Notable Point · 1:43:08 An altered-force simulation tests how an early hit could force Germany to choose between escape and protecting a damaged ship.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Chapter · 1:44:25 A major German defeat could cost experienced commanders as well as ships, while larger British light forces press the retreat.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 1:48:14 A depleted German scouting force could leave Britain more willing to risk fast ships in raids along the German coast.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 1:53:14 If the newer ships absorbed damage well, their performance could strengthen the case for another fast-battleship generation.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 1:54:28 A victory that prevents a Jutland-like battle could leave later navies without some of its hard-earned operational lessons.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:00:00 Greater British battlecruiser strength would trigger earlier German army opposition only if Germany spent beyond its historical naval plan.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:03:26 The question uses HMS New Zealand's wartime survival record to joke that 13.5-inch guns would make an already fortunate ship even harder to stop.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:04:47 The larger British force cannot be treated as a simple replacement pool because its first major battle would change whether and how a later Jutland occurred.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:05:54 The likely alternatives are an eight-gun 28-knot Queen Elizabeth or a longer ten-gun ship at roughly 26 knots.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 2:07:12 Improved machinery could pass into the R class and leave Renown and Repulse with eight 15-inch guns.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:13:04 Italy has the strongest incentive to accelerate the Francesco Caracciolo fast battleships if Britain demonstrates a 28-knot capital ship by 1914.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:16:21 An available triple-turret design does not make a twelve-gun Queen Elizabeth likely in this interpretation.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 2:17:31 A very fast ship with smaller guns might gain tactical freedom, but it would not satisfy the prestige demands that drove prewar capital-ship procurement.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:20:14 A decisive North Sea victory could increase British willingness to accept losses at Gallipoli without adding more capital ships.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 2:21:06 Austro-Hungarian turret arrangements could confer regional prestige without meeting Britain's different expectations as the leading maritime power.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:22:23 Germany would probably continue limited sorties until a decisive loss removed the First Scouting Group, the force needed to raid, scout, and draw Britain into traps.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:23:36 Attaching a battlecruiser squadron gives Harwich Force heavy cover but may weaken its effectiveness by displacing Commodore Tyrwhitt's command.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:25:02 Hull geometry, strength, stability, and hydrodynamics make fuselage-style length variants much harder to standardize in warship families.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:26:53 A fast-battleship starting design could change Admiral-class protection and completion, with different outcomes for the R and Renown programmes.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:31:23 A German fleet hiding after an early defeat would increase the value of carrier-supported torpedo aircraft able to reach it.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:31:49 Permanent Dominion flagships remain possible, while a fast Admiral class could encourage American replacement programmes and obstruct a treaty.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:32:19 The Royal Navy preferred a shorter 45-calibre weapon when its longer barrel life outweighed the extra range of a 50-calibre gun.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:33:22 Submarine losses would still expose underwater and low-freeboard problems even if a decisive Dogger Bank prevented Jutland.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 2:34:03 A viewer challenges whether the suggested Tiger-derived Admiral adequately addresses underwater protection.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 2:35:33 The closing clarification places the proposed Admirals after Queen Elizabeth and the R class in design ancestry.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 2:37:39 The final design estimate puts a possible 30-knot fast battleship at roughly 48,000-50,000 tons.
From Lions not Indefatigables - the Dominions chose to build 13.5in Battlecruisers prior to WWI... · 18 Dec 2025
Q&A · 4:50 Constellation went from a supposedly low-risk FREMM derivative to a heavily altered design with little commonality left.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Q&A · 10:03 The December 2025 update covers British hulls afloat, the Norwegian delivery commitment, and Australia's Mogami choice.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Q&A · 10:54 A compatibility question distinguishes allied operating relationships from shared engineering and equipment.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Q&A · 11:46 The reported 2028 launch target makes a proven cutter hull attractive, but reopening production and controlling changes remain unresolved.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Q&A · 13:52 Changed weapons and poor material readiness lead to different assessments of what Russia's Black Sea losses imply for frigates.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 15:21 Powerful American heavy frigates and numerous British patrol frigates illustrate how a navy's wider fleet determines what its smaller ships must do.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 17:07 A South Korean design transfer and container-carrying autonomous vessels offer contrasting ideas for increasing American surface-ship numbers.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Chapter · 18:15 Future task groups could use crewed frigates and destroyers to provide command, deterrence, and human presence for uncrewed wingmen.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Q&A · 20:54 The proposed division gives frigates a primary ASW role while larger destroyer sensors support area air defence.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 22:24 The Type 83's mooted tethered-drone radar shows how gaining sensor height creates difficult aviation, cable, weather, and station-keeping problems.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 24:05 Hypersonic weapons are a grave threat within the recurring historical contest between offensive innovations and new counters.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Q&A · 26:05 The notional Golden Fleet's endurance question leads to a concrete example of a carrier group losing replenishment support.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 28:31 The cutter alternative offers a buildable hull, but even that restart may leave the Navy waiting years for new frigates.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Chapter · 29:48 A conventional gun-and-VLS Zumwalt could have preserved a modern hull and avoided another disruptive return to Burke production.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 31:16 A debate over Zumwalt's 155 mm gun separates common ammunition from sharing the expensive electronics inside guided shells.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 32:19 Mercogliano contrasts the requirements of drone-threatened merchant escort with a possible long-range underwater-drone threat.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 33:17 Leadership appointments and branch identity prompt differing interpretations of surface-versus-submarine priorities.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Q&A · 34:33 The Knox and Perry comparison challenges the claim that surface frigates have lost their purpose.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 36:15 A proposed LST 100-derived landing ship program is presented as a test of whether named ownership and tightly controlled change orders can preserve a foreign design.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Chapter · 37:24 Chinese construction and British Astute and Type 45 examples connect repeated building to learning, cost, and the number of deployable ships.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Notable Point · 40:39 A class still being completed can already have lost the fabrication workers needed to start its next hull.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025
Q&A · 41:39 Offshore Patrol Cutter and fleet-tug overruns show that American construction problems extend far below the complexity of a front-line frigate.
From What the Frigates up with our Frigates? A Bilgepumps Christmas 2025 @Drachinifel& @wgowshipping · 17 Dec 2025