Q&A · 40:31 Pilots generally shared rank-equivalent accommodation and messes, while receiving ready spaces needed for rapid flight-deck response.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 46:48 A nine-gun 15-inch/45 King George V could avoid main-armament delay while moving most of the battle fleet toward one shell family.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 48:27 Victoria combined very heavy protection and a powerful secondary battery with two enormous but slow-firing main guns.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 49:20 Merchant ships historically moved PT boats between theaters, while modern amphibious ships could benefit from dedicated armed escorts for their landing craft.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 51:09 The Lion program's delays reflected changing priorities and design refinement, not the absence of a workable British main battery.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 52:35 Comparing carriers by raw air-power output misses how Kiev, Invincible, Clemenceau, and Giuseppe Garibaldi served different doctrines.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 55:07 The CVV concept is defended not as a replacement for Nimitz, but as a conventional carrier that could economically remain in reserve.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:02:42 The AUKUS boat is described as a joint design whose British reactor work and Australian construction are distinct from interim Virginia-class purchases.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:06:18 A sea-control ship had to support many carrier missions while performing only one at a time, creating a difficult and inefficient hull-design problem.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:08:55 A Gearing refit could remain rational for Taiwan after hull wear and fleet economics made the same work unattractive to the United States.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:11:08 British shore batteries had not vanished, but their limited 6-inch and 4-inch armament could not reliably stop a serious German raiding force.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:13:03 The panel weighs cost and port restrictions against rapid carrier escort, electrical growth margin, and diplomatic signaling.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:22:15 A larger AV-8B-type aircraft would add useful capacity, but it would improve an established Marine Corps capability rather than create a new one.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:28:13 A first surprise raid might succeed, but repeated attacks would trigger patrols and an early British home-defense mobilization.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:29:36 Some non-European states built or acquired European-style sailing warships, but the much larger global export pattern arrived with ironclads.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Notable Point · 1:30:37 Repeated structural, engine, and avionics changes make the modern B-52 a useful example of how an old platform can retain its identity while becoming materially different.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:31:47 A second reactor refueling is technically conceivable for later Nimitz-class ships, but the condition and generation of each hull would decide whether it made sense.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:37:17 Putting the Indefatigable class's twin 12-inch turrets into the Lion arrangement improves the broadside and probably requires a longer hull.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:37:45 A peaceful transition from empire to a closely aligned Commonwealth could sustain shared CATOBAR carriers alongside smaller V/STOL aviation ships.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:48:33 Four improved Canadian battlecruisers with Town-class cruisers and Acorn-class destroyers could transform Pacific and Atlantic deployments in 1914.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:56:35 The proposed 25,000-ton fast battleship could protect itself adequately, but two Littorio-pattern triple turrets leave too little firepower for the hull.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:57:45 Missile-launch debris conflicted with flight-deck operations, while SCANFAR's ambitious ideas exceeded the maturity of its contemporary technology.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 1:59:56 The damaged turret was made safe and watertight, but Warspite did not regain a fully working four-turret main battery.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:00:34 An early return could place von Spee in command of the High Seas Fleet's scouting force, especially after a daring escape home.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:03:16 Redistributing intact German capital ships could prevent the 1922 Washington settlement and prolong competitive naval construction.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:04:17 Fjord terrain, extreme indirect angles, and the exposure of the attacking ship made surface bombardment a poor way to attack Tirpitz.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:05:42 A compact, radiation-free heat source could remove coal and oil constraints, but its strategic effect would depend on how scarce the material was.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:10:30 At Guadalcanal's extreme night-fighting ranges, even Yamato-class armor would not prevent severe damage from American battleships and cruisers.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:14:04 Modern coastal-defense ships at Narvik, Trondheim, or Oslo would force Germany to commit heavier units and face a stronger British response.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:17:10 An 18-gun, 10,000-ton cruiser would be a dangerous individual raider, but one hull could not change the war and would draw concentrated British cruiser opposition.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:20:58 Replacing Beatty requires more than removing Jellicoe, but Hood in the battlecruiser command could transform British gunnery and the opening action.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:24:55 Iowa versus Lion, King George V versus North Carolina, and Bismarck versus a treaty battleship are offered as broadly balanced gun duels.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:26:10 A much larger Invincible could carry more Sea Harriers and helicopters, making airborne early warning and the destruction of the Argentine carrier far more likely.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:31:20 Repeated development could not simply turn the subsonic Harrier into a supersonic mark; the relevant British path was the larger P.1154 fighter.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:33:08 Interwar 'automation' usually meant mechanized handling with sailors supervising sensors and controls rather than a fully unmanned loading loop.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:34:30 Britain could redirect existing 14-, 15-, and 16-inch work into a very large fast battleship, but an immediate 18-inch design and parallel Vanguard program were unrealistic.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:37:59 Six-inch weapons remain plausible for future surface combatants, but the panel sees little reason for regular naval guns to grow beyond that scale.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:38:46 A 3,000-ton destroyer ceiling produces near-postwar destroyers and pressures every larger treaty category upward.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:41:32 The panel narrows the practical choice to Trieste and the Juan Carlos I or Canberra family, with the final answer turning on how much cost the treasury will accept.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:42:29 A Japanese seizure of Spain's Pacific possessions could remove an expensive imperial burden while leaving Madrid better able to concentrate on Cuba.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:45:09 Presence is driven by political circumstances, with options ranging from visible passage to port visits and exercises with a partner's neighbor.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:47:19 The Shirane class remained a genuine destroyer design while giving Japan experience with concentrated helicopter operations.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:48:26 Direct-drive submarine diesels cannot simply be stacked across two decks to supply battleship power, but diesel-electric transmission could separate engines from shafts.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:49:59 F-35B light carriers lack the complete air group, especially airborne early warning, needed to substitute for American nuclear carriers.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:53:19 The Zumwalt hull and integrated electric architecture offer the most direct starting point for a modern nuclear-powered command cruiser.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:56:10 The Type 12-derived Van Speijk class mainly supported NATO standing, patrol, and anti-submarine commitments rather than colonial deployments.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:56:41 Aircrew generally receive the same food as their shipmates, with scheduling flexibility around long flights rather than a privileged menu.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024
Q&A · 2:58:21 A Warhammer 40,000 crossover uses John Henderson's reputation for forceful innovation to imagine new voidship and planetary-landing systems.
From Bruships 164: Is this Book life? Is this just a library?Caught in a landslide, no Kallax for safety! · 29 Sept 2024