-35Bs and successor helicopters are expected to remain central. More capacity, carrier-based uncrewed wingmen, and new airborne early warning are desired, with delivery uncertain.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Notable Point · 3:42:06 A 76 mm fragmentation barrage is presented as an extra layer that can reduce the number of missiles reaching close-in weapons and decoys.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:43:46 No reliable saving could be identified before a later government funded the program and chose a design.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:44:12 Several hundred million pounds could buy a modern training and diplomatic ship with substantial accommodation, communications, and efficient power systems.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:45:55 The only explanation offered is that Pakistan can pay its bills while North Korea cannot.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Notable Point · 3:46:30 Additional mounts can preserve defensive coverage when a failure cannot be repaired at sea, though maintenance and crew demands still have to be paid for.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:54:37 A measured response could combine mobile and fixed air-defence missiles, coastal anti-ship weapons, more Typhoons, and airborne early warning.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Notable Point · 3:59:13 Carrier-based refuelling is discussed as a possible drone role for the Royal Navy, with airborne early warning offered as a warning about delayed adoption.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:59:42 It was redirected into an aerial tanker, with little visible progress over roughly five years according to the reply.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 3:59:57 Submarine fighting would probably precede carrier operations around a blockade. Mutual attacks on sensors could reduce targeting accuracy and increase the risk of nuclear escalation.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Q&A · 4:01:01 When China's government is satisfied with its size, which the answer does not expect soon.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Notable Point · 4:01:28 Visible gun mounts can communicate preparedness to non-specialists while providing redundancy, giving them a role in peacetime presence and deterrence.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026
Notable Point · 4:06:38 The Warrior-Gloire comparison illustrates an argument that size and familiar appearance can shape perceptions of naval strength alongside technical qualities.
From Bruships 255: Modern Navy & Naval History Questions Answered Live... · 16 Aug 2026