Could Australia crew an old battleship while waiting for a new one?
A request is unlikely while existing manpower shortages made another large crew difficult to provide.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Complete directory
Browse all time notes.
Explore every watch point in reverse video-date order, then in timestamp order within each video.
Three paths to a delayed world war
The three scenarios begin with a 1942 European war, a Pacific war starting first, or a coordinated German-Italian attack followed by Japanese intervention.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Would a Japanese Midway victory change the war?
It could delay the campaign, but it would not stop the later American carrier and destroyer expansion.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Could peacetime expectations favour the Bf 110?
Without combat experience, the Bf 110 could remain attractive enough on paper to receive greater emphasis.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
The Royal Navy's immediate answer to Plan Z
By 1942, British plans already provide a strong capital-ship force, while a completed Plan Z remains a much later infrastructure problem.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Tiger's design lineage leads toward the G3
The G3 battlecruiser is the closer successor in design thinking, while the Admiral and Renown classes follow different paths.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Would a delayed war be longer or shorter?
Either is possible, depending on how the war begins.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Would Britain replace King George V's guns with nine 16-inch guns?
The preferred expectation is to retain the King George V design and build Lions for the larger armament.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
How late can a European war plausibly be delayed?
The estimate puts the practical limit around 1942, already a considerable stretch for the German economy.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Could German finance and Soviet imports sustain peace until 1942?
Only under a tight set of assumptions, including close economic control and continued access to relatively cheap Soviet resources.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
What makes a delayed-war counterfactual credible?
There are many treatments, but credible versions must respect construction time, industrial capacity, and the absence of wartime production programmes.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Could German surface raiders replace U-boats?
The answer favours a combination of surface ships and submarines.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Béarn versus Graf Zeppelin
Graf Zeppelin is favoured on the strength of its air group, provided it can get that air group into action.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Later British carriers would follow Implacable
Probably not in their historical forms, because those designs reflect wartime experience that this timeline has not yet produced.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Could Italy rebuild its oil stocks before war?
Italy could rebuild some stocks after earlier campaigning, depending on political and economic choices.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Better German naval AA faces better attackers
They would improve shipboard defense, but the aircraft attacking those ships would also be more capable after three additional years of development.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Would Italy retain its rebuilt older battleships?
Probably, if Italy were still preparing for a major war.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Would diesel machinery solve Germany's fleet fuel problem?
The answer is doubtful; H-39's diesel machinery would help without making the entire programme affordable.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Would Montana trade twelve 16-inch guns for nine 18-inch guns?
The naval preference described here favours 16-inch super-heavy shells and rate of fire, although knowledge of Yamato could create pressure for 18-inch guns.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Peacetime does not supply the Luftwaffe's wartime lessons
Only if it adopted practices that historically emerged from wartime losses, since extra peacetime alone would not reveal the same training problem.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
German naval fuel estimates remain too tight
They could improve the stockpile, but German planning still appears to underestimate the inefficient fuel consumption of wartime naval operations.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Would Britain revive G3 or N3 directly?
A direct revival is unlikely, although ideas such as a 16.5-inch gun could be reconsidered.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
What was the point of a German experimental 21-inch gun?
The explanation centres on the attraction of possessing the largest gun, without a clear practical ship to carry it.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Missile ships require more than V-weapon research
It would require cooperation between the German services that the scenario does not make likely.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Dutch cruiser growth after three more years of peace
Around six could be completed, based on the ships already being built and likely to finish.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Nuclear research continues without Manhattan-scale urgency
National programmes would keep working, but peacetime research would not match the concentrated resources and urgency of the Manhattan Project.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Merchant shipping without a Liberty-ship emergency
No. Without a wartime emergency, merchant construction stays closer to normal patterns, although active shipyards could still turn out more modern merchant tonnage.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Would thirty destroyers support a much larger German fleet?
That hypothetical force would still be short of escorts.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
How could a friendly destroyer's depth charges damage a battleship?
A destroyer's charges detonating beneath a battleship after a collision provide one possible mechanism; the answer does not identify a Taffy 3 case.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Would turboprops or the Flying Pancake transform naval aviation?
They could help if made to work, but the answer is doubtful about early operational success.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Why funding alone does not create better radar
Money matters, but research also depends on trained scientists, engineers, institutions, and the capacity to turn ideas into working systems.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Would streamlined submarines develop during the longer peace?
Yes; British U- and V-type development is offered as a likely area of progress.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Would Britain still pursue the larger Implacable design?
The 27,000-ton Implacable design was already part of prewar development and remains a plausible continuation.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Why Type XXI is unlikely by 1942
Probably not, because Type XXI development depended in part on research Germany acquired through later conquests.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
A better prepared European land war
More time gives France, Britain, Poland, and smaller states more radios, vehicles, artillery, aircraft, training, and defensive preparation, while Germany retains serious logistical limits.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Stable vehicle designs help armies build and maintain larger forces
The land-war comparison links production continuity and plentiful lorries to the ability to sustain mobile operations.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
More armoured vehicles could reach smaller armies
Continued tank production and sales between partners could give smaller armies armoured formations before a delayed war.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Radios and exercises could improve French and Belgian coordination
Extra time gives communications equipment and joint training a chance to catch up with the forces being expanded.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Better Polish equipment leaves the two-front danger unresolved
Improved fighters and tanks could make Poland a harder target without removing its dangerous strategic position.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Norway becomes a test of Allied sea control
In a 1942 European war, a Norwegian operation could bring a German surface group into range of a much larger Anglo-French force with more carriers, capital ships, radar, and trained air groups.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
A delayed Pacific war starts with a newer aircraft generation
Continued aircraft development could bring a Reppu-type successor forward without the wartime pressure to concentrate on Zero production.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Four Yamatos belong to the later 1944 Pacific scenario
The four-ship estimate assumes Europe goes to war in 1942 and the Pacific conflict follows later, around 1944.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
A hypothetical sixteen-gun British answer to Yamato
One illustrative response combines sixteen 16-inch guns with a projected 30-knot speed, at a substantial cost in size and maintenance.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
An intact France makes an Italian war more difficult
If France stops the German advance, Italy faces French North African positions as well as British forces.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Continuous carrier attacks and massed strikes create different problems
The comparison emphasises repeated British attacks alongside the larger concentrated strikes favoured by Japan and the United States.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Italian yard limits leave Aquila facing a larger carrier threat
The estimate allows roughly one completed Italian carrier by 1942, while British carrier growth could support a larger harbour attack.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
A Pacific-first war creates a stronger coalition
If Japan attacks first, Britain, France, the Netherlands, and the United States begin as allies before Germany acts, while a still-intact French empire makes Malaya, Indochina, and the Philippines harder targets.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·
Why more T-class submarines remain in the Far East
Britain's T-class submarine withdrawal was gradual and driven by Mediterranean losses, so a war delayed beyond 1939 leaves more of the force in Asia as a deterrent and reserve.
From What happens if WWII took place as scheduled... after 1942? (Patreon) ·